FIFA 'made error with Qatar'

FIFA made a mistake awarding the World Cup to Qatar and will put the health of players and fans at risk if the tournament is not moved from the summer, according to the man who led the official inspection of the bidding nations.

Last Updated: 08/10/13 at 20:34 Post Comment

Qatar: Chosen to host the 2022 World Cup

Qatar: Chosen to host the 2022 World Cup

Speaking in his first British broadcast interview, Harold Mayne-Nicholls warns that playing in Qatar in summer will be "impossible" even with the cooling technology proposed by the organising committee.

Mayne-Nicholls, the former chairman of the Chilean FA, said Qatar "was not the best option", but revealed he was certain it would win the 2022 World Cup three days before the decisive FIFA vote in December 2010.

"Three days before the decision, I already had a great per cent (certainty) that it would be Qatar, too many people talking about Qatar at that time, so I was not surprised when it was given the World Cup," he told Sky News.

FIFA's decision to award the tournament to Qatar came despite a clear warning from Mayne-Nicholls in his evaluation report.

In the executive summary, he wrote: "The fact that the competition is planned in June-July, the two hottest months of the year in this region, has to be considered as a potential health risk for players, officials, the FIFA family and spectators, and requires precautions to be taken."

Despite this, Qatar polled more votes than the USA to win the tournament and spark the greatest controversy FIFA has ever known.

Last week FIFA began a consultation into whether the tournament can be moved to a different time of the year, which Mayne-Nicholls feels is essential.

"We wrote that it is very risky to play the World Cup in June-July for the health of the players," he said.

"We had no evidence that something would happen, but we said that even with the cooling system that they promised it would be very risky."

Mayne-Nichols, who now runs Ganamos Todos, a charitable sporting foundation in Chile, said his personal experience in Qatar convinced him that playing in summer, or even as late as September, was impractical.

"When we were walking on the street it was very, very warm, and it was not easy," he said.

"You really suffered with the sun and that was no more than 100 metres, so when we put it in the report we knew it (was right).

"I cannot imagine top athletes running even 90 minutes even with the cooling system, because at certain times of day they will feel this climate."

Intriguingly, Mayne-Nicholls claimed that when FIFA members gathered in Zurich for the 2018 and 2022 World Cup votes it was clear very early that Qatar had gathered significant support.

His assertion that three days before the election he was certain that Qatar would win will raise eyebrows, but the administrator makes clear he has no evidence of wrongdoing.

"We were talking to ex-co members and we were surprised that they were going for Qatar," he said. "Normally they would go for others, but I have no reason to have any doubts about their decision.

"They decided for Qatar. It was one of the countries bidding so they had the right to get a vote. It was a surprise because it was not the best option, but it was an option.

"Rumours have been going on since the election but there is not a single piece of evidence, no one has been able to show us this is what happened. What I can say to myself, nobody, not Qatar or anybody, offered me anything.

"Nobody interfered, we were allowed to do our jobs."

Mayne-Nicholl's revelations come as Michael Garcia, the independent attorney investigating the bidding process for Fifa's ethics committee, confirmed that he is to visit all nine bidding nations.

He said he was examining allegations of breaches of FIFA's ethics code, and will report sometime in the first half of 2014.

Related News

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

T

he thing is, footballers are role models, and children are influenced by them. I watched the Chelsea game with my 6 year old, and at school the next day she stamped on Emre Can.

megabrow (cufc)
Diego Costa: The Patron Saint Of S**thousery

Y

et again Barcelona try to convince the world that they only play the most virtuous of football. I've never seen a team so willing and able to dish out lumps but feel so self-righteous that no opposition player should ever have the audacity to tackle them.

charsmatcengma
Enrique hauls Neymar to safety

I

d love to see a United v Liverpool FA cup final. It would certainly fit the narrative. Obv I'd want the ending to be one of an O.G. and tears as he collects his runner-up medal.

GVMUFC
Gerrard Constantly Searching For That Final Hurrah

Footer 365

Brendan Rodgers: Daniel Sturridge can shine new light on revamped Liverpool

Brendan Rodgers expects the imminent return of "reference point" Daniel Sturridge to help Liverpool push for a top-four place.

Transfer news: Ivan Ramis released by Wigan and signs for Levante

Ivan Ramis has joined La Liga side Levante after his contract with Wigan Athletic was cancelled by mutual consent.

Transfer news: Paul Pogba will leave Juventus in next 18 months, says agent

Paul Pogba's agent expects the French midfielder to leave Juventus at some stage in the next two seasons.

Mail Box

It's A Massive, Big, Brilliant Mailbox

And we left lots of Suarez/Costa mails unopened. What we do have is a video of some rotten Suarez tackles and views on the future of football, Spurs, Liverpool and...

But Biting Doesn't Hurt Like Stamping...

There are Liverpool fans arguing that Luis Suarez is nowhere near Diego Costa's sh*t-house league but we have plenty of love for the agitator too. Oh and Spurs...

© 2015 Sky Ltd. All Rights Reserved A Sky Sports Digital Media company