Monday Moan: Rio right, press are wrong

Mark Holmes blasts the English media's treatment of San Marino, defends Rio Ferdinand's England snub and backs footballers' right to be rich.

Last Updated: 25/03/13 at 23:35 Post Comment

England: Comfortable victors against San Marino

England: Comfortable victors against San Marino

More of the games that matter

Upgrade in minutes or watch with a NOW TV Day Pass.

English media shows its (lack of) class

Since Friday night, you will have read or heard plenty of people arguing the pointlessness of international games between the likes of England and San Marino.

To many, an 8-0 win for Roy Hodgson's side in Serravalle confirmed their opinion that San Marino and the other lowest ranked teams in international football should have to play in a pre-qualifying tournament to earn the right to play actual qualifiers for the World Cup.

You may have noticed that none of these opinions came from anyone associated with San Marino.

No, while San Marino's coach, Giampaolo Mazza, spoke excitedly before the game about "the biggest event in our football history" and has previously said his team "takes part in this competition with every right", English football pundits are united in their belief that the minnows gain nothing from games like Friday's.

The punditry on ITV was so patronising that the San Marino FA even took to Twitter to complain.

"You should do something with this ITV's arrogant, ignorant and rude comments and coverages about us, San Marino," read one tweet, aimed at the English FA. "This is just disgraceful," read another.

They had a point. Who are we to decide what is good for San Marino? Do all those pundits calling for a pre-qualifying tournament really care about the San Marino team, or do they just not want to have to watch England playing against such inferior opposition?

The other two teams at the bottom of FIFA's rankings are Bhutan, in South Asia, and Turks and Caicos Islands, in the Antilles. Presumably those calling for pre-qualifiers have no problem with the lowest-ranked teams travelling to other continents to play games?

It would be interesting, also, to hear where they feel the cut-off point should be. Andorra, for example, are the world's sixth-lowest ranked team, yet were beaten only 2-0 by England in the opening qualifying game for the last World Cup. Was that, too, a pointless exercise?

No matter how small their chances of success, San Marino have earned their right to play in games such as Friday night's, just as England often earn the chance to play in major tournaments despite knowing a superior team will knock them out.

The bottom line is that no English person has the right to say what games San Marino should and should not be playing in.

Ferdinand criticism over the top

Regardless of what side of the fence you sit on regarding his snub, it is impossible to deny Rio Ferdinand has been made to look bad by his decision to fly to Qatar to commentate on Friday night's game having refused a call-up because of an "intricate, pre-planned fitness programme".

Ferdinand would have faced criticism even if he had agreed to cover on the game from the UK, and he would likely have faced criticism had he travelled to Qatar, as he had always planned, but not agreed to any punditry work.

It is common for Premier League teams to spend mid-season breaks in the Middle East, but Ferdinand was always going to be under scrutiny after snubbing his call-up. He should have had the sense to turn down the TV work.

However, Ferdinand should not be criticised for the initial snub.

After being left out of Roy Hodgson's Euro 2012 squad for "footballing reasons" and not receiving the merest hint since then that he could yet win a recall, it's fair to say his call-up for the San Marino and Montenegro qualifiers would have come as a shock.

It's also fair to say that the 34-year-old's fitness has been handled extremely well by Manchester United's medical staff this season, hence it was understandable that the club expressed concerns about him playing two unexpected games for England during a period when he was due to rest.

Ferdinand has not come out of this smelling of roses, but he's not the first person to put his fitness before his international career, and he won't be the last.

Talent deserves to get rich

There was a story on the back page of the Sunday Mirror declaring that football has 'gone mad' because of the size of the contract 17-year-old Ruben Loftus-Cheek is on at Chelsea.

His two-and-a-half-year deal is said to be worth £1.7million in wages, signing-on fees, loyalty payments and allowances, a figure which understandably raises eyebrows among those outside of football.

However, it is not unusual for top clubs' most talented youngsters to be on such eye-popping amounts - in Loftus-Cheek's case, Chelsea were fighting off interest from Manchester United, Manchester City and Barcelona - and nor should anyone be offended by it.

Top-flight football clubs earn an extortionate amount of money each season, and surely a good proportion of that money should be going to the people that make the brand and the product what it is - the players.

Would those that complain about players' salaries rather more money went to the likes of Roman Abramovich, Sheikh Mansour and the Glazers?

The strangest thing about that article in the Sunday Mirror was that surprise was expressed amount the money earned by the player, Loftus-Cheek, but not the £1.3million an agent was attempting to claim for his part in allegedly brokering the deal.

Of all the people that make money out of football, the players should be the ones supporters have least issue with. At least they give something back.

It is also noticeable that complaints are not heard about the riches earned by golfers, tennis stars or Formula One drivers.

Of the world's top 10 richest sports stars, only three - Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo and David Beckham - are footballers. Yet when was the last time you heard anyone complain about the salary of golfers Tiger Woods (#1) and Phil Mickelson (#5), tennis star Roger Federer (#4) or F1's Michael Schumacher (#10)?

Nobody should complain about the money earned by the world's best footballers, but instead about the money siphoned away by all those faceless people that give nothing back to the game whatsoever.

You can follow me on Twitter here.

TEAMtalk Facebook Fan Page

The TEAMtalk fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

S

terling needs to be told though that upon entering the Arsenal squad he will re-enact the final scene from Highlander where he will be thrown around a warehouse by cartoon dragons and then be a mere mortal that will only ever spend three to four weeks a season playing football and the rest on the physio's bed. There can be only one.....player available at The Emirates.

rodger's gusset
Arsenal interest in Sterling

T

he game changed in our favour when Carrick came on. We were able to play further up the pitch due to having a player who can give and go with the ball and keep possession. Yet barkley made some runs and Townsend scored a good goal but carrick's inclusion and chiellini's withdrawal made the biggest difference to the flow of the game

ricky villa
Hodgson: Barkley was brilliant

N

o, you've not silenced anyone Andros, i'm afraid. We know you can score a great goal, and it's really handy to have your direct running and willingness to shoot on the bench. But until you can do the other things expected of a winger (beat the man, put a decent cross in, stay wide etc) then you can't expect more than a regular cameo. Wonderful goal though, what a hit! No wonder Buffon wanted the shirt.

badwolf
Townsend: I've silenced critics

Footer 365

Raheem Sterling will not resume Liverpool contract talks until the summer

Raheem Sterling has confirmed that he will not resume talks over a new contract with Liverpool until the summer.

Celtic manager Ronny Deila keen on new loan for Jason Denayer

Celtic manager Ronny Deila will try to persuade Jason Denayer and Manchester City to extend the centre-back's loan.

De Gea: United 'cannot' fail

David De Gea says that Manchester United must qualify for the Champions League next season "no matter what".

Mail Box

Is This The End Of Ex-Players As Managers?

Do massive wages and cushty TV numbers signal the end of the ex-high-profile player turned manager? Plus Liverpool fans don't actually say the 'next year' thing...

A Solution For The Premier League's 39th Game...

One morning Mailboxer solves the 39th game conundrum. Plus England were actually alright, Harry Kane is rubbish again and do Arsenal have the most embarrassing fans?

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company