Why The Carping At Martinez Success?

Why does praise for Robero Martinez have to come with caveats about David Moyes' defence or the loan system? Is it just because he's proved us all wrong? Perhaps...

Last Updated: 11/04/14 at 08:17 Post Comment

Latest Articles

16 Conclusions: Spurs 0-3 Liverpool

39 comments

A performance to blow away doubts that this Liverpool side are bound to regress. Not when they have possibly Europe's most exciting attacking talent in Raheem Sterling...

Di Maria Fails To Spark United Improvement

38 comments

Matt Stanger saw Angel Di Maria display flashes of his talent at Turf Moor, but United's 0-0 draw against Burnley underlined that Louis van Gaal has his work cut out for him...

All Articles

Whether it's Alan Hansen suggesting that Roberto Martinez owes a massive debt to David Moyes, Adrian Durham claiming that Martinez has not actually improved the Toffees unless he reaches the Champions League or Martin Samuel unleashing his quite sizeable wrath on their exploitation of the loan market, there has been a noticeable shift from 'isn't it nice to see the little fella doing well?' to 'come on, he's not that good'.

Friendship with David Moyes (Mark Lawrenson) and good old-fashioned xenophobia (anyone who writes for the Daily Mail) are obvious motives for this slow withdrawal of credit from some quarters but perhaps the biggest factor is a reluctance to admit that Everton's success has come as a massive 'f*** you' to pre-season predictions. And nobody likes to be proved wrong.

There were those that thought Everton would collapse without the steadying hand of Moyes, there were those who thought players like Sylvain Distin and Phil Jagielka would panic at the alien concept of passing the ball and there were those (our hands are up here) who hoped the likeable Martinez would get time because clearly it would take more than one season to change an ageing and slightly stale side.

And we all - every single one of us - laughed when Bill Kenwright revealed that Martinez had promised to take Everton into the Champions League. Whatever revisionist Toffees might tell you now, those who believed he would get close to that target in one season were as rare as a pessimistic Liverpool fan. But while Everton supporters can revel in glory unexpected, some of those who are paid to know about football bitterly disparage their success simply because they did not know. It defies logic that a manager could so completely change a team's philosophy (in terms of both style and ambition) in such a short space of time. It defies logic so the aggrieved look for loopholes.

Some say he has merely built on Moyes' foundations of a solid defence as if that was a criticism, as if keeping the impressive elements of a team and making improvements elsewhere dilutes his impact; the same people don't stop to wonder why Moyes never attempted to make those same improvements himself if it was so damned easy.

Some say that borrowing players is somehow a shortcut, a cheat. They ask where Everton would be without the goals of Romelu Lukaku and the experience of Gareth Barry, as if they are the only ones to exploit a system that is available to every club, as if it takes no skill whatsoever to source, persuade and integrate a loan signing.

Some say that Martinez has inherited a clutch of youngsters, giving Moyes the credit for 'blooding' Ross Barkley (two Premier League starts last season), buying John Stones (heralded as 'one for the future' barely a year ago) and showing faith in the ever-youthful Seamus Coleman (at 25, older than seven of the players used by Martinez in the Premier League this season).

The truth is that Martinez and his Everton side have surprised us all, that the pairing of James McCarthy and Barry in midfield has been a masterstroke and that the switch from a one-dimensional 4-4-1-1 to a more fluid 4-2-3-1 has been seamless. Whether this season ends with them in fourth or fifth is immaterial - this has been a very, very pleasant surprise.

Sarah Winterburn

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

E

ven if United were to sign CR7 & Messi to play upfront, the fact remains Fletcher and Cleverly are playing in midfield. That's where the problem is. Fletcher is too slow with an awful pass, while Cleverly is simply rubbish

mrunited4life
Di Maria - A Signing of Necessity, or Opportunity?

T

hese days, these days, you can't say something racist without somebody saying that you're a racist.

tk421
'Wrong' Views Not Silenced By Shouting...

D

rop Rooney (he's so disappointing, overrated and overpaid), and play Di Maria and RVP upfront, much like the set up at the Netherlands team with Roben and RVP...

eric bush3
Di Maria - A Signing of Necessity, or Opportunity?

Latest Photos

Footer 365

England name team to face Norway and John Stones will start

John Stones has been named in England’s starting line-up for Wednesday night’s friendly against Norway.

International friendly: England v Norway preview

Team news for Wednesday's international friendly clash between England and Norway at Wembley (kick-off 8pm).

England captain Wayne Rooney 'looks chubby', says Norway's Vegard Forren

Norway defender Vegard Forren says England captain Wayne Rooney “looks a bit chubby”.

Mail Box

Reasons To Feel Positive At Spurs...

They didn't complete any big deals on deadline day, but that doesn't mean Spurs fans should be down about their hopes this season. Plus, United fans say farewelbz...

Danny Welbeck - Yes, No And Maybe

And understandably busy Mailbox with the instant reactions with those happy and sad on their club's transfer dealings. On Welbeck, Arsenal, United, Spurs and loans...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property