Barrie versus Terry

Barrie McDermott and Terry O'Connor go head-to-head with their Super League predictions...

Last Updated: 15/02/13 at 10:18

Brough needs to control the game for Huddersfield

Brough needs to control the game for Huddersfield

Our Super League experts give their verdict on the weekend's games

On the pitch Barrie McDermott and Terry O'Connor liked nothing better than tearing into the opposition.

They may have hung up their boots but that competitive streak still runs strong and we have found a way to channel their energies...

Each week they will preview the live Super League games and give their predictions for the rest of action - and we'll keep track of who's called the most matches right!

Barrie took a two-point lead after round two with some great predictions, but Terry is hot on his heels and will be looking to close that gap this weekend...

Round 166
Round 253
Don't forget that you can follow all the action from the second weekend of Super League XVIII on Sky Sports.

Warrington v Catalans
8pm, Fri, Sky Sports 1 HD

Terry says: A lot of people think that Warrington dropped a point against Wigan. In the second half it was interesting to see that a lot of their senior players were coming up with some errors - players like Adrian Morley were forcing the pass which is not like him. Richie Myler was just exceptional for them though - people talk about Lee Briers being the master tactician for Wolves but Myler's reading of the game was very impressive. Despite being down to 12 men, Catalans still managed to beat Salford convincingly. I really like the way Catalans have started this season, they are a very good side and to score 40 points with just 12 men shows just how dangerous they are. Catalans themselves are going to be a different proposition away from home though and I'm going for Warrington after the disappointed of that draw with Wigan.

TERRY PREDICTS: Warrington by 12 points

Barrie says: I agree that Warrington were a little bit sloppy last week against Wigan. They made a lot of mistakes when they tried to overplay the game. Warrington were trying to play their way out of trouble but that is the way they play and it will win them more games than they lose. I expect Richie Myler to play a big role in this game too - he was man of the match for me against Wigan. Catalans were outstanding against Salford but I think away from their home turf they may not be as good and I expect Warrington to win a close game.

BARRIE PREDICTS: Warrington by 6 points

Bradford v Castleford
4.30pm, Sat, Sky Sports 1 HD

Terry says: The word Ian Millward would have used this week is consistency. Can Castleford back up that win against Leeds on Saturday? That was a great performance from them but in Super League when these games come thick and fast you have got to keep on performing. Bradford did look dangerous last week despite losing so if I did have to pick a side to win this then I will go for Bradford. The emotion of getting up for that big game against Leeds was have taken a bit too much out of Cas. Rangi Chase has also been banned for his shoulder charge on Zak Hardaker and he is going to be a big loss.

TERRY PREDICTS: Bradford by 8 points

Barrie says: West Yorkshire derbies are always fill of passion, unfortunately for Castleford they will have to do it without the influential Rangi Chase who is suspended. Bradford competed against Hull FC but could not quite match the levels they got too when they played Wakefield in round 1. I am expecting them to be better at home and expecting them to win.

BARRIE PREDICTS: Bradford 6 points

St Helens v Hull

Terry says: In their first game when Hull lost to Leeds, I thought the halfbacks gave their forwards notdirection, but last week against Bradford they really bossed their big men around and that made a huge difference. St Helens are a great side full of talent but are just not gelling as well as they should be - however I think they are not far from it all coming together and I can see it all clicking. This could be a very interesting game and I think it will show us and Saints exactly where they are. Their game against Widnes was very close - a real old fashioned arm wrestle. It was only when Ben Cross was sent off did things start to go their way. I fancy St Helens to put on a real performance because the last time they played at home they were very disappointing.

TERRY PREDICTS: Saints by 16 points

Barry says: Widnes made St Helens work really hard last weekend and I think Saints are still a little clunky and not as fluid as you would expect a Saints side to be. Nathan Brown will be making subtle changes and just tinkering away at his side. I could almost see the progression in that eight minutes last week that they are getting better. Hull FC gave Bradford a good hiding last weekend and they will take a lot from that, however, I am expecting Saints to be just a little more fluid and to win this one.

BARRIE PREDICTS: St Helens by 16 points

Leeds v Salford

Terry says: Seven days from this game Leeds will be taking on Melbourne in the World Club Challenge and there are definitely jerseys up for grabs. Leeds will be disappointed with their loss to Castleford but the Tigers just played the conditions better than Leeds. It was a real mud bath towards the end of the game. So I expect Leeds to really pick themselves up for Salford. As I have said before Salford give it their all and their players are prepared to do the hard work. Unfortunately you need that little bit of class too and they are missing that. I think this game is going to be a bit too much for them.

TERRY PREDICTS: Leeds by 30 points

Barrie says: You are right Terry, Leeds were out-enthused last weekend, Catleford really showed them how to play in that very gritty game. I am expecting Leeds to bounce back though. It is a torrid time for Phil Veivers and Salford. He is still trying to make the best out of what he has got, still trying to work with the players he has got.

BARRIE PREDICTS: Leeds by 38 points

Huddersfield v Wigan

Terry says:This is the game that I am really looking forward to more than anything this week! Huddersfield have been in great form and their forwards are taking no prisoners. If your forwards are in such rampant form then it is much easier for the halfbacks to use the ball and get right on the front foot. The way Paul Anderson rotates his big men means that there is never a reprieve for the opposition. However I was impressed with the Wigan forwards last week against Warrington, they are a pretty young bunch but took on a Wolves pack full of internationals and came out on top. It is not going to be easy to back it up against the likes of Eorl Crabtree, Stuart Fielden and Craig Kopczak. I think too much was made in the off season of Wigan losing Thomas Leuluai. Matty Smith has filled that void very well and I just think this Wigan side will step it up.

TERRY PREDICTS: Wigan to win by 8 points

Barrie says: I thought Wigan's young players played exceptionally well against Warrington. Greg Burke is a player I have been keeping a close eye on - he is not even 19 and already had a taste of first team action. I think they did enough to get the win against Warrington and I think they would have got the most of out the draw bearing in mind who was not available for them. For Huddersfield, Danny Brough needs to perform for them in this game. If he can use his kicking game and when that territorial battle and make Wigan come away from their own line, then that could put the game in Huddersfield favour. However Wigan will run hard and enthusiastically at the Giants and it should be a hard, close game. I am going for a Wigan victory.

BARRIE PREDICTS: Wigan by 6 points

Hull KR v Widnes

Terry says: Last week both these sides had a man sent to the sin bin and in that time conceded tries. They have both started games well and have been competitive from the go - Hull KR lost Lincoln Withers when he got run over in the first minute by Justin Poore last week and they miss him there will be even more pressure on Michael Dobson to get his team around the park. Widnes are without Ben Cross who is suspended after his sending off last week against St Helens however it does give the opportunity for someone like Ben Kavanagh or Benn Davies to come in and prove themselves. I expect

TERRY PREDICTS: Widnes to win this one by eight points

Barrie says: I was impressed by Widnes against St Helens. They managed to stick together and defensively they stuck to their task. They are managing to keep scores quite low which will be boost their confidence. Hull KR are not performing to their best and that will be a concern, I think Widnes will cause an upset.


London Broncos v Wakefield

Terry says: When Tony Rea looked at the fixtures list this is probably one of the games that he targeted for the Broncos. Wakefield got a decent result last weekend though and the Broncos are really going to have to pick up their game. London Broncos will be hoping that Craig Gower is fit for this game. If he is back then they have a chance. Tim Smith is the indicator for Wakefield - some of the ball he set up for them against Hull KR was just superb. He is one hell of a good player.

TERRY PREDICTS: Wakefield by 10 points

Barrie says: London have a good record in this fixture as Wakefield do not tend to travel well down to the capital. However, with what we saw from Wakefield, last weekend, especially in the forwards; the criticism that Richard Agar gave them after their first round performance really spurred them on.

BARRIE PREDICTS: Wakefield by eight points

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments


ne of the conclusions from this list is that Man City should never buy a striker in January - good luck Wilfried Bony....

F365's Top Ten Worst January Panic Buys


was there, it was embarrassing - the team looked totally unbalanced from the off, the defence was woeful and when Mikel came off injured it got even worse with nobody in front of them. Up front on several occasions we had opportunities and nobody would shoot - it was a complete farse! On the back of Salah's performance I'm glad there is talk of getting shot...

Cup defeat shames Mourinho


reat to see Tommy Rosicky getting some love. A wonderful player. Such a pity we lost so long to injury. I was so excited when we signed him, this resurgence only makes the absences seem more of a lost opportunity.

16 Conclusions: FA Cup Fourth Round Weekend

Footer 365

Transfer news: Fiorentina will only consider Juan Cuadrado sale if Chelsea meet 35m euro asking price

Sky sources say Fiorentina will not sell Juan Cuadrado to Chelsea this month unless their full 35m euro asking price is met.

Capital One Cup: Liverpool boss Brendan Rodgers says Chelsea's Diego Costa was lucky to avoid a red card

Liverpool boss Brendan Rodgers believes Chelsea's Diego Costa was lucky to stay on the field in the Capital One Cup semi-final.

Capital One Cup: Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho insists Diego Costa does not deserve retrospective action after Emre Can stamp

Jose Mourinho thinks Chelsea's Diego Costa should be left alone to play football after a controversial outing on Tuesday.

Mail Box

'Diego Costa Is A Thug.' Sore Losers..?

There is plenty of fallout from Diego Costa's stamps of authority on Tuesday's League Cup semi-final. Plus Blatter, Rodgers' substitutions and stretching the transfer truth...

The Problem With FA Cup Shocks... that the draw for the next round is pretty shocking. Blackburn v Stoke, anybody? We also have mails on LVG and ManUnited, who drew plenty under Fergie...

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company