A shell shocker

Ian Smith said New Zealand played well enough to beat England at Lord's before their vulnerability resurfaced in a shocking fourth innings collapse.

Last Updated: 19/05/13 at 15:33 Post Comment

McCullum: his men were undone by Broad on Sunday

McCullum: his men were undone by Broad on Sunday

At 12.30pm on the fourth day of the first Test, the former Black Caps wicket-keeper felt Brendon McCullum's side were in good shape after they were set a target of 239 to win the game.

But by 2.30pm they had been skittled for just 68 runs, as James Anderson and, in particular, Stuart Broad, turned on the style for England.

And Smith said this defeat will hurt more than the losses they suffered in South Africa because they were so competitive in the first three-and-a-half days at the Home of Cricket.

He told Sky Sports: "I'm a little bit shell-shocked by what unfolded in the last couple of hours because up until that point they played the equal of England in the game, perhaps even a little bit better in a lot of areas.

"It all just turned so poor so quickly. I don't know whether you sit back and reflect too much on a performance like that because it can perhaps do you damage.

"[The defeat in] South Africa was consistently on the back of some overall bad performances, never being in the game, but they were in the game for a long time here.

"The thing that will hurt them most when they sit down and reflect as individuals on what they could have done better is that the underlying factor will be we could have won.

"We could have won this game because we played well enough for most of it."

Stupid

Smith says New Zealand's batsmen have a soft underbelly that can too readily be exposed by consistent seam bowling.

And he said the form of Broad, who bagged seven wickets in just 11 overs on Sunday afternoon, was too much for the tourists to handle.

"They put it in the right areas more often than perhaps we expected," he added.

"We came to the ground looking at Swann and all these stats about spin bowling and he never got close to having a bowl. That's how quickly it all unfolded and how unpredictably stupid this game can be at times.

"There is a vulnerability about this New Zealand side and the underbelly was again exposed, but I think their mindset was to play like we play.

"There's enough strikers and enough positive players in that side to suggest if they'd got one partnership or one-and-a-half partnerships together of note at a decent rate then Alastair Cook might have had something to think about.

"There's a quality of consistency in the bowling here. That was good bowling; there was some average judgment at times outside off-stump, but there were some damned good deliveries and consistent stuff.

"Like England, they have been batting on those good pitches [in New Zealand] remember and had their way with the English attack for quite some time.

"Not this time around."

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

N

ow is the time for Allardyce to finally get a chance at a big club please. He is likely to have a number of great offers for his services this summer, but who will he choose? Will it be Liverpool, Real Madrid, Dortmund or Man City?

medina_sod
Allardyce leaves West Ham

I

thought exactly this when the Match of the Day pundits were peddling this line. Is it really not okay for fans of a club to have some ambition these days then?

damoceltic
Bored Of Big Sam? It's Your Right...

H

ow magnanimous off him - to leave if he's asked to by the owners? What's the alternative, bunker down in his office claiming squatter's rights if FSG want rid?

feed the bear
Rodgers: I'll go if owners want

Footer 365

Ian Baraclough was delighted Motherwell's game plan worked at Ibrox

Ian Baraclough says Motherwell's game plan worked perfectly as they won 3-1 at Rangers in the Premiership play-off final

Stuart McCall disappointed by slack Rangers in Motherwell defeat

Stuart McCall says Rangers gave their poorest performance under him as they lost their play-off tie against Motherwell

Chris Coleman hopeful Wales will not lost points from Israel win

Wales manager Chris Coleman fears his side would be badly affected if they lose points from their European Qualifier against Israel.

Mail Box

What Is It That FIFA Actually Do?

That's the question raised timidly by someone sat at the back of the room, whilst others remind that UEFA aren't perfect either. Plus a few more gone on to better XIs...

Time To Step Up, Mr Platini...

UEFA should step up and extend the Euros to replace FIFA's tarnished World Cup, say a couple of mailboxers. Also: all hail Carlo, King of the Kop, and plenty more Budget XIs...

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company