Off-colour Hart victim of harsh treatment

TEAMtalk guest Frank Malley says the level of criticism for Joe Hart is unjustified and calls for perspective when judging the England keeper.

Last Updated: 15/11/12 at 17:04 Post Comment

Joe Hart: Not in good form at present

Joe Hart: Not in good form at present

More of the games that matter

Upgrade in minutes or watch with a NOW TV Day Pass.

There is no getting away from it. Joe Hart has not had a good couple of months.

The England goalkeeper was to blame for Poland's equaliser in Warsaw in World Cup qualifying last month when he came off his line but failed to gather a corner kick which was headed in by Kamil Glik.

He has not been at his best for Manchester City in the Premier League so far this season and in England's 4-2 defeat against Sweden on Wednesday he was directly responsible for at least two of Zlatan Ibrahimovic's four goals, including the extraordinary fourth, the overhead propellor-kick following Hart's tame header on the edge of the penalty area.

But does Hart really deserve to be up there with bankers, estate agents and 'I'm A Celebrity, Get Me Out Of Here' MP Nadine Dorris on the list of individuals people seemingly love to hate?

Does he really deserve the treatment meted out by the phone-ins and football forums which were full of hysterical tosh following Hart's performance in Stockholm?

"Over-paid", "Over-inflated ego", "Waste of time", "Arrogant", "Too big for his boots", were just some of the jibes aimed at Hart.

It was all so depressingly typical of the tall poppy syndrome which surfaces from time to time in English sport and which can shatter careers.

Why, it was only earlier this year that Hart was backed by some players and pundits to be England captain after being touted as arguably the best goalkeeper in the world.

Better than Spain's Iker Casillas, said some. Better than Italy's Gianluigi Buffon, others argued.

It was only last summer that he was universally lauded as one of the best performers at Euro 2012 after making 19 saves, the most by any goalkeeper in the tournament.

It was only two months ago that former England star Peter Shilton, who knows a thing or two about goalkeeping, tipped him to surpass his record of 125 caps, albeit with a note of caution.

"Joe Hart has done really well, he is still only young, he is still improving, he needs to continue to improve and he needs to work hard at his game," said Shilton.

"He needs to be pushed, he needs to be kept on his toes, because England are relying on him at a time when there isn't a great deal of strength in depth with England goalkeepers."

Perhaps that is where England manager Roy Hodgson missed a trick with Hart in midweek. A meaningless friendly against Sweden surely was the perfect opportunity for Norwich goalkeeper John Ruddy to gain more experience on the international stage.

Or how about a debut for Fraser Forster, the man who produced a world-class performance against Barcelona in the Champions League a week ago in Celtic's 2-1 win, so dazzling that it prompted the Spanish media to nickname him La Gran Muralla, which translates as 'The Great Wall'?

Hart needs to know there is talent snapping at his heels. He needs competition, the sort Shilton had for a time in the 1970s when he shared the England goalkeeping job with Ray Clemence, each pushing the other to greater heights.

He needs to realise that at 25 he is still learning in a position where there is no place to hide.

What Hart does not need, however, is vituperative criticism from those whose opinions sway like a reed in the breeze from match to match. You cannot be the equal of Buffon one minute and a buffoon the next.

The truth lies somewhere in between and it should be remembered that Hart has been operating in recent times behind an England defence which has lost its once-secure axis of John Terry and Rio Ferdinand.

Hart's shot-stopping quality is undeniable. So is his self-confidence. His strategic positioning, however, could do with improvement. He has had a bad couple of months. That is the bottom line and he would be the first to recognise that.

Yet he is still England's finest goalkeeper. By a distance.

By Frank Malley, PA Sport.

TEAMtalk Facebook Fan Page

The TEAMtalk fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

F

irst Townsend, now Chiles. What next ITV? Comedy that you can actually watch without vomiting up your own spleen? I'll be sad to see Matt Smith go though. I actually quite like him. Plus, he was good in Doctor Who.

sailingmagpie
Adrian Chiles to leave ITV

H

e's like Jay from Inbetweeners. Could've had him, had him, didn't want him, turned him down.

lee
Wenger criticises work permits

A

wful, awful pundit. He was crap on BBC, and offered a little more analysis than Robbie Savage - apart from the delivery of banality in a sexy accent. Also, as I'm Irish he'll never be more then a slimy, hand-balling f**ker in my eyes.

batdog
Football People On TV: Thierry Henry

Footer 365

Transfer news: West Brom close to signing Callum McManaman from Wigan

West Brom are close to completing a deal to sign Callum McManaman from Wigan according to Sky sources.

FA Cup fourth round: West Ham boss Sam Allardyce admits relief after 1-0 win at Bristol City

Sam Allardyce admitted he was relieved after West Ham beat Bristol City 1-0 to avoid joining the list of cup casualties.

Serie A round-up: Paul Pogba scores stunner in Juventus win over Chievo as Inter succumb to defeat at Torino

Paul Pogba scored a superb goal and created another as Serie A leaders Juventus beat Chievo 2-0 in Turin.

Mail Box

Appalling, Slow, Pathetic, Embarrassing

It's a bonus Saturday Mailbox, with plenty of reaction to the most alarming 0-0 draw in Manchester United's recent history. At what point do we worry about Louis van Gaal?

Why Do Man United Look So Impotent?

It's all very well talking about formations and United's defensive problems, but shouldn't their expensive attacking options be doing better? And we talk psychology...

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company