Six Of The Worst - United Under-Performers's Martin Laurence takes a statistical look at which Manchester United players let their standards slip most under David Moyes...

Last Updated: 24/04/14 at 13:11 Post Comment

Latest Articles

Chelsea Arrivals Again Leave Lukaku Out In The Cold


It's clear that Jose Mourinho has a problem with Romelu Lukaku, and it appears he will be leaving Chelsea for good. Is Jose in danger of cutting off his nose to spite his face?

Are Pre-Season Tours Really A Problem?

Post comment

Are pre-season tours really a problem? Liverpool went to Australia last summer and it didn't prevent them from having a good season. Plus, thoughts on LvG and keepers...

All Articles

This week the assumption that David Moyes would be given time to prove his worth at United, no matter how bad the results, was trampled. After an 11th Premier League defeat of the season, and second of the campaign to his former employers Everton, the board decided enough was enough.

While there are plenty that still feel the Scot should have been afforded more time, or at least the transfer window to start to build his own squad having inherited an ageing one - in defence in particular - it's hard to defend the rapid downfall in performance levels.

In turn, a certain amount of the blame must fall at the feet of some of the players. To hit the ground running a manager always needs his best players on song and too many that impressed last season have failed to do so this time around. Below, we highlight those who have perhaps let Moyes down the most with regards to their performances this season, looking at the players with the most significant drop in's ratings.

Firstly, it's worth pointing out that of the 20 United players to have made more than ten top-flight appearances this season and last (including marquee signings Juan Mata and Marouane Fellaini) five saw their ratings increase under Moyes. The most significant, in descending order, were Phil Jones (6.79 to 7.27), Chris Smalling (6.83 to 7.11), Wayne Rooney (7.25 to 7.57), Danny Welbeck (6.69 to 6.83) and Michael Carrick (7.04 to 7.06).

There's an interesting theme in the fact that all five are English, perhaps calling into question Moyes' ability to motivate some of the foreign players at the club. While it is true that he managed plenty of players from overseas at Everton, the core of his squads were British. It could be argued that the homegrown players at United may perhaps have appreciated the job he did at Everton more and therefore needed less convincing of his pedigree.

That is for another time, though. Here are the worst offenders for letting their standards slip from last season, with varying validity of excuses.

6. Rafael - Drop of 0.29 (from 7.32 to 7.03)
Last season was the Brazilian's best in a United shirt. He had previously shown glimpses of the swashbuckling full-back he was predicted to become but also moments of real naivety. During Ferguson's final countdown the 23-year-old started to shown signs of adding the consistency a top-class defender needs to his game, but Rafael has regressed under Moyes.

While he's continued to offer an attacking outlet, the right-back has been more wasteful in possession, with his pass accuracy dropping from 84.5% to 78.8%. From a defensive standpoint he's also been less impressive, with his average tackles and interceptions down from 3.1 and 2 to 2.3 and 1.8 per game respectively. With no goals and only one assist, it's been a forgettable season for Rafael.

5. Ryan Giggs - Drop of 0.32 (from 6.72 to 6.40)
It's interesting that of the 20 United players to have made more than ten league appearances this season their new caretaker manager is the lowest rated according to It's true that Giggs has had very little playing time to find his rhythm but he has made the same proportion of his appearances as a substitute this season as he did last (54.5%) so his impact has certainly diminished, quite understandably, with age.

The Welshman looks likely to fail to score in the Premier League for the first time since its inception, and he's also failed to register an assist in 11 appearances. His averages for shots (0.3), key passes (0.7) and dribbles (0.4) have all dropped from last season and, having adopted a somewhat dogged midfield role at times in his latter years under Ferguson, his tackles per game figure has dropped substantially from 2 to 0.5.

4. Javier Hernandez - Drop of 0.35 (from 6.80 to 6.45)
The player that can no doubt be forgiven the most for his drop in performances this season, Hernandez started just five of his 21 league appearances under Moyes, with the Scot clearly not convinced by the Mexican. Having registered double figures in each of his three previous league seasons at the club, the forward has netted just four this time around and failed to have the same impact from the bench that he did under Ferguson.

Likely to have been a little disillusioned with life in Manchester, the 25-year-old has been making progressively fewer appearances in the last two years and his United career hasn't flourished as he'd have hoped. With just 18 shots all season, he's not been cropping up in the right places as often, despite a lack of minutes.

3. Marouane Fellaini - Drop of 0.43 (from 7.57 to 7.14)
This is arguably a case of Moyes falling on his own sword, with many questioning how Marouane Fellaini would adapt to a side like United despite a fantastic season in 2012/13. The Belgian has been the poster boy of Moyes' failings at times, and perhaps a little undeservingly so. After all, United weren't exactly flying in his lengthy absence through injury.

Nevertheless, Fellaini has struggled to find his identity at Old Trafford, which is strange to say of a player of his appearance and stature. The midfielder has been deployed in a deeper role, as he was early on in his Everton career, and has looked more than a little leggy at times. Having proven such a threat in the attacking third last season, Fellaini is yet to register a league goal or assist for United, creating just three chances over his 15 appearances compared to 40 last year.

2. Ashley Young - Drop of 0.44 (from 6.97 to 6.55)
While injuries may have stunted the progress and indeed promise of Ashley Young, he's still faced his fair share of criticism from United fans in recent seasons, falling under the 'not good enough for the club' category. The England international has done little to dispute such claims in the current campaign, with his performances a far cry from those that saw him earn an international call and interest from United whilst at Aston Villa.

Here is a winger that, in his final season in the Midlands, averaged 2.4 shots and 2.3 key passes per game. Fast forward three years and those figures are down at 0.7 and 0.8 respectively. With United thought to be planning a clear out in the summer, the 28-year old's position will certainly come under threat given his waning form since arriving at Old Trafford.

1. Robin van Persie - Drop 0.53 (from 7.68 to 7.15)
The most significant decrease of all, in more ways than one, has been that of Robin van Persie, who lavished Sir Alex Ferguson with praise during their short working relationship. The Dutchman may have been more disappointed than most then when the legendary boss announced his decision to step down and his fondness of the replacement manager and the club as a whole has been questioned all year.

Much of United's success last season was credited to the exploits of the eventual top scorer in the league (26 goals) but his form has fallen way short this season. While a tally of 11 league goals from 18 appearances is still impressive, he's been guilty of missing the sort of chances that one would deem ideal for a player of his calibre. Perhaps the most damning indication of Van Persie's plight is that he has been awarded just one man of the match rating in the league compared to a massive ten last time around.

By Martin Laurence. Follow him on Twitter.

All statistics courtesy of, where you can find yet more stats, including live in-game data and unique player and team ratings.

Surely they are the best under-performers or the worst performers?
- waynel

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Most Commented

Readers' Comments


e made his power play to try and get Sheikhy to raise his wages or trade him to PSG. PSG were probably not interested and he is stuck with no cake and no vacation. @Jay_D> Surely you jest about FFP being real, right? All Platini is doing is making billionaries pay measly fines, so he and his cronies can get rich. If a fool can pay 50 mil for David Luiz, he will happily pay some fine to UEFA. FFP has failed as for it to succeed UEFA had to take it...

Toure: I am staying with City


uess we can expect Toure's explanation of his behaviour around the same time Pete Townshend publishes his book then.

Toure: I am staying with City


amn you Yaya, don't scare me like that! I only ate the icing. I didn't eat the soft and scrumptious middle - I will buy you another cake!

Toure: I am staying with City

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Transfer News: Manchester United may need two more defenders, according to Lee Sharpe

Lee Sharpe says Manchester United may need to add another couple of defenders to their squad ahead of the new season

Transfer News: QPR want Watford striker Troy Deeney to replace Loic Remy

QPR are interested in Watford's Troy Deeney to replace Liverpool-bound striker Loic Remy, Sky sources understand.

Premier League: Manchester City winger Jesus Navas hungry for more trophies

Jesus Navas believes Manchester City have the quality to win the Premier League and Champions League this season.

Mail Box

Are Pre-Season Tours Really A Problem?

Are pre-season tours really a problem? Liverpool went to Australia last summer and it didn't prevent them from having a good season. Plus, thoughts on LvG and keepers...

It Isn't Easy Supporting Spurs, You Know

We have a long mail about the travails of supporting Spurs, plus Friday thoughts on Marko Marin, marketing, victory v beauty, travelling and vanishing sprays...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property