Rodgers And Martinez: Showing Peers Up As Phonies

While other managers have been quick to speak about limitations, Brendan Rodgers and Roberto Martinez have pushed the boundaries to embarrass their peers...

Last Updated: 18/04/14 at 13:02 Post Comment

Latest Articles

Will The Laughable 'Banter' Defence Lead To Change?

3 comments

We're all laughing at the LMA's attempt to defend Malky Mackay using the phrase 'friendly text message banter' but at least we're doing something other than ignoring the issue...

Even Moyes Managed To Beat Sunderland...

2 comments

...so Louis van Gaal really needs to get his thinking cap on. Does he abandon his favourite formation to make room for Adnan Januzaj? It's also big for Arsenal's Germans and Big Sam.

All Articles


It may have been a tad overstated how united 'the neutrals' are in their hope that Liverpool win the title this year, but the current league leaders are not without their non-partisan cheerleaders. Certainly, anyone who wants to see the Premier League status quo disrupted will be willing Everton to recover fourth place by the end of play on May 11. But amidst all the admiration being poured the way of Merseyside at the moment, there is surely a small cartel who will be desperately hoping that both teams fail in their missions: the other top-flight managers. Roberto Martinez and Brendan Rodgers, by imposing upon their clubs an almost implausible level of upward mobility, are showing many of their peers up as phonies.

The success of both managers over the course of this season has been a victory for pure, old-fashioned coaching amidst a landscape where mass-recruitment is too often looked at as the default route to improvement - perhaps even the only route. Neither of the Merseyside clubs have spent money commensurate with their current league positions: Liverpool's summer business was largely characterised by missing out on their more illustrious targets, while Everton's only permanent signing of import has been James McCarthy.

Unable to simply throw cash at their problems, Merseyside's forward-thinking managers have instead concentrated on working with the tools they've already got. Jordan Henderson has been transformed from a loping and unwanted midfielder to a striding, assertive presence whose performances have grown with the occasion. Martin Skrtel, regarded by Rodgers with similar distrust last season, is now the club's dominant centre-half. Raheem Sterling and Jon Flanagan are both youngsters who, having apparently stagnated, have spent the past six months advancing at the rate of a hot rod manned by Vin Diesel.

Across Stanley Park, Seamus Coleman has gone from peripheral figure to one of the division's most thrillingly buccaneering full-backs, Gareth Barry has made mincemeat of his ever-dwindling band of critics and Steven Naismith is no longer a goal-repellent figure of fun but a predatory and sophisticated deep-lying forward. At the back, Sylvain Distin has undergone a sweltering Indian summer and John Stones has been plucked from the academy and plunged into a high-class Premier League outfit, his performances mirroring the manager's faith. Likewise Ross Barkley, whose midfield maraudings have prompted the broadsheets to draw comparisons, however premature, to both Gascoigne and Maradona.

One wonders what the league table might look like if such an approach was taken towards, say, Joleon Lescott or Demba Ba last summer. Instead, the pair spent their pre-seasons undergoing an abrupt sidelining in favour of a newly recruited, fully trusted and handsomely remunerated lieutenant of the incoming manager.

And it's not just an obvious aptitude for the day-to-day bibs-and-cones work that Martinez and Rodgers share, but also an outlook of seemingly indefatigable optimism. It can often come across as fairly trite and more than a little quixotic, these beamingly upbeat interviews week on week, regardless of the result, but the effect it's had on their respective squads is irrefutable. While managers like Arsene Wenger (and, albeit in a different context, Jose Mourinho) seem to specialise in bleakening their club's ambitions by pointing forlornly at their rivals' deeper pockets, Rodgers and Martinez have not provided their players with any excuses for failure and as a result have garnered gleeful overachievement rather than meek underperformance.

It is well-documented that Martinez swanned into his interview with Bill Kenwright and greeted his boss-in-waiting with the rather rash promise of Champions League football, and Rodgers' often hackneyed motivation-speak has spawned much mockery. But such buoyancy has surely now been vindicated. These are men whose glasses are half-full even when they've been drained of their final drop, and their almost absurdly relentless positivity has shown own up Wenger's habitual complaining about so-called 'financial doping' for what it is: pre-emptive defeatism. Mourinho's 'little horse' act has been similarly exposed as a cheap self-preservation tactic.

Which isn't, of course, to say there's no truth to such protests - any analysis of wage bills and league position will show you that there's plenty - but just that the balance sheet does not have to signify a club's be-all and end-all. And that treating it as such can simply become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

In a footballing climate where transfer business often seems the only genre of news, and players can be written off with much of their careers still ahead of them, it is refreshing to see this pair taking to the training field and shattering these glass ceilings that received wisdom tells us are so indestructible. And with the likes of Stones, Flanagan, Barkley, Henderson, Sterling and Daniel Sturridge at the heart of both projects, it may not be long before the appreciation towards the coaches' fine work extends some distance beyond Merseyside.

Alex Hess - follow him on Twitter.

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

I

recently had to complete a difficult project at work. I had to come in early, stay late. I even had to work some 7 day weeks. Anyway, long story short, I'm now a member of Britain First. Slippery slope.

sailingmagpie
Will The Laughable 'Banter' Defence Lead To Change?

C

rikey, Spain is so exotic, we have cold Tuesday nights in Stoke, they have hot Thursday nights in Eibar

Gollo
Atletico Ready For Another Title Tilt

Y

es, these stats are right. Rio Ferdinand definitely had a better debut than Fernando.

that man
Top Ten Debutants From Opening Weekend...

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Rio Ferdinand would love to manage England after his playing career ends

Rio Ferdinand would love to manage England one day after revealing his long-term plans for a future in football as a coach.

Premier League: Former Cardiff boss Malky Mackay promises to co-operate with FA

Malky Mackay says he will co-operate fully with an FA investigation into Cardiff's text message dossier.

Transfer News: Southampton goalkeeper Artur Boruc wants to move before deadline

Ronald Koeman has confirmed Southampton goalkeeper Artur Boruc has asked to move on from St Mary's.

Mail Box

Man United Fans Clutching At Straws

While the focus is on Liverpool's move for Mario Balotelli, one Man United fan tries to convince the mailbox with nine reasons why Angel Di Maria would prefer them to PSG...

Rojo Is A Better Signing Than Hummels

There's some big talk in the morning mailbox, which claims that Man United were right to sign Marcos Rojo instead of Mats Hummels. Plus, one Gooner's happy Arteta's out...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property