Villa slipped up

A costly individual error - not referee Mike Dean - was to blame for Aston Villa's defeat to Manchester City, Gary Neville told Monday Night Football.

Last Updated: 09/03/13 at 11:48 Post Comment

Tevez: netted the decisive goal just before half-time

Tevez: netted the decisive goal just before half-time

The champions battled to a 1-0 win at Villa Park with Carlos Tevez's first-half injury-time goal proving decisive.

However, in the build up to the goal Edin Dzeko had robbed Ciaran Clark of the ball, just inside the Villa defender's half - a challenge the Irishman was unhappy with.

And Villa's frustrations were later compounded when their second-half penalty appeals were waved away after Matija Nastasic had felled Christian Benteke in the box and seemingly handled the ball.

Neville conceded that on another day the decisions may have fallen in Villa's favour, but he felt the officials were not in a position to award fouls in either instance - and criticised Clark for holding onto the ball for too long.

"The two decisions are not howlers by the ref at all," he said. "For the goal Clark dwells on the ball and he shouldn't do that in that position - he just needs to get rid of it.

"(Mike) Dean is a long way away and you see his arm come up and it looks like he's going to give a foul and he doesn't. I don't think he's sure and he maybe thinks Clark has slipped.

"He puts his whistle to his mouth, decides not to give the foul and then Carlos Tevez shows great composure and slips it round the goalkeeper.

"From an Aston Villa perspective you can't get caught dwelling on the ball. Clark, as much as he feels he's been fouled, will know he's made a mistake.

Difficult

"And then, in the second half, there are definitely claims for a penalty - but it's a really difficult decision to give because of the angle of the referee.

"Nastasic's right leg kicks Benteke in the shin and the ball then goes up and hits Nastasic's hand. I'm not sure you can do anything about the handball - that would be hash - but there are claims for a penalty.

"Benteke claimed for a handball not the kick, while the linesman was blocked and it was hard for the ref to see.

"So, there are two big decisions in the match and the referees have been in positions where it's been difficult for them to see the contacts or fouls."

The result leaves Villa in the relegation zone on goal difference and, when asked to comment on their survival chances, Neville pointed to their upcoming games against fellow strugglers Reading and QPR as vital contests in their bid to stay up.

"I think it's going to be tough [for them to avoid relegation]," he said. "It's easy to sit on the fence and say 'we'll know more after the games against Reading and QPR' - but that's the reality of it for them.

"The Clark mistake is the sort of silly mistake you can't keep making in that area because they're the ones that cripple you in the end."

Unlikely

Title holders City reduced the gap between themselves and table toppers Manchester United to 12 points with victory at Villa Park, but Neville feels they face a huge task to overhaul his former side.

And he says he cannot see Sir Alex Ferguson's men conceding enough points to give Roberto Mancini's charges the opportunity to catch up.

"City will hope what happened last season can happen again," he said, referring to City coming from eight points behind with six games to play to win the league in 2011/12.

"When you're the chasing team you need something to happen, though. You can concentrate on your own games but the games are dwindling down now and there are only 10 to go.

"United need to lose four or five games and City need to win every one of their matches. That's highly unlikely.

"City need United to start getting injuries, losing form and conceding goals - everything that's not happening at the moment. United look comfortable."

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

C

an we get one on the similarities between this year's Arsenal and 5 years ago. Or any other number you care to pick frankly...it shouldn't be hard.

mc1728
Liverpool: Five Similiarities Five Years On

R

icky van Wolfswinkel's remarkable record of one goal from one game at least deserves an honourable mention. And I'm willing to bet that at least one of Costa, Ulloa or Enner Valencia will earn a place on the list by the end of the season. Probably not Costa

stevenjameshyde
Top Ten PL Strikers Who Started Like A Train...

I

will also give up birthday Christmas and bacon for this to happen

badwolf
Ronaldo return ‘in place’

Footer 365

Premier League: Jose Mourinho confirms Eden Hazard's Chelsea contract talks ongoing

Jose Mourinho is confident Eden Hazard will commit his future to Chelsea, with talks ongoing over a contract extension.

Daley Blind backs Louis van Gaal's brutally honest approach at Manchester United

Daley Blind says Manchester United boss Louis van Gaal's brutally honest manner is good for team-building.

Premier League: Manchester United winger Angel di Maria delighted with Old Trafford bow

Manchester United winger Angel di Maria was delighted with his Old Trafford debut after the 4-0 win over QPR.

Mail Box

Who's More Miserable - Baggies Or Mags?

There's not a lot to choose between the misery of West Brom fans and the misery of Newcastle fans. We have mails on them, 'only QPR' and lots on Man United...

Forget it, Ronaldo Won't Come Back

A varied morning mailbox, with thoughts on Ronaldo, Daley Blind = Michael Carrick, Ed Woodward redemption, stick with Pardew, QPR's name change and marbles...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property