Villa Park

Next Game

A Villa v Everton

Saturday, 02 May 2015, 15:00

Barclays Prem

Etihad Stadium

Last Game

Man City 3 - 2 A Villa

Saturday, 25 April 2015, 17:30

Barclays Prem

Bennett this season's Villan

Aston Villa FanZoner Tom Davis reflects on what has been a difficult first season at the club for defender Joe Bennett.

Last Updated: 08/05/13 at 11:50 Post Comment

Joe Bennett: The culprit for Villa's defensive woes

Joe Bennett: The culprit for Villa's defensive woes

More of the games that matter

Upgrade in minutes or watch with a NOW TV Day Pass.

There are some roles in football that never change. The striker at the tip of the triangle is there to score goals just as much as the goalkeeper down at the bottom is there to prevent them. Yet full-backs are a completely different animal.

From being the sturdy and reliable engine to track back and forth at the back, they now require the sort of qualities the number nine up-front can't even master in training. However, in a season where defensive errors have often been our downfall, one player has caused us more grief than joy - and isn't it time we put an end to this misery?

Bennett is obviously the culprit here. It's a telling sign of his ability that this piece was written before his error against Norwich and not after, as he has a mistake waiting in him for almost every game. If it wasn't for Gabriel Agbonlahor's goals we would have dropped two valuable points. It could have even been enough to see us drop down a league as a consequence.

But it wasn't just against Norwich that he let us down.

He has made a collection of mistakes time and time again. Lambert's philosophy has required full-backs with a burning ambition to attack, particularly given our lack of an orthodox out-and-out winger. Yet, and forgive me for sounding old fashioned here, when I see four defenders in the back-line the first thing I want them to do is defend - and Gordon Bennett, he simply does not know the meaning of the word!

You could point to full-backs all around the top European leagues and argue that the traditional number threes are a dying breed - Marcelo, Phillip Lahm and Ashley Cole being prime examples of what a modern-day full-back can bring to the table.

Take it down a notch and Matt Lowton's performances this season have nailed almost every desire you could want from a full-back down to a tee. Bennett could go a long way in learning from his style. But then again an attacking full-back is only a bonus if they can defend in the first place. If they can't do the latter then you have to raise questions on their inclusion in the squad. Unfortunately for Bennett, he falls into this category.

He can be infuriating at times. "Kick him! Punch him! Stand up...do something!" the crowd collectively screams as he offers the opposing winger enough time on the ball to stop and tie his shoe-laces twice over. For all his bright play surging forward, his demeanour is so fragile in defence you can almost feel him flaking away at the very sight of a quick pair of feet - or even a slow pair for that matter.

Lowton's stature isn't much greater, but his aggression and commitment to a challenge - not to mention his positional sense and decision making - already places him far further in the pecking order, despite coming from relatively similar backgrounds. He now has a real chance to build on this season and establish himself as an England international.

Bennett is a talented player when given freedom on the ball and you can't help but want him to succeed at the club. But as a full-back? It'll never work. In a defence that has conceded the third highest number of goals in the league this season, defensive reinforcements are surely a priority for us in the summer and the left-back position should be high on our list. He is simply not good enough and that is not a difficult assumption to make.

You could give him the benefit of the doubt and say at 23 he still has time to develop, but if a defender struggles to master the art of defending now then what hope does he have in the future? I can't help but feel he would be better off shaping his role towards becoming a wide-midfielder. With his sweet left-foot, direct runs and pin-point crossing ability he could easily emulate his fellow Middlesbrough graduate, Stewart Downing. Oh wait, Stewart who? Forget you heard that name!

By Tom Davis, FanZone's Aston Villa blogger. Follow him on Twitter at @tomdav1991 - and don't forget to follow @FanZone too!

TEAMtalk Facebook Fan Page

The TEAMtalk fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

I

t's why Mourinho is so successful. He gives players a specific, limited set of functions to perform. They are but a cog in a machine. Do no more, do no less. I assume he learnt it from LvG :)

red_devil83
Fellaini Has Politely Become Undroppable

I

really hope that someone in the mainstream media spots that the Bayern manager played for and managed Barcelona quite well, and thinks to mention it in the build up. That would be really interesting.

megabrow (cufc)
Barcelona to face Bayern

Y

our gob says one thing, Brendan, the results say something else.

balls-to-monty
Rodgers bullish over Anfield future

Footer 365

Marouane Fellaini: I never lost my quality during first Man Utd season

Marouane Fellaini has taken a swipe at his critics, saying his fruitful time at Everton was "quickly forgotten".

Everton 3-0 Manchester United: Louis van Gaal's side suffer second straight Premier League defeat

Everton beat Manchester United 3-0 at Goodison Park to inflict a second straight Premier League loss on Louis van Gaal's side.

Oscar concern for Chelsea as he suffers possible concussion

Chelsea forward Oscar has suffered a possible concussion, according to his manager Jose Mourinho.

Mail Box

Chelsea Millions Should Buy Better...

For the money they have spent, Chelsea should be playing like the Harlem Globetrotters rather than Atletico. We have mails on Cesc, Brendan Rodgers and...

Brendan Rodgers Is David Cameron...

Rodgers is compared to the Prime Minister, insomuch as he has a right to peddle bulls**t, apparently. Plus why comparing Arsene Wenger to Diego Simeone is a mug's game...

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company