CHESTER 'UNABLE TO FULFIL FIXTURE'   SMITH COOL OVER BOUGHERRA SPECULATION   LOOVENS: TITLE RACE NOT OVER   McLEISH TO IGNORE HAMMERS 'SIDESHOW'   BROWN BRACED FOR BIG SAM'S ROAR   POMPEY TALKS CONTINUE   ANCELOTTI WILL ALLOW LEAVE FOR TERRY   IT'S WIN OR BUST NOW - BROWN   MOYES WAITS FOR FELLAINI NEWS   ZOLA UNHAPPY ABOUT TIMING  
  • Bingo
  • Poker
  • Casino
  • £30 Free Bet
  • Home
  • All The News
    • Premier News
    • Championship News
    • League 1
    • League 2
    • Scottish Premier
    • Cup News
      • Champions League
      • Europa League
      • FA Cup
      • Carling Cup
      • Scottish League Cup
      • Homecoming Cup
    • Transfer Gossip
    • International News
      • Italy
      • Spain
      • France
      • Germany
      • Holland
    • England News
    • World Cup
    • Transfer Centre
    • Transfer Blog
  • Teams
    • Prem Clubs: A-L
      • Arsenal
      • Aston Villa
      • Birmingham City
      • Blackburn Rovers
      • Bolton Wanderers
      • Burnley
      • Chelsea
      • Everton
      • Fulham
      • Hull City
      • Liverpool
    • Prem Clubs:M-Z
      • Manchester City
      • Manchester United
      • Portsmouth
      • Stoke City
      • Sunderland
      • Tottenham
      • West Ham
      • Wigan
      • Wolves
    • C'ship Clubs:A-N
      • Barnsley
      • Blackpool
      • Bristol City
      • Cardiff City
      • Coventry City
      • Crystal Palace
      • Derby County
      • Doncaster
      • Ipswich Town
      • Leicester City
      • Middlesbrough
      • Newcastle United
      • Nottingham Forest
    • C'ship Clubs:O-Z
      • Plymouth Argyle
      • Preston North End
      • Peterborough
      • Queens Park Rangers
      • Reading
      • Scunthorpe
      • Sheffield United
      • Sheffield Wednesday
      • Swansea City
      • Watford
      • West Brom
    • SPL Clubs
      • Aberdeen
      • Celtic
      • Dundee United
      • Dunfermline
      • Falkirk
      • Hamilton
      • Hearts
      • Hibernian
      • Kilmarnock
      • Motherwell
      • Rangers
      • St Mirren
      • St. Johnstone
    • England
      • News
      • Match Reports
      • Statistics
    • Northern Ireland
      • News
      • Match Reports
      • Statistics
    • Republic of Ireland
      • News
      • Match Reports
      • Statistics
    • Scotland
      • News
      • Match Reports
      • Statistics
    • Wales
      • News
      • Match Reports
      • Statistics
  • Fixtures & Results
    • Fixtures
    • Today's Results
    • Fixtures for:
      • Premier League
      • Championship
      • League 1
      • League 2
      • Blue Square Premier
      • SPL
      • Scottish Div 1
      • Scottish Div 2
      • Scottish Div 3
      • Spanish Primera Liga
      • Italian Serie A
      • French Division 1
      • German Bundesliga
    • Results for:
      • Premier League
      • Championship
      • League 1
      • League 2
      • Blue Square Premier
      • SPL
      • Scottish Div 1
      • Scottish Div 2
      • Scottish Div 3
      • Spanish Primera Liga
      • Italian Primera Liga
      • French Division 1
      • German Bundesliga
    • Live Scores
  • Previews & Reports
    • Previews
    • Reports
  • Statistics
    • League Tables
      • Premier League
      • Championship
      • League 1
      • League 2
      • Blue Square Premier
      • SPL
      • Scottish Div 1
      • Scottish Div 2
      • Scottish Div 3
      • Spanish Primera Liga
      • Italian Serie A
      • French Division 1
      • German Bundesliga
      • S.Africa Premier Lge
      • S.Africa Div 1
    • England Domestic
    • Scotland Domestic
    • International
      • By Tournament/Country
      • All-Time Overview
      • 2002-2008 Overview
      • England
      • Scotland
      • Wales
      • Northern Ireland
      • Rep of Ireland
      • Euro 2008 Quals
    • Europe
      • European Club Stats
      • Champions League
      • UEFA Cup
    • Club Stats
    • Historical Stats
    • Interactive Search
    • World Cup Qualifying
      • Europe
      • South America
      • North and Central America
      • Africa
      • Asia
      • Oceana
  • Opinion
    • The Football365 Blog
    • F365 Opinion
    • Chat Forum
    • Mailbox
    • John Nicholson
    • Referee 365
    • Spanish Thing
    • Email Us
  • Features
    • F365 Features
    • Fun Features
    • Credits
    • Music
    • 365 Reviews
    • Mediawatch
  • Fun
    • Competitions
    • Fantasy Football
    • Lookalikes
    • Missing Men
    • Photo Galleries
    • Facebook Fan Page
    • Football365 on Twitter
    • Mediawatch
  • Mobile
    • Sports Quiz
    • Football Alerts
    • F365 on your mobile
    • Mobile downloads
  • Photo Gallery
  • Odds

John Nicholson

Are Our Footballers Becoming Women?

Are Our Footballers Becoming Women?

Posted 27/11/09 13:41
EmailPrintSave


Are you shocked by the huge number of injured players? Does it seem odd that the likes of Liverpool, Arsenal, Everton and many other clubs constantly seem to have a treatment room full of crocks? Well I have news for you. Men, we are not the men we used to be. We are becoming women.

Some see, what is being called, 'the feminisation of the male' to be one of the main reasons behind so many football injuries. That modern day footballers are physically weaker, less tough and are thus more inclined to get injured and be unable to get over the injury quickly.

The injury count at many clubs is quite extraordinary at the moment, with some clubs having over a dozen players out injured, whereas it's not that long ago that clubs could win a league fielding less than 15 players all season long. It is a remarkable change and one that has not gone unnoticed.

Now, despite a lifetime dedicated to ingestion of various medicines, I'm not actually a medical man, but I know a man who is. A proper one. He's called Dec the Doc. It doesn't say that on the door of his practice but it's what I call him because I'm childish and quite possibly a girl. He can tell a labia from a tibia. In short, he's got all the proper learning despite studying medicine at Newcastle University whilst drunk most of the time.

He's writing a paper about the feminisation both physically and culturally of men, part of which looks at the massive amount of injuries in modern day football compared to 25 or more years ago.

Now, it's always tempting for a man such as myself to accuse your modern day player of being a soft little nancy boy in comparison to the brutish alpha males of the 60s and 70s. I mean, Jermaine Jenas would have been thought to be a girl in the 70s, or possibly a lesbian folk singer. But I didn't expect medical science to be on my side - I assumed it was just plain old fogeyism on my part.

But Dec the Doc, points to actual evidence to prove his case - see I told you he was educated and that. Now, I won't give you the full lecture but in short a cocktail of pollutant chemicals in the water from PCBs, pesticides, plastics and many other things are 'endocrine disrupters' which basically means you grow up less male and more female. Baby boys are even born with smaller penises these days because of it - what sort of job is that? Did you have a nice day at the hospital with your ruler, darling?

He also reckons that there is so much estrogen in the water from women who take the pill that it both increases sterility and also makes men more female as they consume it.

Clearly, I'm boiling down a complex theory to a couple of lines but this is the essence of it.

My response to this was to ask why the sterility didn't seem to affect the wasters in trackie bottoms who live on the dole and reproduce the species at a ferocious rate despite the fact that many of them are surely too fat to find their genitals.

He accused me of being reactionary and pointed to lower sperm counts amongst many men across all classes. Why, he asked, when physiotherapy is so good, do players suffer so many more injuries than 30 or 40 years ago when players were less fit, played much more football, had worse diets, played on awful pitches and when physical aggression was a major part of the game?

At this point I tried to imagine myself as one of those F365 readers who reads the website seemingly in order to become very angry and writes to say we (or at least me) are morons; what would he say about these aspersions being cast on their masculinity?

I imagined the fact that the game is faster and players are athletes and as such as prone to more injuries would be raised as a major issue. Is it a valid like for like comparison to put Dave Mackay next to Rio Ferdinand, say? Doesn't football require a different sort of physique to play it these days? A slimmer, faster, leaner man. A Neil Ruddock-style big bruiser wouldn't get near the top level anymore

He pooh-poohed this, and it's not a pleasant site seeing a doctor pooh-poohing. He argues that had the physical changes in many men not happened, we'd now have a generation of super-strong, super-fit players, less prone to injury than ever before.

He says that the strain put on joints and muscles when you are being kicked and have to play on a sticky, muddy pitch is far greater than put on them sprinting along a flat, smooth modern carpet. He also added something about how the modern pasta diet of slow-release carbs feed muscles better and should protect them from injury better than the steak and Guinness pre-match meal of yore, but only if the underlying physique is robust.

I proffered the idea that clubs are just keener these days to protect their expensive assets and so don't rush a player back from injury or take him off quicker if injury is suspected. They can identify injuries more accurately.

He countered by saying, 'Even allowing for the fact that some injuries can be identified today which couldn't be a generation ago - the huge disparity between the amount then and now is not explained purely by that. Injuries are at an all time high despite all the protection in legislation and from medicine. There is every reason to believe that some, though far from all men in football and outside of it, are not as tough or as resilient as they once were and especially those under 25 who have received the great amount of endocrine disrupters from birth. They even seem to have a lower pain threshold than a generation earlier. We know that endocrine disrupters are at an all time high. It must be a factor in some footballers' development as men and one way it might manifest itself is in a lack of robustness.'

He also believes - though admits he can't prove this - those over-emotional men who are prone to tearful tantrums and hysterical over-reaction, is all part of the same condition. 'Old-fashioned male stoicism is being bred out of us physically and culturally' he says. Oooh, get him. What a brute.

'Alex Ferguson commented on this the other day when looking at a photo of a brawl between Leeds and Man United players in the mid 60s, pointing to the fact that the crowd look on impassive, whereas these days they'd be going mad. That is a big culturally and emotional shift within one generation. Something is causing that.'

There's certainly a lot of research into this as I looked up a few articles on the matter just to make sure he wasn't pulling my leg. But then again, there's a lot of research into all sorts of whacko nonsense. And even if it was true there's not much we or our football clubs can do about it in the short-term. If it's true they're stuck with a load of girlies then that's just the way it is.

All the gender-bender chemicals need to be removed from the water, the land and the food or we'll all turn into ladyboys. But is becoming a bit more like a lass really a bad thing? As long as we don't actually start to menstruate, obviously.

So next time you start to tear up while watching Eastenders, disappoint a lady with your manliness in the bedroom or 'get a twinge' and have to be subbed, you can tell the wife or the manager that it's not your fault, it's those damn endocrine disrupters kicking in again, you big girl.


Your Comments

trumpton

"I was thinking about this sort of thing over the weekend so it's interesting that JNs put a thoughtful piece together. I've always slated Wenger for buying injury prone players (or at least used that as an argument to Gooners when they're bemoaning their injury list), but the other common factor is that he buys very young players.

Remeber when Stevie Me was breaking on to the scene? He was always out injured. For long periods. Rather than waiting for his body to develop Wenger would have snapped him up (assuming he was French or African), and then moaned about the fact that he had to sit 3 games out after every one cos of his shin splints.

Maybe this is also a factor...the average age and therefore underdevelopment of the player these days.

That and the fact that we're all namby pambys these days."

CaptFantastic

"I think there are several factors which are being conflated here.

"a cocktail of pollutant chemicals in the water from PCBs, pesticides, plastics and many other things are 'endocrine disrupters' which basically means you grow up less male and more female."

This has been known since the '80s and is a well-documented phenomenon.

But it takes a (sexist) leap of faith to say that means men are weaker (and prone to injury)and more emotional (and prone to blubbing) because they have become chemically feminised.

Are there stats that show women are more prone to injury than mean, or that they feel more pain?

If men are crying more these days, it's more likely to be because of a cultural shift away from a macho identity rather than a chemical imbalance."

markc1728

"So is this world wide or just in England? Presumably the Ivory Coast aren't filling their water with girl chemicals...please explain Didier Drogba.

The research makes sense, but applying it to football doesn't. Especailly it being applied by someone who b1tches about foreign players being so prevelent."

greg101

"Must admit I've had my suspicions for a while, did 'man boobs' exist in the good old days? I thought it was down to the female hormones being pumped into farm animals....."

tomh90

"Perhaps this explains the increase in gang culture? Every bloke knows how much women like to gang up when they're in an argument"

hallicks

"I'll feel a bit more comforted next time I'm on my Meriod. "

Mutid

"Take a quick look at the Plant-F1.com advert to the right. Those are women and only Fernando Torres comes anywhere close to that. At this present time there is not one footballer I can say that is arousing any kind of man-love within me - even Santa Cruz has lost his je ne sais quoi. As to it being an increasing phenomenon, I am not so sure as the Ancient Greeks and Persians were certainly very faggy and the once-respectable and universal practice of pedastry would get you these days 5-7 at Her Majesty's Pleasure and an inclusion on the Sex Offender's List. How times change..."

Liney

"Great article, and food for thought. One other factor that often gets mentioned is the flimsy boots they now wear, which results in a broken metatarsal every time someone gets a hot on the top of the foot."

bun9

"What this article and indeed the doctor hasn't taken into account is that generally when players got big injuries in the "olden days" they simply retired because there wasn't the medical science to fix them. Nowadays players can stay injured for three years but still have hope of playing again (Solskjaer springs to mind). You read books about yesteryear football and it's quite staggering how many players retired at the age of 22 etc. A friend of mine was really shocked that it looks like Dean Ashton is going to retire at his age but this happened all the time a few decades ago. It may not account for the whole argument here but it's worth a mention."

edbreakaleg

"Ha ha, a few biters already. You can take or leave this piece as you want to. Not a waste of space article and it is quite interesting in that it is a fact that there are more injuries than 20-30 years and finding the reasons for that. Stating its because the game is faster and footballers are more 'highly tuned athletes' is as simplistic an arguement as blaming increasing metrosexuality amongst men in today's society. There will be hundreds of factors. It would probably be interesting to see a comparative study made within other sports with less variables than football to statistically prove/disprove theories, athletics - sprinters for example, plenty has changed in that sport but at least things like the athletics track have stayed the same. Nice sly little dig at the younger readers too..."

All comments on this story


Character Count : 0/1900

You have exceeded the 1900 characters limit!

contact us!

Now let's hear what you've got to say about this item... or anything else happening in the world of football. Send in your opinions, rants, praise or abuse to: theeditor@football365.com

Other Articles

  • Stay Young, Free And Single Lads...
  • Whatever Happened To...Free Kicks?
  • You've Got To Love Throwback Rooney...
  • Whatever Happened To...John Gregory?
  • Thank The Lord For Floodlights...
  • Rafa Suffering From The Ex Factor...
  • Football Needs Its Own National Trust
  • His Name Is Mancini, Not Mourinho...
  • Do Fans Slip Easier Than Shoppers?
  • Of Course We're All Sodding Biased...

MEDIAWATCH: JUST FOR YOU...

mediawatch

Arsene Wenger Doesn't Count Almunia As A Footballer, Avram Thinks 16 Points Is Nothing, Brighty Spots What's Boring And Then Repeats It, Merson Fails To Predict Demolition Derby...

LIVE SCORES
365 PREVIEWS

LIVE SCORES

All Of Tonight's Scores And Scorers At A Glance...

365 PREVIEWS

Who's In, Who's Out And Who's A Doubt This Week

  • News
  • Fixtures
  • Results
  • Tables
  • Chester 'unable To Fulfil Fixture'
  • Smith Cool Over Bougherra Speculation
  • Loovens: Title Race Not Over
  • Mcleish To Ignore Hammers 'sideshow'
  • Brown Braced For Big Sam's Roar
  • Pompey Talks Continue
  • Ancelotti Will Allow Leave For Terry
  • It's Win Or Bust Now - Brown
  • Moyes Waits For Fellaini News
  • Zola Unhappy About Timing
  • Benitez Focuses On Football
  • Mccarthy: We Can Stay Up
  • O'neill Wary Of Rooney Threat
  • Wenger Continues To Believe
Feb 09th 2010
FulhamvBurnley20.00
Man CityvBolton19.45
PortsmouthvSunderland19.45
Wigan AthleticvStoke City19.45
Feb 10th 2010
ArsenalvLiverpool19.45
Aston VillavMan Utd19.45
BlackburnvHull City20.00
EvertonvChelsea20.00
West HamvBirmingham19.45
WolvesvTottenham19.45

More Fixtures

Barclays Premier League Results
Sunday February 07
Birmingham 2 - 1 Wolverhampton
Chelsea 2 - 0 Arsenal
Saturday February 06
Bolton 0 - 0 Fulham
Burnley 2 - 1 West Ham
Hull 2 - 1 Man City
Liverpool 1 - 0 Everton
Man Utd 5 - 0 Portsmouth
Stoke 3 - 0 Blackburn
Sunderland 1 - 1 Wigan
Tottenham 0 - 0 Aston Villa

More Results

TeamPWDLGFGAGDPts
1 Chelsea 25 18 4 3 60 20 40 58
2 Man Utd 25 18 2 5 61 20 41 56
3 Arsenal 25 15 4 6 60 30 30 49
4 Liverpool 25 13 5 7 43 26 17 44
5 Tottenham 25 12 7 6 45 25 20 43
6 Man City 23 11 8 4 45 32 13 41
7 Villa 24 11 8 5 31 18 13 41
8 Birmingham 24 10 7 7 24 24 0 37
9 Everton 24 8 8 8 33 35 -2 32
10 Fulham 25 8 7 10 27 28 -1 31

More Tables

WENGER THREAT
PRESSED ACCOUNT

WENGER THREAT

Arsenal Boss Threatens Silent Protest At 'Misquotes'

PRESSED ACCOUNT

So Here's What Wenger Said After Chelsea And Villa...

Whinging&Whining
NUMBERS & STATS

Whinging&Whining

It's Descended Into A Debate About MoTD, F365, And...

NUMBERS & STATS

Why This Part-Timer Can't Go To The World Cup...

MISSING MEN
WINNERS&LOSERS

MISSING MEN

A West Ham Side Beating Brum From 1999...

WINNERS&LOSERS

Hmmm. So Have Liverpool Finally Turned Their Corner?

© 2009 365 Media Group Ltd.  All Rights Reserved

Sports

Sporting Life | TEAMtalk.com | Sportal | Football365 | Cricket365 | Golf365 | Extreme365  | Fixtures365 | Planet F1 | Planet Rugby | Sky Sports 

Betting & Gaming

Betting Zone | WSOP | Betting | Poker | Online Casino | Online Bingo | Oddschecker  | Casino Checker | Poker Checker | Bingo Checker | Free Bets 

Mobile, Fun & Games:

Free Online Games | 24-7 Football | Super 6 | Fantasy Football | Fantasy F1 | Fantasy Golf 

 

About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy