Sherwood: Levy's Perfect Lightning Rod

Matt Stanger is perplexed by Daniel Levy escaping scrutiny at Spurs. How can Tim Sherwood be wholly to blame when his appointment was always destined to fail...

Last Updated: 01/04/14 at 08:08 Post Comment

Latest Articles

He's Solved 'The Rojo Problem' Before...

Post comment

Before the World Cup it was a nation believing that Marcos Rojo was their weak link (think G Johnson) and now it's cynicism at his £16m move. Can he prove folk wrong again?

Chambers' Poise Impresses Again

13 comments

It was a gritty result for Arsenal on a difficult night in Istanbul. Olivier Giroud struggled, but Calum Chambers again looked assured on a higher stage...

All Articles

Tim Sherwood is out of his depth. He is out of his depth tactically, he is out of his depth in terms of motivating the squad - despite what he might tell you about his 'little rants' - and he is out of his depth when it comes to dress sense. These are all things we knew a long time before Tottenham's latest embarrassing collapse on Sunday.

They are things many predicted would soon be proven back in December, when a coach with no previous management experience was handed the reins at a club with top-four ambitions. There is nothing shocking about the death of Spurs' season. In fact, the most surprising aspect of Sherwood's tenure is that he has kept the club in the top six.

But Sherwood is the perfect lightning rod. A brash, outspoken manager who, by his own admission, likes to wear his heart on his sleeve - "when I wear them". The level at which he regards his own ability has risen at a rate mirroring the amount Spurs fans wish he would leave or, at the very least, stop talking. This has been an excruciating public humiliation for supporters both on the pitch and in press conferences.

But whatever people think of Sherwood, he is not the man responsible for Spurs' failings. Sure, he's incompetent, and at times annoyingly smug, but it's hard not to feel that he's taking the blame for someone else's mistakes - specifically, the person who thought this would be a good idea in the first place.

Daniel Levy may be one of the shrewdest negotiators in the game, but the frequency at which he drives a hard bargain disguises the frequency at which he allows Spurs to lurch from one philosophy to the next. There were justifiable reasons to get rid of Harry Redknapp and adopt a new approach under Andre Villas-Boas in 2011 - and there may even have been cause to sack the Portuguese just 18 months into the job - but letting Sherwood lead £70m of new talent when Spurs were still fighting on four fronts immediately seemed a preposterous move.

Levy's escape from scrutiny has been aided by Sherwood's meltdown becoming the Spurs narrative in the second half of the campaign - exacerbated by the chairman's deliberate refusal to offer him public support. Despite awarding his rookie manager an 18-month contract after just two games in charge, Levy has left Sherwood high and dry every time he has sought clarification on his position amid rumours of the chairman pursuing Louis van Gaal. "The silence is deafening, isn't it? It's up to Daniel," said Sherwood at the start of March.

Indeed, whatever you might think of him as a man or manager, Sherwood deserves some sympathy for the club allowing his future to be the subject of relentless speculation, and there are plenty more experienced managers who would have cracked under the same pressure. While he has spent the last three months fire-fighting - mostly owing to his own tendency to spontaneously combust - Levy and the rest of the Tottenham board have been happy to sit in the shadows.

The most unforgivable aspect of this latest failure is that it was so predictable from the moment Levy installed Sherwood as Villas-Boas' replacement. From the outside it looked like guesswork, while the noises coming out of the club certainly don't suggest there is a secret plan locked away in the White Hart Lane safe. Instead, the chairman continues to gamble with Spurs' future, rather than drawing up a strategy and remaining loyal in the first signs of struggle.

When things go wrong, managers always receive the brunt of the criticism. But neither Sherwood or Villas-Boas - whose transfer policy last summer was driven by Franco Baldini - were provided with the proper framework to achieve Spurs' ambitions. Levy has been happy to propagate the myth that a new manager will provide a quick fix to Spurs' problems, but the evidence shows that simply isn't the case. The club is no longer treading water, it is falling backwards, and it is the seemingly unimpeachable Levy, not Sherwood, who is to blame.

Matt Stanger - he's on Twitter

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

O

K FIFA we're done, you can ban us now

jimmyjazz
Barcelona transfer ban upheld

A

h Daniel. I could spend hours on this subject putting the world to rights. You can even take a step back and ask why football fans (and society in general) have this need to know that something will happen before it actually does. There are times this important, when it comes to things like war, food production and natural disasters. A man you've never met changing his job? Not so much.

ajsr1982
Time To Burst The ITK Bubble

G

reat article. Hits the nail on the head. Encapsulates why I don't read tabloid newspapers anymore. The only thing worse is the 'told you so first' headline when they get lucky.

ianonabeach
Time To Burst The ITK Bubble

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Transfer news: Marco Reus said to have turned down move to Manchester United

Atletico Madrid president Enrique Cerezo has told Onda Cero that Marco Reus rejected a move to Man Utd this summer.

Transfer News: Swansea complete deal for Napoli defender Federico Fernandez

Swansea City have signed defender Federico Fernandez from Napoli for an undisclosed fee.

FIFA committee rejects Barcelona's appeal against transfer ban

Barcelona will be unable to sign new players in the next two windows after a FIFA committee upheld their transfer ban.

Mail Box

So Long And Good Luck To Nani

A Mailbox that offers best wishes to a departing hero, defends Olivier Giroud, tells us to steady on over Calum Chambers and makes some amusing predictions...

Mailbox: Feeling Sorry For Poor TC23

If there's one loser in all the machinations at Man United, it's poor TC23. We have mercifully few mails on United, but lots on Arsenal and in particular Olivier Giroud...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property