Rooney Can't Be Trusted To Stop Pirlo...

Wayne Rooney's central role is under threat once more, this time from Danny Welbeck, who represents England's best chance of snuffing out Andrea Pirlo, says Ian Watson...

Last Updated: 11/06/14 at 09:58 Post Comment

Latest Articles

It's That Time Again: 'Wenger Out'

Post comment

Are Arsenal fans the ficklest in the Premier League? That's one question in the mailbox as Gooners call for Wenger to leave (again). Plus, plenty of reaction to Falcao...

Sense Of Value Lost In Current Transfer Market

12 comments

In the days of oligarchs with infinite pots of money, it is becoming impossible to assess value in the transfer market. John Nicholson has a headache...

All Articles

Attack is the best form of defence, implied Roy Hodgson, when he discussed how England planned to counter the creative threat of Italy's Andrea Pirlo.

The sentiment is admirable, and such bullishness will go down well with many England fans. But at some point reality has to replace rhetoric.

England are unlikely to out-play the Azzurri in Manaus on Saturday, when they will have to defend, possibly for long periods. To not pay special attention to Pirlo, and repeat the mistake of Euro 2012, would be suicide.

Of course, Hodgson knows that. He is a pragmatist and stopping Italy will be weighing on his mind as much as how he goes about drawing the best out of his forward players. One solution could solve both of his problems.

In Kiev, England made no plan for Pirlo, relying on the nearest man to close him down. It didn't work. The Juventus regista was given time and space to seek the killer passes, and when Pirlo spots one, he usually delivers.

Fortunately for England, Italy were wasteful. They failed to beat Joe Hart with any of their 18 shots on target that night but England's luck is unlikely to hold if they allow a similar number of opportunities in the Amazon.

England have to cut off Italy's supply, which, more often than not, comes from Pirlo. Allow him the ball, by all means. But don't allow him the space to wreak havoc.

Pirlo prowls in the area ahead of Italy's back four, the zone normally occupied by Rooney when he plays as a number 10. The England striker, though, lacks the discipline or nous to multi-task as a defensive attacker. Rooney failed to do it in Kiev two years ago and little has happened since then to suggest it was an unfortunate one-off.

In fact, when Sir Alex Ferguson was faced with a similar poser to Hodgson in the shape of Real Madrid and Xabi Alonso, the United boss benched Rooney for the second leg after a sloppy defensive display at the Bernabeu.

Instead, Welbeck was asked to play a more withdrawn role to sit on Alonso and it worked. At least until United were reduced to ten men, after which they were predictably given the run-around.

In Hodgson's favoured 4-2-3-1 system, Welbeck has to be the one designated to Pirlo, but he can't do that from his usual wide position. It would mean shifting Rooney to the left, from where - as both player and manager have pointed out - he can hurt the opposition.

Rooney wasn't interested in listening to Paul Scholes last week, but the former United midfielder was speaking from experience when it comes to dealing with Pirlo. He says the Italian "destroyed" United in 2007 when they opted not to man-mark. Three years later, with Ji-Sung Park stood on Pirlo's toes over 180 minutes, United recorded a 7-2 aggregate win.

Rooney doesn't have the discipline or engine to follow Pirlo on Saturday night while attempting to link up with Daniel Sturridge. Welbeck may not have the talent to do both, but he can do the first job, while his pace puts him in a better position to break forward to support England's attack. Raheem Sterling is similarly capable in that role, but Welbeck's previous experience will probably clinch him the starting spot. After 70 minutes in the Amazon heat, even the great Pirlo will be loathe to see the Liverpool flier spring off the bench to take over the job of turning the playmaker back towards his own goal.

Alternatively, Hodgson may throw Italy a curve ball and play a midfield three, like England did in qualifying during another must-not-lose game - the drab goalless stalemate in Ukraine. Without Rooney that night, Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard and Jack Wilshere protected the back four, while James Milner and Theo Walcott attempted to support Rickie Lambert from wide. Such a set-up, though, goes against everything Hodgson has been preaching and practising in the build-up.

With Welbeck assigned to Pirlo in a 4-2-3-1, it at least allows Rooney more space on the left to be his most effective. James Milner's discipline may be required on the right to compensate for Rooney's tendency to drift into attacking positions, even before the ball is won, which may be another pointer towards a bench role for Sterling.

For all Hodgson's attacking talk, England do not have to beat Italy; avoiding defeat is the primary objective and playing Welbeck, not Rooney, around Pirlo gives England a fighting chance.

Ian Watson - follow him on Twitter

Agree with the point about Rooney. As talented as he may be, positional discipline is not his strength. Playing him on the left of the advanced midfield three could be the best option (without changing what seems to be the favoured 4-2-3-1 system). He can then play almost a free role, whether justified or not. Sterling would be the man to play the number 10 role for me. Ok, not as experienced as Welbeck. But he offers the same qualities (pace, discipline) with the added form and quality that Welbeck doesn't.
- yeboahhhhh

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

E

ven if United were to sign CR7 & Messi to play upfront, the fact remains Fletcher and Cleverly are playing in midfield. That's where the problem is. Fletcher is too slow with an awful pass, while Cleverly is simply rubbish

mrunited4life
Di Maria - A Signing of Necessity, or Opportunity?

T

hese days, these days, you can't say something racist without somebody saying that you're a racist.

tk421
'Wrong' Views Not Silenced By Shouting...

D

rop Rooney (he's so disappointing, overrated and overpaid), and play Di Maria and RVP upfront, much like the set up at the Netherlands team with Roben and RVP...

eric bush3
Di Maria - A Signing of Necessity, or Opportunity?

Latest Photos

Footer 365

Transfer news: Radamel Falcao joins Manchester United on loan

Manchester United have signed Monaco striker Radamel Falcao on a season-long loan with an option to buy.

Transfer news: Hatem Ben Arfa leaves it late to join Hull City on loan

Hull City have signed midfielder Hatem Ben Arfa on a season-long loan from Premier League rivals Newcastle.

Transfer news: Arsenal sign Danny Welbeck from Manchester United

Arsenal have signed Danny Welbeck from Manchester United for a fee believed to be in the region of £15-16million.

Mail Box

It's That Time Again: 'Wenger Out'

Are Arsenal fans the ficklest in the Premier League? That's one question in the mailbox as Gooners call for Wenger to leave (again). Plus, plenty of reaction to Falcao...

Wenger: The Most Stubborn Manager Going

Arsenal fans would quite like their club to sign a striker thank you very much, whilst someone is excited about Jim White et al. Plus, Klose to Arsenal please...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property