PL Diary: Moyes Haunted By What 'They' Think

If Moyes does continue his advancement into failure, what will be his defining moment? The moment he started using a pluralised pronoun willy-nilly, that's when...

Last Updated: 09/12/13 at 10:40 Post Comment

Latest Articles

It's The Small Things That Lose You Titles


Liverpool got the 'fear' at times on Sunday, but Vincent Kompany was there to allow the little kid to carry on sprinting. The sort of mistake that wins or loses a title race...

It's Time For The Rooney Rule Max


The argument is not that Hughton should have been kept on because of his race, but the under-representation of certain demographics must be addressed once and for all...

All Articles

Looking back at the last few cycles of top-flight English football, every great managerial failure has had a thing. One moment or decision or action that, in hindsight, acts as a handy up-sum of the whole entire and sorry mess. Roy Hodgson's Liverpool reign can be entirely understood just by gazing at that sad and sorry face-rub. Paolo di Canio kicked off about ketchup, in the process exposing himself as entirely the wrong kind of fascist. Alex McLeish had Alan Hutton.

It might well be that the world doesn't actually bother to provide such symbols, and that this is simply a consequence of the human animal's compulsion to finding shape and meaning in a random universe that hates you and wants you to die. But either way, it's how things work at the moment, and so we turn to David Moyes's faltering quest for a knighthood and wonder: what, precisely, will be his moment? This is not to say that he's bound to fail, of course. But it's best to be prepared, and nobody's here to read about Norwich.

With Moyes, there are options. It could be Marouane Fellaini, who neatly combines a large price-tag, an underwhelming start, and the lingering sense that his was a purchase driven largely by the fact that he used to play for Everton, into one large and hairy package that almost begs to be written off as a flop. It could be the ruthless purge of the backroom staff, as years of title-winning experience was jettisoned in favour of years of sitting-next-to-David-Moyes experience. Rene Meulensteen's miraculous transformation of Fulham into Champions League contenders only makes things worse on this count.

Or will it be, as we suspect, the curious tic that's developing when speaking to the media? Cast your minds back to the beginning of the season, when Jurgen Klopp and his twitchy disciples were campaigning for Shinji Kagawa's release from purgatory/the substitute's bench. When asked about his treatment of this latter-day Mandela, Moyes referred on several occasions, ambiguously, to they. "They tell me he's good." "They tell me he's a fine player." "They say he can leap tall buildings in a single bound."

Then, after Saturday's loss to Newcastle, he explained to the waiting press pack that "People would have questioned what what I was doing if I took Robin van Persie off," despite the Dutchman having played the entire game with the air of a man pondering whether 'transfer request' has a hyphen. And wondering if people had noticed his new stubble. Was this a cry for help? Or was it just stubble? It seems that Moyes is being guided in his job not just by his own instincts but by a mysterious and possibly malign other. Who is not a good manager. It is handsome stubble, mind.

This is peculiar. It's possible, of course, that there is an actual they; that Manchester United have a shadowy committee who meet in smoke-filled rooms and dispense unwanted, amateurish, knee-jerk advice on team selection and game management. Motion proposed: you can't take him off, he's Robin Van Persie! All in favour? Motion carried. Like Twitter, but with biscuits.

But more likely, we feel, is that this they is simply something in Moyes's head. A verbal manifestation of the manager's own doubts at his fitness for purpose. The second-guess, externalised and projected. It's only natural, of course; who among us has not found themselves, at some point or another, faced with a task that seems beyond our capabilities and begun to wonder what everybody else, the experts, might make of our fumbling swipes towards competence? But Moyes, being a proud man in the public eye, can't simply go back to bed and place a pillow over his head. He's trapped out there, and so he's positioned this they just over his shoulder, and now has to listen to his own doubts chirping away. That won't look good. Oooh, you shouldn't be doing that. Why on earth aren't you doing this?

Nothing is certain, of course. Just as United aren't necessarily doomed to the horror of not winning everything all the time, so Moyes needn't be defeated by his own demons. Should United buy sensibly in January, rally, finish strongly, re-secure Champions League football, and march proudly forward into a gloriously Moyes-ish future, then not only will that be a fine managerial achievement, but he'll have triumphed over this imaginary internal they that definitely wasn't simply invented by two diarists bumping up against a deadline. It'll be a human interest story. There might be a musical in it. Moyes!

And if he doesn't? Well, the knighthood might still be on. Arise, Sir David of Moyes, and accept this gong as a thank you to the service you've given a grateful nation. The people have been waiting almost twenty years for the chance to have a proper laugh at United's expense.

Andi Thomas and Alexander Netherton

You can follow Andi on Twitter here, Alexander on Twitter here, and buy last season's Diary here.

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Sky Bet

    • Retrieving latest Sky Bet odds

Most Commented

Readers' Comments


e was right to leave, but not just because of the money City were coming into. If I remember rightly he had a reasonable amount of chances to shine at City, but he never passed the bloody ball. Loads of aimless dribbles and 40 yard shots and not much else. I would say that if he had learnt to be a bit more of a team player he may have done better at City.

bright and edgy
Sturridge: Right to leave City


h! And.... has it gone in!?' Well John, it is quite literally your job to tell me, so stop phrasing it as a question.

Eye On The Experts: John Motson


an who resembles bond villain complains about spies ....brillliant

Palace deny spying accusation

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Luton Town promoted to Football League after winning Conference Premier title

Luton Town have won promotion from the Conference Premier - ending a five-year absence from the Football League.

Premier League: West Ham boss Sam Allardyce frustrated to lose lead at Arsenal

West Ham boss Sam Allardyce admitted his frustration at his side's inability to hold their lead in the loss at Arsenal.

Premier League: Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger hails importance of West Ham win

Arsene Wenger hailed the importance of Arsenal's victory over West Ham as his side came from behind to win 3-1.

Mail Box

Worried Liverpool Will Become A Selling Club

Liverpool fans in the mailbox are not too worried about sour grapes from United supporters, but one admits he's scared the Reds could end up selling their best players...

United Should Have Gone For Bruce And Hughes

A mailbox asking why United did not go for two old boys over Moyes, what Wenger's targets were for the season and whether he's had a better season than Pellegrini..?

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property