Daily Debate: Best signing of the summer

After the summer transfer window was finally brought to a close on Monday, two TEAMtalk writers discuss which player will be the best signing.

Last Updated: 17/09/14 at 16:09 Post Comment

Cesc Fabregas: The signing of the summer?

Cesc Fabregas: The signing of the summer?

More of the games that matter

Upgrade in minutes or watch with a NOW TV Day Pass.

In Daily Debate, two TEAMtalk writers give their views on a hot topic and then invite readers to decide who has put forward the best argument.

You can vote for your winner using the story comment facility at the bottom of the article, or by declaring your support on Twitter.

Who is the best signing of the summer transfer window?

More than £850million was spent by Premier League sides during this summer's transfer window, headed by Manchester United's mammoth outlay of over £150m.

Six clubs spent more than £50m each as the British transfer record fee for one player was smashed by Angel Di Maria. In fact, six of the top 10 spending European clubs this summer are from the Premier League, with just Real Madrid, Barcelona, Atletico Madrid and Borussia Dortmund amongst them.

So, with transfer records broken and hundreds of players on the move, who is the best signing of them all?

Mark Holmes (@homzy) - Cesc Fabregas

There were plenty of excellent signings made by mid-table clubs over the summer but there are six more high-profile deals that have grabbed most people's attention.

Arsenal's signing of Alexis Sanchez pushes them ever closer towards a genuine title challenge, Liverpool's purchase of Mario Balotelli means they may yet prosper without Luis Suarez, while Manchester United have done all they can to get back into the Champions League with the big-money captures of Angel Di Maria and Radamel Falcao.

It is Chelsea, however, that have made the best signing of all in the shape of Cesc Fabregas.

Diego Costa fits into the same category as the likes of Sanchez and Falcao in that he is a potentially fantastic signing but may struggle to maintain top form during his first season in the Premier League - but Fabregas won't have that problem having cut his teeth at Arsenal.

Furthermore, he is exactly what Chelsea have been missing, a genuine playmaker that will dictate the vast majority of games he plays in. Unsurprisingly, he has attempted more passes than any of his team-mates in all three of his appearances and already has four assists to his name.

At around £30million, you could hardly say he came cheaply, but that is only marginally more than United and Liverpool paid for Ander Herrera and Adam Lallana respectively. Neither of those players are in Fabregas' league.

The Spaniard also has his best years ahead of him at 27 and, having signed a five-year contract, can go on dominating Premier League midfields for years to come.

Both now and for the future, he is an exceptional signing.

State your support for Mark by using the story comment facility below or by getting in touch on Twitter.

James Marshment (@marshyleeds) - Eliaquim Mangala

As the defending champions, it's very hard to find a weakness in Manchester City's armoury.

Offensively, City scored an impressive 102 league goals last term as they marched towards a second Premier League title in three years, while glory in the Capital One Cup only added to their domestic domination.

But the one area that obviously needed addressing was the centre of their defence - and the need to find a world-class defensive partner for Vincent Kompany.

Although the club conceded less than a goal per game in the league last year, it's always been felt that a lack of a defensive colossus alongside the ever-reliable Kompany would be paramount if the club was to take the next step towards European domination.

Although commanding a reportedly eye-watering £32million fee, I believe City have finally landed that man in France centre-half Mangala, who showed during his three seasons at Porto that he was one of the continent's most effective stoppers.

In many ways, while the fee does appear quite steep, I'd argue City are getting twice the defender that David Luiz is - and he, of course, cost PSG a truly-preposterous £50million just a matter of a few weeks earlier.

Transfers fees aside, and despite the fact he's not as glamorous a name as the Radamel Falcaos or Angel Di Marias of this world, Mangala is a player that should add steel, poise and reliability to City's defence.

Where the likes of Joleon Lescott, Stefan Safic and to a slightly-lesser extent, Matija Nastasic, have failed, I believe Mangala can truly excel and prove a perfect foil for the slightly-more refined style of Kompany.

Football may be geared towards attacking styles and the creative genius of the Number 10, but the art of defending cannot be underestimated either and this is why, I believe, Mangala can be the signing of the summer.

State your support for James by using the story comment facility below or by getting in touch on Twitter.

TEAMtalk Facebook Fan Page

The TEAMtalk fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

S

till reckon Chelsea will go for Khedira as back up for Matic. I think it will turn out to be quite a Mourihno-y window: We'll see the squad players and youth in action pre-season, say things like well, we need not buy anybody and then the club will bid £60m for Pogba and send everybody on loan.

tk421
F365's Transfer Guide - Part One

I

would love to be a fly on the wall at the meeting between Milner and Rodgers. I don't know if flies can count, but if they can then I would be counting the number of times Rodgers used the word outstanding in his attempts to get Milner to sign.

godzilla
Reds and Arsenal chase Milner

W

ell, it wouldn't be a summer without Arsenal fans fretting over losing a key player, and United throwing their weight around and muscling in on transfer deals which are (apparently) near to completion. If we can't be entertained by the football on the pitch, let's enjoy the silly off-pitch soap opera of the transfer season. Hurrah!

CamberleyGooner
The Back To It Gossip

Footer 365

Gundogan yet to make decision on future

Borussia Dortmund midfielder Ilkay Gundogan could yet join Manchester United this summer, according to a report from Germany.

Liverpool close in on Milner - Report

Want-away Man City midfielder James Milner could be announced as a Liverpool player by the end of the week, according to reports.

Atleti, Arsenal and Liverpool target Vietto

Villarreal are reportedly attempting to renegotiate Luciano Vietto's contract to ward off interest from Atletico Madrid, Arsenal and Liverpool.

Mail Box

Calling Carlo For Liverpool... Please

One Liverpool Mailer wants a manager who isn't starstruck by the job. Plus why Milner has now become overrated, play-offs for the title, Ronaldinho and democracy..

James Milner: Jose's Perfect Player?

Probably. But presumably he would not swap one bench for another. We have mails on over-hyped players, Arsenal enthusiasm, UEFA, FIFA and naked dudes...

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company