Disallowed Goal Not Even The Worst Decision

While there was plenty of debate about whether Cheick Tiote's goal should have stood, Nick Miller thinks Mike Jones made a worse decision in Newcastle v Man City...

Last Updated: 13/01/14 at 08:57 Post Comment

Latest Articles

A Battle For The Soul Of Football

8 comments

Adam Bate was in the Santiago Bernabeu to watch Real Madrid beat Bayern Munich 1-0. It was a clash of styles that felt like far more than just a contest between two teams...

Van Gaal Would Promise A Fascinating Ride

19 comments

Should Louis van Gaal take over at Old Trafford, there seems little guarantee that he would be successful. One thing is sure, it would be an interesting and enjoyable ride...

All Articles

Ah, a good refereeing controversy. Gives you a warm fuzzy feeling inside, doesn't it? Like sharks, it feels like football fans, journalists and broadcasters might die if we stop moving - and in this instance for 'moving' read 'arguing about a contentious decision in a game of football'.

Of course, in the back and forth about whether Mike Jones was correct in deciding that Yoan Gouffran was interfering with play when Cheick Tiote's shot fizzed past his nose, it's easy to miss the real point, specifically that Alan Pardew's reaction was really funny. He was understandably angry, but nonetheless, it was funny.

You are all cordially invited to peruse the laws of the game yourself and squabble over whether Jones did in fact make the correct decision. It all seems to rest on your interpretation of whether Gouffran was interfering with an opponent, and whether you can shake the image of Gouffran interfering with Joe Hart in a non-football context.

One point though - if you watch Hart's reaction, he paused after the ball hit the net, and only started to appeal as he looked around, possibly for an excuse or an explanation as to why he didn't dive. It was a little like how wicketkeepers appeal for a leg-side catch in cricket to try and put the umpire off giving a wide. Of course, it's possible that Hart didn't dive because he knew Gouffran was there and thought he would block the ball, but that is firstly quite unlikely given the speed of the incident, and secondly not especially good goalkeeping.

The odd thing is that if the Manchester City keeper had positioned himself better, then Gouffran would clearly have been interfering. As it was, Hart was standing so close to his near post and of course didn't move - had Hart dived from a more central position and been impeded by Gouffran, the decision would have been clear.

One of the problems is not quite so much the decision itself, but how Jones arrived at it. The referee was, unusually, directly in line with the Manchester City defence, so therefore should have immediately seen that Gouffran was in an offside position. And thus, if he was offside, whether he was interfering with play. There is nothing wrong with consulting with an assistant in the interests of accuracy over speed, but if Jones was absolutely sure that the latter was true, then it was curious that he felt the need to ask his assistant. Particularly as that simply gave the impression that the final decision was reached only after some rather hearty complaints from the City players.

Still, this was the type of decision that will always provoke debate because it relies on such subjectivity. It will always be contentious because the laws are written in such a way as to rely on the referee's interpretation of what is and is not interfering with an opponent. And it's tough to see how that could change unless it is changed to Brian Clough's old maxim of 'if you're not interfering with play, what are you doing on the pitch?' It will again presumably inspire plenty of 'all we want is consistency' comments, which of course is impossible when such subjectivity is in play.

Arguably a worse decision was Jones' failure to send Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa off for a horrendous chop on Samir Nasri, a chop that forced his international colleague off with what Manuel Pellegrini described after the game as a 'very serious' injury. Of course the referee should not make such a decision on the basis of the injury, but it deserved a red card even if Nasri had gaily hopped up and carried on with the game.

Yanga-Mbiwa pulled Nasri back by his shoulder, missed with a right-footed swing, missed with a left-footed swing then finally made thumping contact with another knee-high hack. In one incident, at least two bookings and a straight red card for violent conduct. Quite why Jones only issued a yellow card is a far more baffling decision than disallowing Tiote's goal, but not the one that will get the headlines.

Nick Miller - follow him on Twitter

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Sky Bet

    • Retrieving latest Sky Bet odds

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

W

hy don't you call in Becks as well...and we will all have a lovely tea party!

kimosabi
United: Scholes helping out

M

ourinho is just a good-looking version of Allardyce (Fit Sam?). Clearly 19th century football isn't such a big deal after all?

Ezy_Rider
Chelsea Killed The Game Instead Of Playing It

S

tay put, Pep. Timothy Sherwood has this under control.

slowgraffiti
Guardiola plans Bayern stay

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Premier League: Paul Lambert plays down uncertainty over future at Aston Villa

Aston Villa manager Paul Lambert insists he "fully intends" to remain in charge of the Premier League club next season.

Premier League: Ramires banned for four matches after accepting FA charge

Chelsea midfielder Ramires will serve a four-match suspension after a charge of violent conduct went uncontested.

No contact from Manchester United says Borussia Dortmund coach Jurgen Klopp

Jurgen Klopp says he has not been approached by Manchester United to fill the managerial vacancy at Old Trafford.

Mail Box

Guardiola Is No Better Than Moyes...

At least he wasn't in Bayern's defeat to Real Madrid, says one chap in the mailbox. Plus, more excitement over Van Gaal at Man United and thoughts on FFP...

Man United Fans Excited By Van Gaal Talk

Man United fans know who they want to replace David Moyes, with Louis van Gaal the favourite to take over at Old Trafford. Plus, thoughts on Real Madrid v Bayern Munich...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property