Reds, WBA & Hull guilty of overspending

WhoScored's Martin Laurence takes a look at which Premier League clubs are guilty of spending over the odds for players in this summer's transfers window.

Last Updated: 17/09/14 at 15:25 Post Comment

Adam Lallana: Joined Liverpool from Southampton this summer

Adam Lallana: Joined Liverpool from Southampton this summer

More of the games that matter

Upgrade in minutes or watch with a NOW TV Day Pass.

In an inflated market it's increasingly easy to overspend in order to secure the services of a wanted man. Clubs set their asking prices sky high in some cases, often to ward off potential suitors but also to exploit those with cash to spare and a real need to spend it.

A whole manner of things can have an effect on a transfer value, including some that really shouldn't. In a goals based business strikers cost more, despite the fact that it is equally important to keep them out at the other end, and despite international failings for decades, English players demand higher fees due to player registration rulings.

The market on who will move where is always interesting to monitor, and you can view odds on various players' next clubs here.

Such factors may well have had an impact on the following 5 deals, with WhoScored.com looking at transfers that were perhaps more expensive than they should have been. This isn't to say that these players are poor or even that they will fail at their respective new clubs, just that perhaps the money could have been spent more wisely.


Adam Lallana (Liverpool)

Let's get arguably the most controversial choice out of the way early. Adam Lallana has always shown promise and an eye for goal from midfield since breaking into the Saints first team and he made the step up to the top-flight in impressive fashion, proving a crucial member of a Southampton side that secured their highest ever Premier League finish last season. The playmaker is now 26 and while it could be argued that Liverpool have signed a player approaching his peak, the question remains as to how much Lallana will really improve from here on in.

Southampton's asking price was high due in no small part to an agreement in place that saw Bournemouth entitled to 25% of a fee that could rise to a lofty £25m. The England international contributed to 15 league goals last season (9 goals, 6 assists) and earned a very respectable rating of 7.20 from WhoScored.com in turn, but he also gave away possession due to a poor touch the second most times (91) and was directly dispossessed more times (93) than any other player in the Premier League. For a side already boasting the likes of Coutinho and Sterling that have since added Lazar Markovic from Benfica, the outlay on Lallana is perhaps steep, despite the need for strength in depth given their renewed European commitments.

Brown Ideye (West Brom)

Having finished just one place above the relegation zone last season, West Brom's problem was clear. The shared top-scorer tally was just 5, between Berahino and Sessegnon, so the fact that new record signing Brown Ideye could only match that tally in the Ukrainian league last season doesn't immediately encourage. The striker's chances were limited in an admittedly impressive Dynamo Kiev attack line, with the Nigerian starting just 7 of 19 league appearances. He did start 5 matches in the Europa League but failed to register on the scoresheet.

It's certainly not all doom and gloom for Baggies fans. Prior to last season Ideye had registered double figures in terms of league goals in each of the previous three campaigns after all and at 25, he has time on his side to acclimatize to a new and improved league. What the deal represents, however, is a big gamble. He impressed in one season in France, earning him a move to Kiev, but his only appearances at the top level over the Europa and Champions League - of which he has made 18 (excluding qualifiers) - have heralded just 2 goals.

Jake Livermore (Hull)

The fact that Hull were convinced to complete the permanent signing of Jake Livermore was no surprise. The midfielder was solid and dependable in the middle of the park and even managed to lead the side in terms of assists, though the tally of 4 was modest enough. The £8m transfer fee was eye-catching though, and is perhaps a clear case of a player's homegrown status taking effect. With The Tigers already well stocked in that department, however, their need to splash the cash was debatable.

Livermore forged a decent partnership with fellow signing from White Hart Lane Tom Huddlestone but is very much a no frills type of player. Solid across the board, he has avoided garnering any statistical weaknesses according to WhoScored.com but has just one strength - long shots - and his rating of 6.80 last season ranked 7th of first team regulars at the KC Stadium. It seems £8m can only really get you a 'decent' English player nowadays.
 

Leonardo Ulloa (Leicester)

The task for a newly-promoted side is always to lure in the sort of quality that can consolidate their position in the league. Leicester's expensive splurge on Leonardo Ulloa can be seen as a real risk, with £7m in all likelihood taking a significant chunk out of their transfer budget. In his 18 months on the South Coast the burly front man certainly became a Brighton fan favourite but at 28, his lack of experience at the very top level is a concern.

He's a hard worker from the front, earning a strength of 'defensive contribution' from WhoScored.com courtesy of 0.9 tackles per game, but his strike rate is certainly not the best. A respectable tally of 14 last season came from 87 shots (16.1% conversion rate) and only two players missed more clear cut chances in the Championship last season (16). Leicester's desire to add to their strike force was understandable given top scorer David Nugent's record at top-flight level but their choice of reinforcement is questionable.

Lukas Jutkiewicz (Burnley)

On a tighter budget than the sides that they came up with, Burnley's mission remains the same. The Clarets need to bolster their attacking ranks was justified following serious injury to Sam Vokes, whose 20-goal exploits were somewhat overshadowed by younger model Danny Ings last season - despite the fact that the Championship Player of the Year netted just once more than his strike partner. Sean Dyche's decision to bring in the likes of Marvin Sordell and Lukas Jutkiewicz in his place will be under scrutiny.

The latter was the more expensive of the two at around £2m but will need to improve on his figures from last season if he is to adapt to the rigours of the Premier League. Once a prospect on the books of Everton, Jutkiewicz is now 25 and has never registered double figures in a league season in English football. A loan spell at Bolton from January certainly saw his stock rise a little after an ultimately disappointing time at Middlesbrough but it would be a surprise if the forward could fire in the goals to help keep Burnley afloat next season.

You can follow Martin on Twitter @martinlaurence7.

All statistics courtesy of WhoScored.com, where you can find yet more stats, including live in-game data and unique player and team ratings.

TEAMtalk Facebook Fan Page

The TEAMtalk fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

L

oved the article. i remember at school, after failing an exam, I would become obscenely secretly happy if I discover that others failed as well. Misery loves company...Now here is to hoping Chelsea joins the party and Stoke city wins the league...Cheers!

gabu
The Premier League: As Crazy As A Bag Of Snakes

C

haos reached its ultimate reckoning last weekend with Tony Hibbert looking assured at left back and Osman looking like a cultured ball playing midfielder before busting a gut to get to the back post for a Samuel Eto'o ball. Different chaos but chaos. If Kone scores the winner tonight I fear the world will end.

jelasfirsttouch
The Premier League: As Crazy As A Bag Of Snakes

A

beautiful demonstration of why stats mean diddly-squat in football.

cheshire-gooner
WhoScored's PL Team Of 2014 So Far...

Footer 365

Premier League: Gus Poyet challenges Sunderland to be the first team to beat Chelsea

Sunderland boss Gus Poyet has challenged his players to become the first team to beat Chelsea this season.

Brandao jailed over headbutt on Motta

Brazilian striker Brandao jailed and fined 20,000 euros (£15,850) for headbutting Paris Saint-Germain's Thiago Motta.

Premier League: Arsenal's Jack Wilshere has ankle surgery and will be out for around three months

Arsenal will be without Jack Wilshere for around three months after the midfielder underwent ankle surgery.

Mail Box

Arsenal Fans Are Full Of Hope Again...

Arsenal fans have been sucked back into believing Wenger can bring the glory years back after beating Borussia Dortmund. Plus, more on Liverpool's worrying decline...

Makes Sense To Make Gerrard Liverpool Manager

That's the thoughts of one Mailboxer, who wants Jamie Carragher as defensive coach. Plus views on Arsenal, Malmo v Juventus, Alexis Sanchez & tremendous improvement...

© 2014 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media property