Swansea v Man Utd tactical analysis

Adam Bate takes an in-depth tactical look at Manchester United's 4-1 win over Swansea at the Liberty Stadium on Saturday.

Last Updated: 18/08/13 at 21:08 Post Comment

Danny Welbeck and Robin van Persie provided a finishing masterclass against Swan

Danny Welbeck and Robin van Persie provided a finishing masterclass against Swan

More of the games that matter

Upgrade in minutes or watch with a NOW TV Day Pass.

With Manchester City spending big and Chelsea welcoming the returning Jose Mourinho, Manchester United have found themselves installed as third favourites to retain their Premier League title. The Old Trafford faithful might feel a little bemused by that after a 4-1 win over Swansea at the Liberty Stadium ensured it was three points for David Moyes in his first league game in charge.

Robin Van Persie and Danny Welbeck scored a goal apiece before the break - and then duly repeated the feat after the interval. Swansea new boy Wilfried Bony did get a goal for the home side in the second-half but by that stage the points had been sealed with Wayne Rooney coming off the bench to provide a couple of assists. Here we take an in-depth look at the game...


The focus before kick-off was on Rooney as the forward was named among the Manchester United substitutes. That intrigue aside, Moyes went with a predictable line-up by picking nine of the players who won the FA Community Shield at Wembley last weekend, including Michael Carrick who missed England's game against Scotland on Wednesday through injury. Antonio Valencia replaced Wilfried Zaha on the right, while the suspension of Rafael saw Rio Ferdinand come in to partner Nemanja Vidic as Phil Jones moved to right-back.

Swansea's season was already up and running due to their involvement in the Europa League but the two-goal hero from the 4-0 demolition of Malmo was omitted. Ivory Coast international Bony was left on the bench after playing for his country against Mexico in New Jersey in midweek. That decision by Michael Laudrup saw Michu - who had scored in his two previous games against the Premier League champions - play as the lone frontman with Jonjo Shelvey in support. Jose Canas made his league debut in midfield in an otherwise familiar Swans line-up.

Where it was won and lost

In the early stages there was little to suggest United would go into the break two goals up. Swansea began brightly, closing down high up the field and playing their customary passing game. In fact, United didn't get a kick of the ball in the first minute and Ferdinand was only just able to cut out a Shelvey through-ball in the second. "There's only one team playing football at the moment," noted Sky Sports pundit Gary Neville in the 14th minute.

But when you have Robin van Persie, you have the difference maker. His presence once again proved that dominance and fluidity are not prerequisites for victory. And while Victor Anichebe battled manfully for Moyes last season at Everton, it's a different story when the Dutchman can bail you out like this. His opening goal turned the game and the fact that he added to it means he now has nine goals in his last eight Premier League appearances.

Laudrup will be frustrated by how the opener came about as slack defending saw Chico sucked towards the ball, while Angel Rangel played Van Persie onside from the right-back position. It still required remarkable vision from Ryan Giggs to loft the pass over the defence rather than play the anticipated short pass and Van Persie was able to do the rest with a powerful finish on his weaker right foot.

Searching for evidence of Moyes' influence is a tricky business when the champions are so experienced and the wait for the Scot's first signing goes on. But given the way that Leighton Baines was such an important part of Everton's attacking play over recent seasons, it was interesting to note the performance of Patrice Evra. The French left-back played in an advanced role reminiscent of Baines, with his average position being more akin to that of Valencia than Jones on the opposite flank. It was effective as Evra provided the cross that led to Welbeck's first goal and United's second to double the lead late in the first half.

Laudrup changed things around at half-time in an attempt to get back into it but given that United have won 133 of the 136 Premier League games in which they've had a lead of two goals or more at the break, it was a forlorn hope. The belated arrival of Bony in favour of Leon Britton did provide Michu with some support and there were some encouraging signs for Swansea in the way the two forwards interacted. A cushioned header from Bony almost set-up his team-mate before he was able to mark his Premier League debut with a goal himself thanks to a composed finish.

However, by that point we'd been treated to the introduction of Rooney - given a generous reception by the travelling support. Any fears of an inhibited performance by the purportedly wantaway forward soon dissipated. Not only did he provide the quick lay-off to find Van Persie in the build-up to the third goal, he also followed it up with the driving run that bought his colleague the split second he needed. Rooney's overlap caused Ashley Williams to back off slightly and Van Persie did the rest.

After Bony pulled one back with his goal, Rooney had a second assist. But the game's final goal was all about Welbeck. The statistic that the England forward scored just one Premier League goal last season seems to have entered popular culture over the summer and it must grate with the man himself. For while Welbeck's overall contributions continues to be praised there is no disputing the fact that he needs to score more goals. Two here means that the 2012/13 tally has been doubled on the opening day and if the first was the sort of tap-in he must deliver more regularly, the second was an exquisite chip that highlighted his class.

Two assists for Rooney. Two brilliant goals from Van Persie. Two - yes, two - goals from Welbeck. Moyes may be on the look-out for a midfielder but it's worth remembering that it was the sheer goalscoring power of Manchester United that fired them to the title last time out. If the evidence of Saturday is anything to go by then there's every chance of a repeat - no matter what the bookmakers say.

Swansea v Man Utd
SwanseaMan Utd
Chances Created139
Big Chances Created21

Laudrup view

"For the first half an hour everything went as planned. We did what we should do and passed the ball around. I think they had one shot on target and suddenly you saw that difference. A very difficult finish from Van Persie and then the second one we made a couple of mistakes there. Two goals in two minutes - it's too difficult to come back from there. I made changes at half-time and we had a few chances. But again, you saw the class of Van Persie. The third goal is outstanding and then you know it is finished. In the end you just have to say the difference was in the finishing."

Moyes view

"Swansea had a lot of the ball but I think that any team who comes down here will find that they pass it very well. But we limited them to very few opportunities and although we probably scored a little bit against the run of play it was a brilliant goal. The goals we scored were quality goals. It was that little bit of difference and we've got that. We could have played a little bit better in the game but overall I'm more than happy with winning the game 4-1."

Jamie's view

"It's been a perfect day for David Moyes. I think the performance of Van Persie - we all knew what Van Persie could do. But Moyes will be even more delighted by Danny Welbeck today. He challenged him to get more goals in pre-season and he's delivered. All the question marks about whether he could handle the pressure, he's proved that today. It's a great performance. Swansea were just a little bit flat. Not quite at the level we are used to seeing them play. It didn't feel like they had that incisive aspect to them. The goals took the sting out of them."

Player ratings

It's natural that the summer focus should be on the likes of Luis Suarez, Wayne Rooney and Gareth Bale as the transfer speculation continues. But this was a timely reminder who the Premier League's main man still is. No prizes for guessing the Sky Sports man of the match award went to Robin van Persie. His opener changed the course of the game and his second goal sealed it. Van Persie received a 9/10 mark for his performance but his new manager might well feel it was rather better than that. "He has been the difference," said Gary Neville. "A special player."

TEAMtalk Facebook Fan Page

The TEAMtalk fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments


till reckon Chelsea will go for Khedira as back up for Matic. I think it will turn out to be quite a Mourihno-y window: We'll see the squad players and youth in action pre-season, say things like well, we need not buy anybody and then the club will bid £60m for Pogba and send everybody on loan.

F365's Transfer Guide - Part One


would love to be a fly on the wall at the meeting between Milner and Rodgers. I don't know if flies can count, but if they can then I would be counting the number of times Rodgers used the word outstanding in his attempts to get Milner to sign.

Reds and Arsenal chase Milner


ell, it wouldn't be a summer without Arsenal fans fretting over losing a key player, and United throwing their weight around and muscling in on transfer deals which are (apparently) near to completion. If we can't be entertained by the football on the pitch, let's enjoy the silly off-pitch soap opera of the transfer season. Hurrah!

The Back To It Gossip

Footer 365

Gundogan yet to make decision on future

Borussia Dortmund midfielder Ilkay Gundogan could yet join Manchester United this summer, according to a report from Germany.

Liverpool close in on Milner - Report

Want-away Man City midfielder James Milner could be announced as a Liverpool player by the end of the week, according to reports.

Atleti, Arsenal and Liverpool target Vietto

Villarreal are reportedly attempting to renegotiate Luciano Vietto's contract to ward off interest from Atletico Madrid, Arsenal and Liverpool.

Mail Box

Calling Carlo For Liverpool... Please

One Liverpool Mailer wants a manager who isn't starstruck by the job. Plus why Milner has now become overrated, play-offs for the title, Ronaldinho and democracy..

James Milner: Jose's Perfect Player?

Probably. But presumably he would not swap one bench for another. We have mails on over-hyped players, Arsenal enthusiasm, UEFA, FIFA and naked dudes...

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company