Danny Devine turned in an impressive performance in central defence during Wednesday night's goalless draw with Dundee United at the Tulloch Caledonian Stadium.
But with Gary Warren available again following suspension and club captain Richie Foran back from a knee injury, Butcher has a decision to make regarding who starts at the back for Inverness in the clash between the teams standing third and fourth in the Scottish Premier League.
He said: "Danny Devine played well and it now leaves me with not only a headache regarding the back four for Saturday, but also Richie Foran is available.
"However, it's nice to have that headache because I don't often get them.
"It's going to be a belter of an occasion. For us, it's about making sure we go out and do a good job."
Inverness dropped a place from second in the SPL table on Wednesday night, due to Motherwell's victory against Celtic.