Search

McManaman escape frustrates Toon

Newcastle are "disappointed" after learning that Wigan's Callum McManaman has escaped FA punishment for his tackle on Massadio Haidara.

Post a Comment:

Comments 1 - 10 of (54)

shenkenshalken (Newcastle United) says...

When the FA brought in this rule and agreed it with 'stakeholders' surely in the planning they considered occasions such as this where it wouldn't be fit for purpose? The referee was un-sighted and didn't see it.. okay. The assistant referee DID see it, but not properly. The fact he did see it however (though not properly) is grounds for no action. Hmmm. I think they are making it all up as they go along. The governing bodies are such a disappointment from top to bottom.

Posted 12:02pm 21st March 2013

bernsteinforpm (Manchester City) says...

As I've said previously I don't think he went in maliciously, but that tackle was about as bad as it gets. Can those saying it wasn't as bad as is being made out give an example of a worse tackle (rather than elbows etc...) in the Premiership years (Keane on Haaland aside perhaps)? I guess there may be a few, but surely not many.

Posted 7:59pm 20th March 2013

varicoseregent (Manchester United) says...

@hump3 - It truly was The One Show of sports programmes. You literally had no idea what was coming next.

Posted 3:21pm 20th March 2013

iyibaba (Arsenal) says...

I thought the sports press was bad in this country but this just beats anything even...FIFA, FA gone bonkers HELP we are in trouble!!!!!!

Posted 2:29pm 20th March 2013

Gab1965 says...

So let's get this straight........ The Newcastle assistant manager can end up getting charged over this incident but the Wigan player has got off it completely. Dave Whelan is an idiot, loves talking far too much.

Posted 1:05pm 20th March 2013

hump3 (Ipswich Town) says...

@varicosergent. Trans World Sport. Ahhh, the brilliant thing about that was you just didn't know what sport was on next. Sometimes i wondered whether the commentator knew what was comming on next. You try and script South American football, to Aussie Rules, to Surfing, to Basketball to Tennis to whatever you fail. Sit back and absorb it all like the hallucinogenic scene in 2001 a Space Oddity. I also suspected everyone cheated in kabbadi. I only ever heard badi.

Posted 12:37pm 20th March 2013

varicoseregent (Manchester United) says...

@hump3 - The Saturday mornings of my youth were spent watching Trans World Sport, Kabaddi and American Football on Channel 4. You will never find a greater or more varied juxtaposition of sporting programmes anywhere on the planet.

Posted 11:40am 20th March 2013

mostik (Manchester United) says...

It is a sh*t system but we are stuck with it at the moment, the officials should be punished for missing it!! Not the ref as I think we would all agree he did't/couldn't see the action from his angle and I have respect for the fact he apologised afterwards but the linesman and 4th official must have seen it and so should be punished. I still haven't seen a statement from McManaman has he publicly apologised? He may have done so fair do's but if not he needs to at the very least to show a bit of sportsmanship.

Posted 10:37am 20th March 2013

bez948 says...

Problem is that the FA set precedent in the Ben Thatcher incident some years ago. The referee gave a free kick and booked Thatcher for an aggressive shoulder barge, when it was then later shown to be a clear elbow to the head that nearly killed the player (Mendes I think) they reviewed it and gave hit a 7 match ban. Clearly the referee saw the incident and made a decision but they decided that was'nt severe enough punishment. What has changed in that time? Indeed did Uefa themselves not take retrospective action against Eduardo for diving in a Champions League game (they did then go back on it after appeal)? Just further examples of the ludicrous inconcistencies in the game that can be easily avoided.

Posted 10:35am 20th March 2013

varicoseregent (Manchester United) says...

If they have sucha problem with the current procedures theny why did they, along with everyone else, agree to them at the start of the season?

Posted 10:31am 20th March 2013

Related News

Sky Bet

    • Retrieving latest Sky Bet odds

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

P

erfect replacement for Carragher. Slow, average when he was at his best, now well past it. Would just slot straight in! :)

rez plus
Liverpool eye Kolo move - Report

T

rue. Stoke, Sunderland and Swindon also showed no interest in him.

udangapi
Carra puzzled by no interest

H

ang on, why are journalists asking a manager who has never won a major honour for his opinion on a manger who has won two European Cups and league titles in four different countries?

darcy_171
Sam backs 'mature' Mourinho

Footer 365

Serie A: No Napoli offer for Rafael Benitez but Edin Dzeko is a target

Napoli chief Aurelio De Laurentiis has denied that he has held talks with Rafa Benitez, but admits he wants Edin Dezko.

Klopp's tears over Kagawa fate

Jurgen Klopp is 'heartbroken' at Shinji Kagawa's bit-part role at Manchester United and says the midfielder is one of the world's best players.

Romelu Lukaku waits on Chelsea decision after West Brom loan ends

Romelu Lukaku says his future is out of his hands and he will wait to see what happens when he returns to Chelsea.

Mail Box

Should Chelsea Be Worried About Jose Return?

After a disappointing end to his three years at Real Madrid, could Jose Mourinho struggle to bring immediate success if he completes his anticipated return to Chelsea?

What Would United Be Like In The Pub?

The Premier League season has only been over for about 20 hours and already we're well into the summer-type Mailbox. Plus, a shout for the 2014 player of the year...

Site Map

Our Network

Websites

Partners

Betting & Gaming

Mobile, Fun & Games

© 2013 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved