Show Respect; Don't Re-Write History

We should all be respectful at the passing of any human being, but Philip Cornwall is angered by suggestions that Malcolm Glazer 'led' Man United to greatness...

Last Updated: 29/05/14 at 16:00 Post Comment

Latest Articles

New Striker Not Liverpool's Priority...

12 comments

The burden on Liverpool to replace Luis Suarez's goals will be reduced if they can work out how to stop conceding them at the other end. Will Brendan learn from Mourinho?

United Can't Rely On Force Of Personality Alone

26 comments

With only two weeks to go until the start of the season, Man United still have plenty of work to do in the transfer market. It seems the enormity of the task is dawning on Van Gaal...

All Articles

"The death of Malcolm Glazer will be mourned more by some than by others," is a diplomatic way of putting it but those who lose sight of the human loss of a father by his children let themselves down. Yet nor should the fact of someone's death cause us to lose perspective regarding their life.

Sky Sports News showed a 2005 press conference at which a bashful Malcolm refused to answer questions about the recent purchase of Manchester United, at which the Tampa Bay Buccaneers owner offered "just a smile". The script continued: "Even though he wasn't closely involved, the purchase of the club certainly led to success on the field for Manchester United," which was followed by a graphic showing that in the nine seasons after the Glazer purchase, the club won five Premier Leagues, one Champions League, one Club World Cup, three League Cups and - including David Moyes's triumph against Wigan - five Community Shields.

It was a three-letter word that prompted a four-letter response, the offending term being 'led'. There is a philosophical fallacy known as post hoc ergo propter hoc - the notion that because an event happened after another it must have been caused by it. It's the kind of error that caused our ancestors to blame defeat in battle on the contents of a slaughtered animal's entrails and right after that 'led', I could see ritual sacrifice making a comeback.

That is some trophy haul in the nine seasons after Malcolm Glazer proved United really were for sale. Yet in the nine seasons ending in 2005, United also won five Premier League titles, one Champions League and one Intercontinental Cup, the Club World Cup's predecessor. Though they came up empty in their one League Cup final, they did manage two FA Cup wins instead and, alongside all that silverware, falling short in the Community Shield stakes (two rather than five) is of little consequence. The Glazer purchase did not make United successful; rather United's success enabled the Glazers to make the purchase and slowly pay for it with the club's own money.

It was inaction - leaving Sir Alex Ferguson to carry on largely as before - rather than action that was the catalyst for the trophy haul. United were trohyless in 2004 and 2005 and did look severely challenged by Roman Abramovich's largesse at Chelsea. But the instability of the oligarch's relationship with Jose Mourinho had nothing to do with United's new owners and the key figures in the club's on-the-pitch revival - Cristiano Ronaldo and Wayne Rooney - had already been signed. The first major personnel decisions the Glazers have had to make - after the retirements of Ferguson and David Gill - have been failures, a total one in the case of Moyes.

Of course, football fans - and especially those of United - know all this. And maybe even the club do. While the Buccaneers were effusive, United stuck to a low-key statement on the website, extending condolences to the family.

As the Manchester United Supporters' Trust put it on Twitter: 'In terms of the effect of the Glazer takeover - massive damage to MUFC fanbase and minus £1billion from our club.'

Some United fans will react foolishly to Glazer's death, just as some of the protests down the years have shown a frightening lack of proportion. But his passing does not alter the facts of a highly leveraged takeover that weakened rather than strengthened a football force that, under Ferguson, could only be challenged in recent years by massive injections of cash from outside the game. What the takeover 'led' to was a fracturing of the connection between an institution and a substantial part of the community that gave it life. Something that seemed in part organic became more and more synthetic.

It is the Glazer sons and daughter who have run things for the family and nothing will change with Malcolm's death. So, while a respectful attitude is appropriate for now, we should expect the entirely justified resentment to remain.

Philip Cornwall

Eloquent and elegant writing, Phil. One of the best articles I've seen on this site.
- red_ped

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

T

heyremind me of Utd's treble winning side. Swashbuckling and risk prone. We ha Jaap Stam to paper over the cracks at the back though. Not sure they have their Jaap yet.

HarryBoulton
New Striker Not Liverpool's Priority...

A

lexis Sanchez; too good for Liverpool, Stevie. :)

pires
Suarez 'too good for Arsenal'

T

he solution is to not feel sorry for any of Jabba, Gold or Sullivan. They're all deeply unpleasant and all deserve each other. If only West Ham would sign Barton and Suarez then no one would ever need to despise any other club.

spuzzell
The Strange Idea Of Sympathy For Big Sam

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Patrice Evra reveals he would have been Man Utd captain if he had stayed

Patrice Evra has revealed he would have been made captain if he had stayed at Manchester United.

Transfer news: Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers targets further signings

Liverpool boss Brendan Rodgers is hoping to further strengthen his squad ahead of the transfer deadline on September 1.

Transfer news: Jose Mourinho confirms Fernando Torres will stay at Chelsea

Chelsea manager Jose Mourinho has told Sky Sports News Fernando Torres will not be sold during this transfer window.

Mail Box

Plenty Of Reasons Why Lukaku's Worth It

The mailbox defends Everton's enormous outlay on Romelu Lukaku, while we also have mails on Spurs and Suarez. Oh, and worrying about the new magic spray...

Sterling Stuff And Other Friendly Thoughts

We have one reader reaching conclusions from last night's friendly while we have others discussing Romelu Lukaku's move to Everton. Oh and some swearing...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property