A Battle For The Soul Of Football

Adam Bate was in the Santiago Bernabeu to watch Real Madrid beat Bayern Munich 1-0. It was a clash of styles that felt like far more than just a contest between two teams...

Last Updated: 24/04/14 at 09:11 Post Comment

Latest Articles

This Saints Start Feels Sustainable...

Post comment

While Aston Villa look like temporary interlopers, there's something sustainable about Southampton's early-season form. Organisation is married to creativity...

Should Gerrard Play Further Forward?

Post comment

That's one shout in a mailbox that recalls Rafa Benitez saying the Liverpool man would one day end up as a striker. Plus, thoughts on Rooney and 500 words on Ipswich...

All Articles

In one sense, this was just a match between two famous clubs, one Spanish and one German. Two grand old teams of the game with so much in common. But such is the debate that's been sparked, you'd think it was a battle for the soul of football itself.

Real Madrid versus Bayern Munich. Possession against counter-attack. It was a classic match-up offering an intriguing contrast in styles. Such affairs can sometimes be one way, such as when Jose Mourino's Chelsea team not only parked the bus but stubbornly refused to get off it throughout the previous evening's game in the Spanish capital. But there was more than enough purpose and ambition to Real Madrid's breaks in the Bernabeu to ensure excitement.

Real might style themselves as 'Reyes de Europa' as the banner unfurled in the Fondo Sur prior to kick-off proudly proclaimed. But against Europe's current champions they were cast in what is perceived by some to be the emasculated role that comes with surrendering possession to the opponents - on their own turf as well.

It wasn't exactly de rigueur stuff from Europe's most successful team, still in search of that elusive tenth European crown. And certainly not from one that includes the reigning Ballon d'Or winner Cristiano Ronaldo in their ranks. Fans in Madrid come to see him with the ball at his feet, not chasing Germans.

Ronaldo, not fully fit after a three-week absence it should be noted, touched the ball just 16 times in the match - something Bayern's Toni Kroos had achieved before most of the crowd were settled into their seat. He also attempted just eight passes, completing six. Crucially however, from such limited involvement, Ronaldo still managed three shots on target in his 70-minute appearance. Tellingly, the entire Bayern team had four in the whole match.

That little statistic cuts to heart of this matter. The accepted wisdom is that possession of the ball equals control of the game. Of course, there are always exceptions that prove the rule. The Champions League itself has seen both Internazionale and Chelsea win the tournament in recent years without dominating. In the past decade, Greece have won the Euros, Uruguay triumphed in the Copa and Zambia have achieved unlikely success in the Africa Cup of Nations.

But it's not for nothing that the teams at the top of league tables the world over invariably rank fairly high in the possession standings too. The law of both averages and logic suggests retaining it makes sense. But when does possession - and Bayern had plenty of it with 71.7 per cent of the ball against Real - not equal control?

The answer it seems, is when it is as sterile as the fare served up by Pep Guardiola's side on Wednesday evening. Particularly when accompanied by unsatisfactory protection of the defence against opponents so devastatingly dangerous on the counter-attack.

With midfield dictator Bastian Schweinsteiger in an unusually advanced role, it was necessary to keep one eye on the dynamics at the other end of the pitch at all times. In more ways than one, every passing chain felt like the prelude to a 'Real' chance.

As if to highlight the absurdity of the contrast, Bayern had actually enjoyed 81 per cent possession at the precise moment Karim Benzema deposited the ball into the visitors' net. An incisive forward pass down the left channel by Ronaldo found the advancing Fabio Coentrao and the left-back bypassed the Bayern defence to gift Benzema a tap-in. It was the first significant chance of the game.

The opportunity had come more or less directly from a Kroos blocked shot at the other end. Is that unfortunate or inevitable? The problem of such patient build-up play is that there is plenty of time for bodies to get back and get in the way. It takes speed in the final third, unbelievable intricacy or an error from an opponent to create the opening. Real were not in mood for the latter and Bayern looked too one-paced to provide the former.

Naturally, with the counter-attack it is a different story. It's quite logical that with space in behind the defence for players to attack, when a chance is fashioned it will be clearer and therefore more likely to be put away. That's exactly what Benzema did. Indeed, Ronaldo and Angel Di Maria could and should have tripled the lead between them before half time. Real had none of the ball but all of the best chances.

While Bayern created chances of sorts, the clear opportunities came Real's way. Opta defines a big chance as "a situation where a player should reasonably be expected to score, usually in a one-on-one scenario or from very close range" - and Bayern didn't manage to fashion one of those all evening.

As it stands, Real are the only team Guardiola's side haven't created a big chance against in this season's Champions League, but given that they only managed one in three hours of football against Manchester United, the trend appears to be going in the wrong direction. By way of further contrast, Real have created the most of them in this year's competition at a rate of more than three per game. That vital away goal looks a distinct possibility in Munich.

Real Madrid coach Carlo Ancelotti, who boasts an unbeaten record against Bayern, made his point succinctly in the post-match press conference. "The game was more or less as I expected," he said. "Football is not just about controlling the ball. It's about defending, counter-attacking. We had three or four very clear chances in the first half. This team is formidable on the counter."

Guardiola agreed in words if not spirit. "Madrid are the best counter-attacking team in the world," he said. "The faster you take the ball to them, the faster it comes back at you." Later adding: "Madrid have always been a counter-attacking team, for a long time, since I was a player. They sit back and hit on the counter."

Like a vegetarian telling their partner the steak looks nice, the sense of distaste in his mouth was almost palpable. Perhaps it is understandable that Guardiola should view Real this way. After all, the last time they managed so few passes in a game was up against Pep's great Barca vintage of 2011. But a key difference is that this Bayern - for all its quality - does not have a Lionel Messi.

Against teams with men behind the ball, it requires dribbling as well as passing to unlock defences. Arjen Robben attempted eight of the 18 Bayern tried in the Real half, but completed just three of them and was well-marked. His team looked devoid of ideas. "We had a lot of possession but we have to improve our final diagonal pass," Guardiola said. Always the passing.

Balance has been lost. Guardiola took over a Bayern team that had a variety of strengths. There was a physicality to their game and an incisive counter-attack of their own. Bayern scored the most goals from set-pieces in last season's Champions League. This year Atletico Madrid have scored three times as many. Only three teams scored more goals on the counter-attack last season. This year not a single strike has come via a fast break.

"Bayern Munich have become possession without purpose," said Sky Sports pundit Gary Neville. "They have to get that balance right. May seem harsh but if the imbalance continues then what is a great team can become a one trick pony. Early warning signs are there. However, they still could go through next week. They have a great manager and team have just lost their incision."

There are 90 minutes left to find it and nobody should rule out them doing so. There appears to be an appetite in some quarters to see them fail - for the pass-masters to be foiled. But with home advantage in the second leg, Bayern remain an even-money bet to progress to the final. If they do so then they'll be huge favourites to become the first team to defend the famous trophy in the Champions League era.

Small margins for the soul of football to be decided on. Perhaps what people should really focus on is the joy of a sport that can be played - and won - in so many different ways.

Adam Bate in the Santiago Bernabeu - follow him on Twitter.

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Most Commented

Readers' Comments


e deserved respect for forging a successful football career despite being, clearly, made from balsa wood.

Wenger: Diaby deserves respect


iverpool should put in a bid for Barkley. As cheeky as it may sound, only he looks capable enough to replace Gerrard.

Gerrard's Decay Becoming Sadly Apparent


y emotions were not mixed. Super professional that he is. I will never look at you the same way Frank. Love affair over.

Lampard: Mixed emotions

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Rio: Fergie exit hit RvP hardest

Rio Ferdinand has claimed Robin van Persie was the player who suffered the most after Sir Alex Ferguson's retirement as Man United manager.

Premier League: West Brom boss Alan Irvine ready to drop big names

West Brom boss Alan Irvine has underlined his willingness to drop out-of-form players, regardless of their status.

Transfer news: Frank Lampard's Manchester City loan spell could be extended

Frank Lampard's loan spell with Manchester City could be extended into February next year, according to Sky sources.

Mail Box

Should Gerrard Play Further Forward?

That's one shout in a mailbox that recalls Rafa Benitez saying the Liverpool man would one day end up as a striker. Plus, thoughts on Rooney and 500 words on Ipswich...

Will Rodgers Finally Drop Gerrard?

The mailbox wants to know if Brendan Rodgers has the stones to drop Steven Gerrard. Plus, thoughts on Wayne Rooney's display, sitting down, and thanking United fans...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property