The best PL XI with no more than one player per club and…

Date published: Thursday 26th March 2020 10:13

Thanks for your emails. Keep your various different XIs and quizzes and games and Six Degrees efforts coming to


More One Per Club XIs
Long time lurker, first time mailer. I would like to thank Rick for further reaching into the barrel and plucking out yet another creative exercise that stimulates thought and discussion during these uncertain times.

Here we go – I’ve gone with a 3 – 4 – 3, well I guess more of a 3 2 2 3… I actually don’t know what I’m talking about but I’m just having a crack.  Note: this exercise is a lot more difficult than first thought.  (Sorry Southampton & Brighton)

Starting XI:

GK: (Arsenal) Leno

CB: (Burnley) Tarkowski
CB: (Liverpool) Van Dijk

CB: (West Ham) Issa Diop

CDM: (Leicester City) Wilfred Ndidi
CDM: (Watford) Abdoulaye Doucoure

CM: (Man City) Kevin De Bruyne

CM: (Man United) Bruno Fernandes

RW: (Newcastle) Saint-Maximin

ST:  (Tottenham) Son

LW: (Wolves) Traore


(Sheffield Utd) Henderson

(Aston Villa) Grealish

(Everton) Mina

(Bournemouth) Ake

(Chelsea)  Willian

(Crystal Palace) Zaha

(Norwich) Cantwell

I’ve gone for a mobile and resolute backline, I’m banking on Leno stopping some shots if they get stretched wide.  My CDMs cover a lot of ground and are strong in the tackle.  I’m hoping they can lay off quickly to a very creative partnership in the heart of midfield.  I’ve gone for guile, trickery and blistering pace in the front three.  If you play a high line against this team, you’re f*d.  If you set up a deep block…well, it’s quite possible we’re f*d.

I look forward to reading more of these – great stuff Rick.  Keep those great ideas coming.  Thanks mate.
Jack – (Melbourne, AUS)


…GK: Henderson (Sheffield United) – Sheffield United are absolutely a team (that’s a compliment not a criticism), but Henderson looks most capable of thriving outside of the current system

RB: Pereria (Leicester) – have to agree with F365 which recently said Pereria was the better FB when compared to Chilwell, so he comes in for his Leicester team mate

CB: Maguire (Manchester United) – Has won me over this season. Thought it was a huge waste of money to sign him, and while it was undoubtably an inflated price, he has been very strong since he has acclimatised to the team

CB: Van Dijk (Liverpool) – no brainer

LB: Digne (Everton) – not the best in the division, but very capable, and comes from a team that doesn’t have many other first team options for this side

DM: Moutinho (Wolves) – a real shame he didn’t come to England earlier, the type of player you are almost obliged compare to a Rolls Royce

DM: Kante (Chelsea) – not his best season, although taking one of the best defensive midfielders in the world and moving them around the side probably hasn’t helped

LW: Grealish (Aston Villa) – not sure this is his best position but wanted to get him in the side. Would be interesting to see how good he could be with better players around him

AM: De Bruyne (Man City) – best player in the league, if City had a defence as good as him they would have actually challenged Liverpool this season

RW: Son (Spurs) – will basically be excellent about 95% of the time, so in he goes

CF: Aubameyang (Arsenal) – a class act, and would guarantee goals with the creativity behind him


Dubravka (Newcastle)

Ings (Southampton)

Aarons (Norwich)

McNeil (Burnley)

Dunk (Brighton)

Sarr (Watford)

Rice (West Ham)

Pretty decent side, very solid defensively and with enough brilliance up front to trouble most sides. No place for anyone from Bournemouth or Palace, with Ayew a bit unlucky to not make the cut.
Jack (Almost had Ings as my frontline striker, until I realised I didn’t have anyone from Arsenal) Manchester


Six degrees of Kluivert + bonus Spursy XI
As soon as I saw this one, I didn’t care about getting there in the shortest number of moves; I knew the only way to go would be through the other Ajax father/son combo of Danny and Daley Blind!! So here goes:

Pat Kluivert

Danny Blind

Clarence Seedorf


Daley Blind

Hakim Ziyech

Justin Kluivert

Whilst I’m here, here’s my worst Spurs XI:

Espen Baardsen

Dean Austin

Stuart Nethercott

Ricardo Rocha

Paolo Tramezzani (without doubt the worst Spurs player in my lifetime!!)

Moussa Saib

Goran Bunjevcevic

Jason Dozzell

Andy Sinton

Grzegorz Rasiak

Helder Postiga
Paul (Spurs) T.Wells


…I believe this works…

Patrick Kluivert > Javier Saviola > Arjen Robben > Martin Demichelis > Eden Dzeko > Justin Kluivert

(Barcelona)          (Real Madrid)      (Bayern)                    (Man City)      (Roma)

There may be quicker ways to get from one to the other, but there’s something particularly pleasing about this way (if it checks out)
Ned Wall


Banks to Pickford
Cheers, Will Padmore – this one was probably the hardest yet and almost had me stumped! I had to use the full 5 footballers and a lot of wikipedia/transfermarkt, but here we go:

Gordon Banks at Stoke with Alan Dodd 73/74
Alan Dodd at Wolves with John Pender 83/84
John Pender at Wigan with Roy Carroll 96/97
Roy Carroll at United with John O’Shea 04/05
John O’Shea at Sunderland with Pickford 16/17

I never thought I’d say it, but thank the stars for Roy Carroll! Here’s one slightly different for people: Can they get from Alf Ramsey (Manager) to Jurgen Klopp (Manager) using 5 players they’ve managed? Should be tricky!
Lee (that definitely killed an hour), LFC


All American Premier League XI
Shockingly, this team could give the Welsh and Scots a run for their money.

GK – Brad Friedel

Absolutely loaded at this position, but Big Bald Brad and his bizarre half-English accent is the choice from a equally bald-headed group featuring Kasey Keller, Tim Howard, Brad Guzan, and Marcus Hahnemann.

LB – DeMarcus Beasley

Slight-statured Beasley will still be getting USMNT caps into his 50s. Scored three goals for City on loan from PSV.

CB – Carlos Bocanegra

California pretty boy Bocanegra featured for five seasons at Fulham and is now an accomplished executive for Atland United. Useful on corners, scored 8 Premier League goals.

CB – Geoff Cameron

Slim pickings at center back. Cameron was a steady presence in the famously stingy Pulis-ball Stoke squads.

RB – DeAndre Yedlin

Gets a lot of crap from pundits for his somewhat unorthodox, rough-around-the-edges style, still room on this team for one of the fastest players in PL history. Burst onto the scene against Belgium in the World Cup. Saved Sunderland from relegation with an assist on the final day (they were relegated the season after he left), went to Newcastle and they were promoted in their first season. Almost seems forever ago that Spurs had Walker, Trippier, and Yedlin all on the same squad.

CM – John Harkes

Stu Holden could’ve held this spot had a series of major injures not curtailed his promising career, Harkes gets credit for being the first American to play in the PL, the second American to score at Wembley, and the first American to play in a major English cup final (1991 League Cup). Sent in the cross that Andres Escobar infamously put into his own net for Colombia. Also, no team would be completely without a man who was accused (and later confirmed) to be sleeping with his teammates missus.

CM – Claudio Reyna

Along with Holden, spent a lot of time in the training room, but he is the best pure central midfielder the US has ever produced. His son Gio is featuring for Dortmund at age 17 and may join this group soon.

CM – Clint Dempsey

Arguably the most naturally gifted American player ever with an endearing trash-talking mean streak about him. Scored the most famous American goal in Europe ever against Juventus. Bruce Arena summed up what makes him special perfectly: “He tries sh**.” Honorable mention to Preki who scored a famous goal in a 1-0 USMNT win over Brazil.

LW – Landon Donovan

Landycakes was never the most athletic or graceful player but always came through in big moments. His legendary exploits for the national team give him the edge over steady Eddie Lewis.

RW – Christian Pulisic

First to score a hat-trick in the Premier League. Scored more goals in a half than Jozy Altidore scored in two seasons.

ST – Brian McBride

Gets the nod over Roy Wegerle and Joe-Max Moore, the midwestern epitome of the hard-working, good-looking All-American boy with a heart of gold and a head of iron. The sight of him in world cup coming back on after a vicious elbow courtesy of Daniele de Rossi still brings a tear to the eye. Recently elected General Manager of the USSF to clean out the riff-raff.
John, Los Angeles


Another Niche XI
Here’s a relatively niche XI:  Players Who Never Won the World Cup but Lost in The Final:

Schumacher (82, 86), Burgnich (70), Schnellinger (66), Maldini (94), Facchetti (70), Neeskens (74, 78), Van Hanegem (74), Puskas (54), Hidegkuti (54), Cruyff (74), Baggio (94).

No Baresi because he was part of the Italy’s 82 winning squad and no Messi because he’s still playing and he could win it in Qatar…

I’m sure someone could make an equally great XI with players I’ve left out, the likes of Seeler, Haan, Rummenigge and er Junior Baiano.
Matthew, Belfast


Taking the Biscan
Re Rob’s Worst LFC XI ever, absolutely not re Igor Biscan. He was genuinely decent, just continually played out of position by Houllier. Very fond memories of some big performances playing in midfield en route to Istanbul. Broadly agree with the rest, though how El Hadji Diouf hasn’t made the team I dont know. He was total sh*t, plus a complete weapon. Dreadful signing.
Jack Flaussen


So with the UK in lockdown and no football on our screens, YouTube is becoming a great place to feed our urges (now available in 360p, feels like the early 2000s), anyway Sky uploaded the other day The Best Showboats in Premier League History.

On said video is a fair amount from Adel Taarabt during his Spurs and QPR days, in one clip he manages to nutmeg a defender and cause teammate Anthony Gardner to give the best reaction I think I have seen in recent memory, so this brought me to this question: who is a player that could always have a trick or two in his locker, that would make you go wow but overall was considered kind of a bit crap?
Mikey, CFC 


More Related Articles