The former Rangers and England captain has played on some of the biggest stages in football, but even he is left breathless after his side meet Ross County.
Ahead of the first meeting of the teams this season, at the Global Energy Stadium on Friday night, Butcher said: "They are very close games, very tense games, very hard-fought games.
"At the end of the game you are like, 'Phew, what a game that was', irrespective of whether it was 0-0 or 3-1 or whatever. The 3-3 game stands out in your mind more than anything else.
"But they are wonderful spectacles of football. That intensity, you want to bottle it up and keep it in the Highlands because it's special.
"I have played in, managed in and witnessed a few derbies up and down the UK and this one matches any one in terms of hatred, intensity and respect and everything else.
"Before the game everyone will have friendly rivalries, but come the game everyone hates each other. It's just those 90 minutes, they are special."
Inverness knocked County out of the William Hill Scottish Cup after a replay last season as well as meeting the Dingwall side in the top flight for the first time.
Butcher said: "Derby matches add spice to the season. We have had seasons where we haven't had to play Ross County and I wouldn't say it's been flatter but it's certainly great when you have the derby matches. Six last season was a lot, but hopefully we can have four this year and both of us finish in the top six again."
Inverness only lost one of the six derbies last term, but it proved costly as defeat on the final day saw them miss out on a place in Europe.
Butcher said: "It will be a good pitch we play on this time. The last game of last season was a bit like playing on a car park.
"That suits both teams and suits football. We have had a debate this week about who is the best passing team but both teams can pass the ball very well.
"They have some very good players who are very comfortable on the ball too."
Caley Thistle go into the game in second place in the Scottish Premiership, but only nine points ahead of Ross County after suffering consecutive defeats against St Johnstone and Partick Thistle.
But Butcher was in no mood to contemplate the impending close of his team's first round of fixtures.
"There will be no reflection before the game because it will be helmets on, visors down, bayonets fixed," he said.