Whelan: Challenge was fair

Wigan Athletic chairman Dave Whelan has insisted to Sky Sports that Callum McManaman's challenge on Massadio Haidara was a 'fair' one.

Last Updated: 18/03/13 at 19:14 Post Comment

Massadio Haidara: After the challenge from Callum McManaman

Massadio Haidara: After the challenge from Callum McManaman

Haidara had to be stretchered off after the controversial tackle in Sunday's match but Whelan has launched a staunch defence of his player and does not feel he should be punished.

After the match Roberto Martinez insisted the challenge was not malicious, whilst referee Mark Halsey looked to have his viewpoint blocked.

Whelan insists that it was not a foul, and he told Sky Sports News: "Can I say to the Newcastle player that I hope you're soon well and hope you don't miss any matches, it was a pure accident and so we wish you a speedy recovery.

"I was watching the match and the referee was only 15 to 10 yards away, the ball came down between the two players, they both went for it. Our lad got the ball, no question he got the ball, but they collided - the still pictures look like he has gone for the player and gone over it, but he didn't, he got the ball.

"The referee was only 10 yards away and didn't even give the foul - it was a fair challenge, you have to see it all - our lad went for the ball, and they collided, it is football. It is tough game but it was an accident."

Newcastle are understood to be 'baffled' by Whelan's response but have not made an official statement on the matter.

Whelan himself had his career ended in the 1960 FA Cup final by Norman Deeley - but says players collide, and that is football.

"I have got a fair view, when a ball bounces between two players - I had the same at Wembley when the ball bounced between myself and Norman Deeley," he said.

"I got the ball but we collided and I broke my leg - and these accidents do happen. It was an accident when we went for the ball and in football you are allowed to go for the ball.

"We have to have 100 per cent commitment from every player, and I don't care who you're playing - they were fighting for the ball as much as ours - but our lads won't be unfair.

"It was a complete accident and hope the lad from Newcastle recovers quickly."

Right message

Whelan is adamant that the Football Association should not charge McManaman.

"It sends out the right message, the message is this; you play football and the ball bounces you are entitled to go and win it, kick it or get the ball as long as you go for the ball and it is not too high and this was only 14 inches off the ground - now that is playable," he said.

"That is what young McManaman has done, he has gone for the ball and has won the ball and the referee was only 10 yards away and didn't even give a free-kick and there is a lot to be said for that."

Whelan says they have been told by Newcastle that nothing is broken.

"We have asked for it [a check on the player], but they have said nothing is broken and they are just checking on ligaments but hopefully the lad will be playing in a fortnight," he said.

Should the FA charge the Wigan player, Whelan says they will not fight it.

"We will accept it as the FA look at things carefully, but they won't stop the pictures like the press do," he said.

"It was a tough match and we did not play at our best and I am sure Newcastle were a bit tired, but we stuck at it and lady luck smiled on us a bit and we had a little bit of good luck, not Callum McManaman which I thought was right, but others like the goal which apparently hit the hand before going in."

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

H

ow are people still backing Arsenal for the title? It's like you're predicting the tide not to come in; Arsenal will finish third or fourth and make the quarter final of the Champions League. It was ever thus.

thefuldutch
F365's Season Predictions

N

othing screams 'Panic!!' when your new manager brings Fellaini on as a sub for your star signing of the summer and within 5 minutes you concede the winner. I know it is only the first game in but I would seriously be sh1**ng myself I was a Man Utd supporter. This has the potential of being very nasty indeed.

stevemelbourne
Now Are You Nervous, Louis?

I

n the words of Pete Townsend, meet the new boss, the same as the old boss. Though I would comment that it's 3 more points than we picked up in the same fixture last year, so that's a 100% improvement.

uncle monty
No Sign That Liverpool Will Lessen Attacking Intent

Footer 365

Chelsea goalkeeper Thibaut Courtois wants rival Petr Cech to stay

Thibaut Courtois wants Petr Cech, his rival for the Chelsea goalkeeper's jersey, to stay at the club.

Champions League: Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger slams decision to send off Aaron Ramsey

Arsene Wenger described Aaron Ramsey's dismissal as "unacceptable" after Arsenal picked up a 0-0 draw at Besiktas.

Sky Bet Championship: Nottingham Forest go top, level with Cardiff, Charlton and Millwall

Nottingham Forest came from behind to replace Bournemouth at the top, level with Cardiff, Charlton and Millwall.

Mail Box

Dear Brendan, Please Sign Di Maria

That's the request to Brendan Rodgers in the mailbox, and not just because it would annoy Man United fans. Plus, more thoughts on why Arsenal didn't want Cescy back...

Man United Fans Still Pining For Mourinho

The morning mailbox ponders where United might be now had the club appointed Jose Mourinho last season, while Chelsea fans are getting very excited...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property