Newcastle: Man Utd director Ashworth ‘hurt and bemused’ by Mitchell as he’s branded a ‘failure’

Joe Williams
Newcastle sporting director Paul Mitchell and Dan Ashworth
Paul Mitchell replaced Dan Ashworth at St James' Park in July.

New Man Utd sporting director Dan Ashworth has been ‘hurt’ by Paul Mitchell’s comments about the state of recruitment at Newcastle, according to reports.

Ashworth eventually took over as sporting director at Old Trafford in July after months of wrangling over the compensation that would be owed to the Magpies.

Mitchell, meanwhile, arrived at Newcastle to take over from Ashworth after previous roles in scouting and club development at Southampton, Tottenham, RB Leipzig and Monaco.

Mitchell, 42, played professionally with clubs including Wigan and MK Dons before his career was cut short by injury and he moved into off-field roles.

He became chief scout at MK Dons before moving to Southampton in 2012. He followed manager Mauricio Pochettino to Tottenham in 2014, becoming their head of recruitment. His signings for the north London club included Dele Alli and Son Heung-min.

Mitchell – who has previously been linked with both Liverpool and Man Utd – later joined the Red Bull group, spending time with Leipzig and New York before being appointed as Monaco sporting director in 2020.

A report on Friday claimed that Eddie Howe and Mitchell have ‘clashed over transfers and the team’s playing style’ since the former Monaco man was appointed in July and the former came out to criticise the state of the recruitment department earlier this week.

Mitchell said: “There are things we got wrong in our strategy for sure. Me coming in when I did probably wasn’t the best timing for the organisation but what it has done is allow me to witness a process.

“As custodians of this club, we can’t just keep spending, spending, spending because at some point that won’t enable the club to facilitate its goals.

“I don’t think any Newcastle fan wants to see this club in a place where other clubs were last season with docked points (or) financial penalties because that can really affect our growth.

“Should our scouting and recruitment be driven more extensively with a wider reaching net? It definitely should be because this is becoming a really nuanced space now. You can’t just capital fund everything every year and buy loads of players at peak age and peak price.

“Was, let’s say, the scouting network, the lengths and breadths of our process and our strategies, including the influence of Eddie Howe, bigger and broader enough? Probably not. And that’s the bit we analyse to be better. That’s the bit we have to adjust and modernise.”

MORE NEWCASTLE COVERAGE ON F365…
👉 Newcastle ‘consider’ shock January move for £80m Man Utd flop if pursuit of Forest star fails
👉 Osimhen to Man Utd? PL Big Eight ranked on their chances of signing banished Napoli star
👉 Newcastle: ‘Heartbroken’ Amanda Staveley ‘forced out’ as PIF ‘leaks of dissatisfaction’ emerge

And now Luke Edwards in the Daily Telegraph has claimed that Man Utd sporting director Ashworth and ‘other former members of Newcastle United’s recruitment team have been hurt and bemused’ by Mitchell’s comments that their structure wasn’t “fit for purpose”.

Edwards wrote:

‘Telegraph Sport has been told by multiple sources that Mitchell’s criticism has not gone down well with those who were involved in signing players before he took over. These include Ashworth, who left the club in February for Manchester United, as well as former co-owner Amanda Staveley, her husband Mehrdad Ghodoussi and chief scout Steve Nickson.’

The journalist added:

‘Some have privately expressed frustration that their recruitment decisions were questioned by Mitchell and are proud of their record while in charge at St James’ Park. One has even suggested this was an attempt to blame others for his own failure to sign a marquee player in his first window.’