What's Wrong With Manchester City...?

Why have Manchester City been so good at home but so terrible away? We're not sure, but Nick Miller has picked out a few reasons for their inconsistency. Choose your favourite...

Last Updated: 14/11/13 at 09:35 Post Comment

Latest Articles

La Liga's Seesaw Continues With Brilliant Barca

Post comment

Another La Liga season over and Real Madrid and Barcelona are again at opposite ends of the spectrum. Things can change fast, but Messi is the current Clasico king...

Liverpool 2015 Feels Like Liverpool 2011...

Post comment

One Mailer says Benteke = Carroll, Bellamy = Milner and Clyne = Downing. Plus we have U21 Euro impatience, farewell Rio, Rafa Benitez, Milner, FIFA and title play-offs...

All Articles

What's eating Manchester City? Several people in the comments sections and the F365 Mailbox have asked what the hell is going on with Manuel Pellegrini's side, and the truth is that we barely have the first idea about why a team can beat Norwich 7-0 one week then lose to Sunderland the next.

However, we at Football365 are not called the Woodward & Bernstein of football journalism for nothing (or, actually, at all), so here are a few reasons why City might have been so utterly terrible on the road this season.


Vincent Kompany, or lack thereof
Of course, any team without their best defender is going to suffer, but Kompany is more than just that for City. Matthew Stanger covered this issue in more depth here, but in short City lack that most ephemeral of qualities - 'leadership' - when he isn't around. The news that Kompany might be out for another three weeks will have gone down like a bucket of warm spit with Pellegrini and his men, and there is talk of some fairly significant strengthening at the back in January, although it might well be a bit late by then. Of course, since Kompany has been absent for City's successes at home and present for the clusterf*ck at Aston Villa it doesn't explain things fully, but when City have needed a calming figure, the Belgian has been missing. Perhaps it's less to do with his absence, more the identity of the players that have taken his place...


Demichelis, Garcia et al
...who, frankly, have been terrible. Javi Garcia has been little short of a disaster for City since arriving in that tranche of the great unwanted, among the players signed for Roberto Mancini went he wanted someone else. He's not quite as actively destructive in midfield, but when he plays in defence...oi vey. Equally Martin Demichelis, who showed positioning as bad as his haircut in the defeat to Sunderland, allowing their attackers (and Phil Bardsley) as much space as they fancied. Even Matija Nastasic, implausibly composed in his first season, has suffered from a second campaign disrupted by injuries, in and out of the team and not able to settle as he did last season.


Joe Hart
You've seen his mistakes, you've read thousands of words on his predicament so we won't elaborate too much here, but Hart's communication calamity with Nastasic against Chelsea cost City that game and was the final straw for Pellegrini. In addition, Hart's confidence has been shot for much of the season, and the impact a jittery and jumpy goalkeeper can have on a defence cannot be understated.


Individual errors
There could be a case for City fans not getting too worked up about this bad away run because basically each game can be written-off as isolated freak results. Chelsea (Hart and Nastasic), Cardiff (Hart), Villa (a collective cranial calamity) and Sunderland (Demichelis, Richards, Milner) can all be attributed to individual errors that on another day might not have been punished, and just happened to occur in away games rather than spread across all the matches. Of course, that's fairly flimsy logic as when a thing happens a number of times it ceases to be a thing, and becomes a pattern.


No Gareth Barry, or similar
We will not be the first to put forward the idea that City should not have given Barry up quite so easily in the summer. While Yaya Toure and Fernandinho have generally performed well together, whenever Pellegrini has needed someone to screen the back four, the only options he has are Garcia and Jack Rodwell. Garcia, as we've established, has been no good, while he seems oddly reluctant to use Rodwell, who while suffering from more of the injuries that have stunted his City career, the Englishman has made just one league start and has been an unused substitute on four occasions. Someone like Barry or perhaps Nigel De Jong might have been valuable.


Deputies not performing well
City's first-choice players have in general been pretty strong, particularly the front six of Fernandinho, Toure, Samir Nasri, David Silva, Sergio Aguero and Alvaro Negredo. However, when Pellegrini has needed to rotate, the quality of his side has diminished. Garcia and Rodwell have been dealt with, James Milner has been uninspiring at best, Jesus Navas has flattered to deceive, Edin Dzeko seems to have spent more time complaining than scoring goals and Stevan Jovetic has been desperately unlucky with injuries. Football, as you know, is very much a squad game these days, and City's squad isn't performing.


Pellegrini doesn't know what he's doing
It's possible. After all, while he is highly respected and liked by those that have encountered him, he hasn't actually won very much. He has never won a title in Europe (unless you count the 2004 Intertoto Cup, which you shouldn't), and nothing at all since the Argentinean Primera Division with River Plate in 2003.

As with all things, it's probably a combination of all the above. However, pick your favourite and use that as a scapegoat. It's more fun that way.

Nick Miller - follow him on Twitter

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

S

till reckon Chelsea will go for Khedira as back up for Matic. I think it will turn out to be quite a Mourihno-y window: We'll see the squad players and youth in action pre-season, say things like well, we need not buy anybody and then the club will bid £60m for Pogba and send everybody on loan.

tk421
F365's Transfer Guide - Part One

I

would love to be a fly on the wall at the meeting between Milner and Rodgers. I don't know if flies can count, but if they can then I would be counting the number of times Rodgers used the word outstanding in his attempts to get Milner to sign.

godzilla
Reds and Arsenal chase Milner

W

ell, it wouldn't be a summer without Arsenal fans fretting over losing a key player, and United throwing their weight around and muscling in on transfer deals which are (apparently) near to completion. If we can't be entertained by the football on the pitch, let's enjoy the silly off-pitch soap opera of the transfer season. Hurrah!

CamberleyGooner
The Back To It Gossip

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Sepp Blatter announces he will resign as FIFA president

Sepp Blatter has announced he is to resign as president of FIFA and an election will be held to decide his successor.

England squad for European U21 Championship named by Gareth Southgate

England U21 head coach Gareth Southgate has revealed his final 23-man squad for the forthcoming European Championship.

FIFA secretary general Jerome Valcke was sent letter from South African FA

Sky Sports News HQ has a copy of a letter sent from the South African FA to FIFA secretary general Jerome Valcke.

Mail Box

Liverpool 2015 Feels Like Liverpool 2011...

One Mailer says Benteke = Carroll, Bellamy = Milner and Clyne = Downing. Plus we have U21 Euro impatience, farewell Rio, Rafa Benitez, Milner, FIFA and title play-offs...

Calling Carlo For Liverpool... Please

One Liverpool Mailer wants a manager who isn't starstruck by the job. Plus why Milner has now become overrated, play-offs for the title, Ronaldinho and democracy..

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company