Eye On The Experts: Alan Hansen

Often regarded as yesterday's pundit, it's well to remember that he can just be bloody good sometimes. Pace. Power. Diabolical. Magnificent. It's Alan Hansen...

Last Updated: 20/12/13 at 11:18 Post Comment

Latest Articles

Football People On TV: Paul Scholes

25 comments

It's a sad thing to say, but Scholesy suffers from just being a bit plain, from not having the analysis of Neville or anger of Keane. He is Lowry's idea of a pundit...

F365's Foreign Managers Quiz - Questions

Post comment

With the stampede for Jurgen Klopp in full flow - how much do you remember about foreign managers in the Premier League?

All Articles

John Nicholson and Alan Tyers look at some of football's pundits and commentators and try to pin down what makes them good, what makes them bad, and what makes them ugly. This week it's the turn of one-time BBC titan, Alan Hansen...

Style
Legendary. His withering, one word assessments "pace" ... "power"... "diabolical"... "abysmal" have become so well-known as to form the basis of an instantly recognisable impression that even Rory Bremner can get over the line, albeit possibly with a hilarious conceit that Alan is saying these things in a satirically-imagined role as the Prime Minister. The repetition of them (since Hansen began in 1992) must run into the tens of thousands: two decades of growling the same few words week after week in exchange for millions of pounds. Possibly part of some post-modern art project? Is Alan actually in the KLF? Has always favoured the plain, often black shirt. Prone to a golf club lambswool V neck. Patterned clothing is for fops.


Special Interest
The political and social history of South Africa 1948-1994. Not really, silly. Although of course Hansen's World Cup 2010 assessment of Apartheid ("That system was obviously fundamentally flawed...but now they've got the World Cup") remains one of the (unintentionally) funniest moments of sports broadcasting of our lifetime. No, Alan likes defending. Or, rather, he likes bad defending. You know the drill.


Strengths and Weaknesses
Earlier in his career, was acute and illuminating, even rather edgy in comparison to the woolly jumper bumblers of the Coleman era. In his pomp he was the very definition of brooding and passive-aggressive. As such he was genuinely original but it's hard to escape the feeling that the game has moved on since, and of course his phasing out at the BBC bears that out. Still, on the upside: has a great, recognisable voice, speaks with real authority, doesn't waste words. Assessment that "you'll never win anything with kids" remains one of sport's most storied punditry howlers. Was also pilloried for referring to "coloured" footballers, but it seems to us that this was a generational linguistic blunder rather than anything else.


Tactical genius or tactics truck?
When minded to, does actually have that not inconsiderable gift of being able to explain why things have happened on the pitch. We once remember him dissecting a badly organized defence with an almost military precision; potentially boring, he made it thrilling. Does not give the impression of having wasted too much time on research. One World Cup 2010 moment endures in the memory: a Slovakia preview, in which Lee Dixon was enough of a girly swot to earmark Marek Hamsik as one to watch; Hansen sneered "someone's give you him", as if production of this arcane knowledge was pretty poor form and could only have come from some behind-the-scenes droid. Hamsik was the captain of Slovakia.


Leg squeezer geezer?
Likes footballers, especially keen on encouraging Alan Shearer to enthuse about how much he would have enjoyed such-and-such a cross etc. Can't imagine he especially cares for the opinions of non-footballers, indeed, we are fairly sure we once heard him say the words 'medals on the table' as a kind of alpha male assertion strategy, and of course, Alan has a lot of medals. Being Scottish precludes any touching of other men on the leg or anywhere else, except with a fist.


Bantersaurus Rex?
We imagine he'd actually be a really good laugh: bright, sparky, cutting. Very competitive at golf.


Cliché counter
As mentioned above, has developed a unique style all of his own. "If there's one thing defenders hate, that's pace." The problem with being a long-serving pundit is that you end up being a self-parody, or at least, become a well-worn practitioner in a genre you all but created for yourself. Thus, much of what we think of as football cliché is only cliché because of Alan's frequent use. So in that sense he is both an originator and a recycler.


Why does he get gigs?
Originality in punditry is rare and its reputation and consequent ripple effect is profound and long-lasting. Hansen has, for years, benefited from being one of the best at the start of the huge media expansion of football coverage. He became synonymous with TV football and though his powers slowly dimmed, the suspicion is this is due to weak production and that he could actually do much better work if properly motivated and guided.

Appearances will be curtailed now, but the revelation that he was getting £40,000 a show was, not that this is any way his fault, a bit of a low-point for the public perception of the BBC's sports department. According to the Daily Mail, he's still getting one million a year this year, and has not appeared on every MOTD.

Also worth bearing in mind that sometimes, just sometimes, he is still bloody good.

John Nicholson and Alan Tyers

See extracts from Alan's new book 'Tutenkhamen's Tracksuit: The History of Sport in 100ish Objects' here.

Check out John's new series of crime novels about a football fan, set in Middlesbrough, are here.

You can also follow Alan and Johnny on Twitter.

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

A

nd we always will love Ozil. I don't really mind if no other team can see just how brilliant he is, or if people think he is rubbish, because we know he is far from it. He is a fantastic player, and if people cannot see that it can only be a good thing, in that he will be at Arsenal for years to come, pulling the strings from behind a glass veil.

ganachus
F365's Top Ten Unheralded Players Of The Season

I

like the list and Ozil in particular does seem under appreciated when you look at his stats (an odd thing considering his fee or maybe because of it). Palace have a few and I've always thought Dwight Gayle at Palace was under rated, certainly when you look at his goals per game ratio. You can probably also add Ryan Bertrand at Saints who should be in the England team in my view.

sensiblepoolfan
F365's Top Ten Unheralded Players Of The Season

N

ew Shaun Wright Phillips, there I've said it. If any club offers stupid money we'd be stupid to say no, he's not a potential worldie by any stretch and I feel that after a few years warming the bench at city or Chelsea he'll be back at QPR smoking sheesha pipes under Harry Redknapp.

uncle monty
Sterling Case For Leaving 'Bigger' Club

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Harry Redknapp criticises Mauricio Pochettino and Tottenham

Harry Redknapp says Mauricio Pochettino "has been rescued" by the performances of Spurs' young players this season, and has criticised the club's transfer policy.

Arsenal's bid for Paulo Dybala confirmed by Palermo

Palermo president Maurizio Zamparini claims that Arsenal have made a bid for 'new Messi' Paulo Dybala.

Diego Simeone baffled by Premier League failure

Diego Simeone is baffled at the lack of cash-rich Premier League clubs in the later stages of the Champions League.

Mail Box

Brendan Rodgers Deserves Another Season...

"I am not bashing Chelsea, however..." The Mailbox takes aim at Jose Mourinho once again and under-fire Liverpool boss Brendan Rodgers "deserves another season".

Klopp Over Rodgers? Not On Your Nelly

Liverpool fans have short memories and should give Rodgers more time, while Jose's tactics and claims are getting many more in a stew. It's the afternoon Mailbox...

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company