Man City are playing like surly teenagers as Fulham draw pushes wobble towards full-blown crisis
Pep Guardiola beat Fulham 15 times out of 15 as Manchester City manager. In fact, heading into this, City had won their last 20 meetings with the Cottagers in all competitions, stretching back to September 2011, when Roberto Mancini’s side featured the likes of Micah Richards, Gareth Barry and, er, Adam Johnson.
Fulham had not won at the Etihad since April 2009, when City were still in the infancy of their oil-money transformation. Valery Bozhinov and Martin Petrov featured in attack for the hosts, Clint Dempsey scored a brace, and Fulham finished three places above City in the final table.
The days of Bozhinov and Petrov feel a lifetime ago, but Enzo Maresca’s City feel more like that charmingly shambolic side than the one we’ve become accustomed to over the past decade of domination.
Coming into this meeting, three consecutive Premier League defeats have sounded the crisis klaxon. It’s the first time City have suffered such a run since… December 2024. Hang on, two years ago? That sounds a bit less alarming when you consider some of the dates being mentioned when it comes to their city rivals.
Guardiola’s City finished third that season. That’s the advantage of having allegedly spent years operating outside the rules: even when the wheels come off, there’s enough financial muscle to keep you ahead of almost everyone else.
While their Big Six rivals have flitted in and out of the Champions League, City have been there every season since 2010-11. Sixteen consecutive qualifications, with third or – just once – fourth about as bad as it gets.
And so, onto Fulham. The title is surely already out of reach; the question now is how bad things can get. Are we looking at a genuine meltdown or a temporary wobble? This should provide a useful barometer. Given the recent history, City couldn’t have hand-picked a better fixture to steady the ship.
A gimme, then? Nope. There was the familiar air of malaise, both on the pitch and in the stands. The pressing lacked bite, the passing lacked urgency and Fulham seemed almost dumbfounded by how easily they could invite their hosts forward without questions being asked. The first half felt like a continuation of their pre-break woes, if not quite as chaotic as the Forest defeat.
Erling Haaland’s would-be equaliser being disallowed was borderline scandalous, with butterfingers Bernd Leno surely never having established control of the ball before the striker bundled it over the line.
City were not disastrous, even a tad unlucky, as they had been in their defeats to Villa and Brighton. But you make your own luck, and they could have few major complaints about going in at half-time behind. Fulham defended with discipline and commitment, staying compact, frustrating their hosts and taking their chance superbly through Rodrigo Muniz.
The sluggishness continued after the break, but they found a way through just before the hour mark. Elliot Anderson met a half-cleared corner with a superb low volley from the edge of the area, squeezing it through a crowd of bodies and beyond Leno. The goal sparked City into life, with Anderson suddenly everywhere.
City had their tails up, the Etihad briefly stirred from its early kick-off slumber, but Fulham relished the extra space as the game opened up and probably fashioned the better opportunities. City remained vulnerable at the back, with Marc Guehi and Abdukodir Khusanov again unconvincing.
There was no late siege, no overwhelming sense that City would inevitably find a winner. The old aura has disappeared, much like Manchester United’s in the immediate aftermath of Sir Alex Ferguson’s retirement. Fulham deserved their draw, could’ve easily won it, and City offered little to suggest they’ll drag themselves out of the doldrums any time soon.
The charges, the impending punishment and the uncertainty over City’s future are impossible to ignore, particularly given how dramatically their results have deteriorated since the news broke over the last international break. There is something almost teenage about their current attitude: a collective shrug of the shoulders and a sense of ‘what’s even the point?’
Fulham, by contrast, look like a team with plenty to play for. They were excellent here, and another reminder that the Premier League’s bottom half is stronger than it has ever been.