Next Game

Aberdeen v Celtic

Sunday, 10 May 2015, 14:30

Scots Prem

Tannadice Park

Last Game

Dundee U 1 - 0 Aberdeen

Saturday, 02 May 2015, 15:00

Scots Prem

Structural defects

Having been around the Scottish game for a long time, I have to say I'm far from convinced that the proposed changes to the structure of the leagues is the best way forward.

Last Updated: 07/01/13 at 13:18 Post Comment

Longmuir: encouraged by reconstruction plans

Longmuir: encouraged by reconstruction plans

With the SPL in a two-week break, all the talk centres on how the game can make a positive step forward and after much discussion between all interested parties, a format of two top leagues of 12, which split into three leagues of eight after 22 games, is on the cards.

It seems to me that if there's a way of making an easy game of football much more complex, we'll find it.

SFL chief executive David Longmuir has described the on-going talks on league reconstruction as being very positive. Following the collapse of Rangers in the summer and a rulebook that had no provision to deal with such a scenario, their eventual placement in the bottom tier of Scottish football resulted in relationships between SPL & SFL clubs being extremely fragile.

Initially, the SFL wanted a top league of 16 with a league of 10 and another league of 16 below that. A fairer distribution of wealth was their driving force with play-offs also top of their agenda.

But apart from Rangers, the biggest and most powerful clubs are obviously in the SPL and their chief executive Neil Doncaster immediately described the idea of a top league of 16 as "unworkable".

This new proposal of 12-12-18 is gathering favour and here's how it would work.

The top two divisions would split after two rounds of fixtures, 22 games, with teams meeting home and away. The top eight then play a further round of fixtures home and away giving a total of 36 games. These teams would be playing for the title and European places.

The bottom four of the initial 12 would play against the top four of the lower division of 12 and these eight clubs would also play another round of games home and away with the top four staying in the initial 12 for the following season and the bottom four being relegated.

The bottom eight in the lower 12 would also play off against one another for relegation places.

Confused? I'm not surprised.

Switzerland and Austria tried the same experiment in their top division for seven years before going back to a 12-10 set up.

Report

All of this of course has been on the back of a recent report from the SFA by former First Minister Henry McLeish who took a year to examine in detail the set-up, finances and best way forward for our game in the immediate to short term.

The SFA are an easy target for criticism but in giving him a free reign to say exactly what he thought, the former East Fife player didn't hold back.

With no hidden agenda and no allegiance to any side, McLeish proposed going back to a top league of 10, playing each other home and away twice for a total of 36 games with one relegation place as well as the second bottom being involved in promotion/relegation play-offs.

He also suggested every club should be under one body, something almost everyone agrees with. Having an SFA, SPL and SFL means self-interest is the driving force in every league.

But surely we can come up with something better than two top leagues of 12 splitting into three groups of eight?

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

M

aybe Hull charged the Liverpool fans more because their massive sense of entitlement takes up more room? Badum tish.

sailingmagpie
Everton team subsidise awayday

T

he John Carver Experiment sounds like the worst jazz fusion band of all time. Which is saying something.

sailingmagpie
The John Carver Experiment: The Next Episode

T

ime to play Liverpool players in their natural positions? I agree, but surely the subs' bench isn't big enough for all of them?

balls-to-monty
The John Carver Experiment: The Next Episode

Footer 365

Manchester United 0-1 West Brom: Robin van Persie penalty saved as Baggies shock United

Chris Brunt's deflected free kick gave West Brom a 1-0 win at Manchester United as Robin van Persie saw a penalty saved.

QPR defender Rio Ferdinand loses wife to cancer

Rio Ferdinand’s wife Rebecca has died following a short battle with cancer.

Arsene Wenger claims Jose Mourinho disrespected Arsenal with title taunt

Arsene Wenger feels Jose Mourinho was disrespectful for taunting Arsenal about their 10-year wait for the title.

Mail Box

Shouldn't We Give Players Time?

Do we really want to throw out the baby with the bathwater every single summer? We also have a Man United fan who wants massive investment. And more...

Liverpool: No Greater Than Aston Villa

It's fair to say that Raúl H. Garcia from the morning mailbox has got something of a kicking on Thursday afternoon. Oh and the Neviller is wrong for once...

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company