Brian v Sachin

Brian Lara and Sachin Tendulkar will do down as two of the finest Test cricketers of all time - but which one was better?

Last Updated: 18/03/13 at 10:30 Post Comment

Lara: batted with pizzazz, says Athers

Lara: batted with pizzazz, says Athers

That was the question up for debate amongst Sky Sports pundits Mike Atherton, Paul Collingwood and Steve Harmison whilst rain curtailed day four of the second Test between New Zealand and England.

West Indian icon Lara, who retired from the five-day game in 2006, amassed 34 centuries in his 131 matches and a batting average of 52.88, while he still holds the record for the highest individual score in a Test innings with the 400 not out he accrued against England in 2004.

India's Tendulkar, meanwhile, is the only man to accumulate over 15,000 Test match runs, has a higher average than Lara (54.29) and 51 five-day tons, although he has figured in 65 more Tests than his Trinidadian rival.

Former England skipper Atherton lavished praise on both men but says he would choose Tendulkar's all-round excellence over Lara's panache if he could only pick one of them in a Test match team.

"I would still say Sir Viv Richards is the greatest of all time, though (Lara and Tendulkar) are undoubtedly two of the best players to ever play the game," said the Times writer.

"Test cricket is a game of aesthetics as well as numbers, though, and if I was a spectator I would prefer to watch Lara as I think he just pips Tendulkar in terms of style and grace.

"When he came out to bat he was slightly more vulnerable than Tendulkar, but once he got in he could take the micky out of you by hitting the ball in any gaps in the field.

"However, if I was a selector I would probably choose Tendulkar as he is someone who can bat for his life against pace and spin in all conditions, while his ability to cope with the deification and scrutiny from the Indian public for 20-odd years is a hallmark of his greatness.

"I've never seen such a great player less involved in the game, though; usually top players are right at the heart of things in the slips but Tendulkar is often having a graze at deep cover and nattering with the crowd.

"It's almost like he saves his energy for batting."

Steve Harmison

"If you tried to bounce and hit Brian he would come at you, go hard at the ball and give you a chance. Sachin can bat for six hours at the same pace but Brian liked to go through the gears and while he could get a big score and make you want to have an extra fielder, he might not last that long. Lara was one of those batsmen, like Kevin Pietersen, who could light up a crowd, but for his ability to stick around, I'd rather have Sachin in my team."

Paul Collingwood

"Sachin is a fantastic player of spin as he was brought up on Mumbai wickets but it was incredible how Lara used his feet, hands and flair and hit over extra cover to the spinners; Mushtaq Ahmed used to say that he couldn't bowl at him! They could both play on flat, bouncy wickets, too, but I think Tendulkar, the more technically correct of the two, was probably the more consistent player."

Let us know YOUR thoughts on the Lara-Tendulkar debate by filling in the feedback form below.

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

H

e doesn't need a caoch. He needs a bus. A bloody big one, that he can park across the goal line. And when he gets one, he can do us a favour and let us know where we can buy one from as well.

HarryBoulton
Rodgers: No defence coach

Y

ou are wrong Per, thats the right way the play. Its everyone elses' fault that it doesnt work.

delboy
Mertesacker urges style change

A

s it's panto season coming soon, let me be the first Oh yes you do

munchie
Rodgers: No defence coach

Footer 365

La Liga: Carlo Ancelotti praises 'professional' Real Madrid after 3-1 Barcelona win

Carlo Ancelotti praised Real Madrid's "unique professionalism" after they came from a goal down to beat Barcelona.

Premier League: Mauricio Pochettino says Alan Pardew deserves more respect

Tottenham boss Mauricio Pochettino admits it is tough not to feel sorry for Newcastle counterpart Alan Pardew.

La Liga: Luis Enrique stands by Luis Suarez selection after Barcelona defeat

Luis Enrique defended his decision to start Luis Suarez against Real Madrid after his team slumped to a 3-1 defeat.

Mail Box

'Goals Like That Can Make You Pregnant'

Those being sniffy about Erik Lamela's rabona are given short shrift in the afternoon mailbox, where criticism of Brendan Rodgers is smashed out of the park...

Does David De Gea Need Competition?

It would certainly be a good idea to give Victor Valdes a contract, while we have more mails on Brendan Rodgers, Arsene Wenger, the rabona and mailbox gripes...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property