Manchester City had one of their omnishambles kind of days as they were destroyed by an excellent Stoke side.
Twice in the opening 15 minutes, the wonderful Xherdan Shaqiri and Marko Arnautovic combined to put the Potters 2-0 up against an awful City side missing the injured Vincent Kompany, Yaya Toure and Sergio Aguero.
The 2-0 scoreline actually flattered City, who never got to grips with a Stoke formation that featured no out-and-out striker.
City, who finished the match with 10 men after midfielder Fernando limped off following his side’s third substitution, began the day top of the table on goal difference but a fourth away game without a win – and the third in a row without a goal – conceded the initiative to the chasing pack.
They were beaten by a Stoke side unrecognisable from last weekend’s 2-0 defeat at struggling Sunderland as they oozed confidence – with no greater example set than by centre-back Philipp Wollscheid’s Cruyff turn on Kevin de Bruyne on the edge of his own penalty area in the first half.
Playing five in midfield largely negated City’s chief threats of David Silva, Raheem Sterling and De Bruyne by denying them service.
But it was not a defensive tactic as it allowed the hosts to establish an early dominance with Shaqiri dropping deep and Arnautovic roaming forward from a left-sided position.
The pair linked up for both goals and the same combination could easily have contributed a couple more before the interval.
City’s left side was an avenue of weakness Stoke exploited with regularity as Shaqiri showed as early as the seventh minute when he skipped past Fernando, easily beat Aleksandar Kolarov and crossed for Arnautovic to nip in front of Bacary Sagna and side-foot home.
De Bruyne was denied by a good low save from Jack Butland, who also deflected a Kolarov effort onto the post late in the half. just moments before Shaqiri embarrassed the hapless Fernando with a turn of such brilliance the City midfielder was halfway towards his own bench before he realised what had happened.
Fernando may as well have continued his run and taken a seat alongside Pellegrini so poor was his performance – although the same could not be said of Shaqiri who immediately laid on the perfect assist for Arnautovic’s second.
City’s central defensive pairing of Nicolas Otamendi and Martin Demichelis, in for the suspended Eliaquim Mangala, were at sixes and sevens and that could easily have been the half-time scoreline as Arnautovic headed narrowly wide and hit the post after slipping as he shot from another pass from Shaqiri.
While Mark Hughes may have added considerable style to what used to be a substantial Stoke team they have not lost any of their commitment – evidenced by the diminutive Bojan Krkic racing back to intercept a City counter-attack from Stoke’s corner on the edge of his own box.
Stoke’s approach did not change with the strong wind at their backs in the second half as Hart saved from Bojan and Arnautovic clipped the rebound into the side-netting, before the Austrian attempted to return the earlier favours from Shaqiri with a pass across goal which required the slightest of touches to score only for the Swiss to get his feet in a tangle and fail to connect.
City’s miserable afternoon continued when, 10 minutes after making their third substitution, Fernando went off with a hamstring injury leaving them one short for the final 15 minutes.