Moss Rose Ground

Next Game

Macc'field v Stoke City

Saturday, 03 August 2013, 15:00

Friendly Match

Managers give verdict on Rafa

Tony Pulis, Roberto Martinez, Neil McDonald, Brian McDermott, Martin Jol and Steve Clarke have given their views on Rafa Benitez's comments.

Last Updated: 28/02/13 at 22:56 Post Comment

Rafa Benitez: Has an uneasy relationship with Chelsea hierarchy

Rafa Benitez: Has an uneasy relationship with Chelsea hierarchy

Speaking after Chelsea's 2-0 FA Cup win at Middlesbrough, Benitez turned on those who gave him the title of 'interim manager' when he succeeded Roberto Di Matteo in November, and the fans who have never forgiven him for guiding Liverpool to the 2005 Champions League final at the Blues' expense.

Benitez's relationship with club owner Roman Abramovich is coming under scrutiny but Tony Pulis said only the Chelsea manager would know what level of support he has.

He said: "What goes on at Chelsea goes on at Chelsea - I can't control that. In terms of what Rafa is going through, the best person to talk to is Rafa.

"Every manager has a different relationship with chairmen. I have had different relationships with other chairmen at other football clubs to what I have got with Peter (Coates).

"I'm very privileged to have the (Coates) family here, who are absolutely fantastic people. If I want to see them, I pop down the road and it is five minutes if I jump in my car. The door is always open for me to go and see them.

"Ask Rafa what his relationship is like with Abramovich or the people in power there. He is the only one who can answer that - and from that stems everything.

"When I first came into football, Bruce Rioch said to me the greatest relationship in a football club is between the manager and chairman. That was 20-odd years ago, and Bruce has been dead right. The relationship between yourself and the person who runs the football club is paramount to how the football club really projects itself.

"As a football manager, I am extremely lucky here. Other managers are not so lucky."

Asked whether players cared about the manager's job title, Pulis replied: "You can call me anything you want. The most important thing is that the people who are working for me have to show me respect. I don't care what I am called - especially behind my back!"

Wigan manager Roberto Martinez enjoys a good relationship with fans at the DW Stadium despite now being involved in a fourth successive relegation battle since taking charge at the club.

Martinez was a popular figure during his playing days with Latics and has retained much of that support - a situation in contrast to that experienced by his fellow Spaniard at Stamford Bridge.

But Martinez was unwilling to be drawn too much on that subject as he met media to preview his side's game against Liverpool this weekend.

"I didn't see it last night but as a manager you are working 100 per cent every day to try to affect the things you can affect," he said.

"Obviously there are many issues you can't affect and you can't do much about it. As a manager that can make your job a little bit harder.

"But it is difficult to comment from my point of view. When you are involved in our situation, I don't think there is too much time to look elsewhere. I can't really comment."

Martinez admitted the title of an 'interim' manager was one he was not familiar with.

He said: "It is something you need to ask a solicitor. I don't know if it has anything to do with football. I have no experience on that so can't give an answer. It is something I haven't seen before."

West Ham assistant boss Neil McDonald can understand why Benitez should become antagonised, but he also believes supporters of any club have the right to air their grievances.

McDonald said: "He's obviously frustrated, I suppose, in a way. You have to deal with that, don't you? It's always difficult coming into a football club not being the 'manager'.

"He hasn't had the results he probably wanted but at the same time he's trying to do his best. That's all you can do as a manager.

"Sympathy... we're all in the same situation. If we don't get the results we're under pressure and if the team's not playing as well as what it has done in the past, then the crowd have got every right to voice their opinions and that's what he's had to deal with at the moment."

Reading boss Brian McDermott understands Benitez's frustration at being given the 'interim' title, having experienced a similar situation himself.

He said: "That is the title that the job was given. When I got the job here in the first place I was caretaker manager. It was called caretaker then until I got the job as the manager. That is kind of how it is.

"The title was 'interim manager' and I understand that that title doesn't look to be a permanent title, I would suggest, so I can see from Rafa's point of view that wouldn't be the title he would have wanted."

Regarding the constant jeering Benitez has had to endure during his Stamford Bridge reign, McDermott added: "It isn't pleasant but that is how it is. That is football, and fans want to see teams that are winning."

Fulham manager Martin Jol also had sympathy for Benitez, saying: "I feel for any manager who is not well-liked and he wasn't well-liked from the start so I feel for him.

"He is a professional so he will probably do his job until the end of the season."

West Brom boss Steve Clarke "didn't see a lot wrong" with the comments made by Benitez.

Clarke said: "It is difficult for me to say whether it was a rant or not by Rafa because I didn't hear the interview.

"I read it and seeing a transcription is different to hearing someone say something.

"But I didn't see a lot wrong in what he said. The script, as it was written down, was okay.

"I think by and large we are all interim. Someone is going to come and take your position at some stage.

"Only Sir Alex (Ferguson) and maybe Arsene Wenger can say they are in it for the long haul, but eventually someone is going to take your job so we are all temporary managers.

"We go in as a head coach or a manager and we go in for whatever period of time it is to try to help the club to move forward.

"Rafael Benitez was put in as manager to take the club to the end of the season and I'm sure that will happen."

Clarke reckons Benitez would have known the situation he was confronting when he replaced the sacked Roberto Di Matteo in November.

He said: "If you are manager at a club like Chelsea, you know what comes with the territory.

"You work with great players, you've always got a chance to compete in the major competitions.

"Everyone keeps telling me Chelsea are struggling, but they are doing okay.

"They are in the top four of the Premier League and the quarter-finals of the FA Cup and the last 16 of the Europa League and reached the semi-finals of the Capital One Cup. They are doing okay.

"Is the criticism unfair? It is not for me to judge. I work for West Brom. Chelsea, and what they see as their problems, that's for Chelsea. It is not for me.

"I was lucky I had the chance to do that (gain respect) over 12 years as a player at Chelsea. It's different for me. I had great times as a player and coach there.

"I've got a fantastic relationship with Chelsea. I'm not going to say anything bad about the club. It's a club I hold close to my heart. It's a big part to my past."

Football365 Facebook Fan Page

The Football365 fan page is a great place to meet like minded people, have football related discussions and make new friends.

Related News

Sky Bet

    • Retrieving latest Sky Bet odds

Most Commented

Readers' Comments

W

hat's a Bebe??

godsaveourkeane
Bebe seeking Sporting switch

W

hips, harness and saddlery ? This IS an Onion article.

v. profane
Bale set to trademark logo

I

want to trademark the word football .

herculezbotak
Bale set to trademark logo

Footer 365

Newcastle pull Douglas deal

Newcastle United have reportedly pulled out of a deal to sign Dutch defender Douglas, according to reports on Wednesday morning.

Southgate tipped for U-21 job

Gareth Southgate is the overwhelming bookmakers' favourite to replace Stuart Pearce as England Under-21s manager.

La Liga: Gerard Pique wants Barcelona to keep Thiago Alcantara

Gerard Pique wants Barcelona to try and talk Manchester United target Thiago Alcantara into staying at the Catalan club.

Mail Box

Twas The Worst Game I Ever Did See...

In this Mailbox it's England v Algeria in 2010 that is seen as the nadir, but there's potential for worse, surely. Plus, one man says we should praise Rooney's honesty...

Why Doesn't Suarez Request A Transfer?

The morning mailbox ponders Luis Suarez's current predicament, cool footballers, the Lion City Cup, Spurs' transfer policy, Kanu's absence and lots more...

© 2013 British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. All Rights Reserved