How Mauricio Pochettino can recreate his 2016/17 Tottenham team at Manchester United

Mauricio Pochettino with Harry Kane etc
Mauricio Pochettino with Harry Kane etc

We understand and share the general concerns and reservations about whether Mauricio Pochettino can truly turn Manchester United around and Get Them Back Where They Belong.

But that’s because we have general concerns and reservations about whether any manager can do so under the current bone-headed regime. It really might not just be possible at all.

And while it’s also extremely possible that, after seven years of questionable decisions and mixed results, Pochettino also just isn’t the manager he once was, we do also need to address one myth that has started to bubble up around him when attempts are made to downplay or discredit his achievements at Spurs.

Because at Spurs he really did do something akin to what he will be required to do at United. Create a brilliant team in spite of working for main-character owners who want on-field success on the cheap if at all while they throw all the money at a shiny new stadium. The valid question here is whether he really can bottle that lightning again, not whether he actually did it before.

We’ve seen it suggested that he simply inherited an excellent team at Spurs. Sorry, but did he f*ck. He built that team, identifying and removing the bad eggs, completing some surprisingly adroit transfer business in those first few windows before Spurs just stopped bothering with that at all to finish the stadium, and above all by transforming the fortunes of players he did inherit that would become part of his peak Spurs team in 2016/17.

His first Premier League Spurs XI in August 2014: Hugo Lloris; Kyle Naughton, Eric Dier, Younes Kaboul, Danny Rose; Etienne Capoue, Nabil Bentaleb; Aaron Lennon, Christian Eriksen, Erik Lamela; Emmanuel Adebayor.

We also very much like the fact that on the bench for Spurs that day was Ben Davies. Has he just always been on the Spurs bench? We like to think he’s just always been on the Spurs bench. A reassuring constant in a world of flux.

Essentially, though, Poch inherited what all Spurs managers inherit. An unbalanced, mismatched squad assembled by multiple previous managers, featuring a hotch-potch of talented players who have underperformed, promising youngsters, vast egos and a bunch of wasters who just simply aren’t good enough. But Pochettino made it work. And it sounds quite apt for United’s current set-up, doesn’t it?

Of those players he inherited who would go on to become integral to the side that finished second in 2016/17 with 86 points and a home record in the final season at White Hart Lane that read P19 W17 D2 L0, only perhaps Lloris, Mousa Dembele and Eriksen were always going to be fine and none were guaranteed to have the careers they did.

The full-backs that would become so key to the whole thing, Kyle Walker and Danny Rose, were both considered not good enough at that stage, just classic Spurs wastrels in the grand tradition. Even Jan Vertonghen hadn’t truly got anyone convinced.

Harry Kane had been ‘discovered’ by Tim Sherwood, sure, but he wasn’t even a one-season wonder yet and wouldn’t break into Pochettino’s starting XI until November of that first season. Dele was signed that winter and joined up with Spurs for the 2015/16 season.

Two more vital cogs would arrive in that 2015 summer in Toby Alderweireld and Son Heung-min, for a ludicrous even at the time combined fee of under £40m, alongside the usual Spurs misses (Kevin Wimmer, Clinton N’Jie) and Kieran Trippier, who would prove extremely useful after signing for buttons.

The final piece of Pochettino’s definitive Spurs XI would be signed just before the 2016/17 season, with Victor Wanyama arriving from Southampton for just £12m the same summer Spurs chucked £30m at Newcastle for Moussa Sissoko, proving once again that there is, if anything, an inverse correlation between how much money Spurs spend on a player and how good they turn out to be.

The key point, though, is that Pochettino didn’t simply inherit a team that was always going to be as good as they became. The secondary point is that we will not be entertaining any trophy banter at this time. We’re not saying trophies don’t matter, of course they do and especially when This Is Manchester United Football Club We’re Talking About, but ask any Spurs fan whether they would prefer to relive 2015-2019 or 2020-present day and you’ll soon realise that trophies are obviously important but are definitely not everything.

So the question then becomes a different one. No other Spurs manager in the Premier League era has done what Pochettino did in making them consistent challengers at the pointy end of the table. No post-Fergie manager has achieved it at United. How close can Pochettino really get to taking this 2014 Spurs-adjacent 26/27 United and turning them into something approaching 16/17 Spurs?

Either by improving or trusting what he has, or making the kind of smart transfer choices that were so profoundly un-Spurs but came along at key times in the development of that team. You’ll have to indulge us here as we also have to pretend that Pochettino will get two full years to turn United around, but to those who say such an idea is ludicrous at United we say this: no more ludicrous than it was both before and after Pochettino at Spurs, so…

 

GK: Hugo Lloris – Senne Lammens
They’re not quite the same thing, which will become a recurring theme here. Lloris was only 25 when he signed for Spurs but had already been Lyon’s first-choice keeper for four seasons and was already captain of France. There is an obvious experience gap here, but the profile is not entirely dissimilar. Lammens is now 24, and has already played at a World Cup.

Alas, it might be better if he hadn’t played at a World Cup after his mishap against Spain, one from which he is yet to fully recover. But, as with Lloris, he will start out under Pochettino as a relatively young keeper of obvious huge talent who can develop into a key leader within the group.

 

RB: Kyle Walker – Rico Lewis
Even staunch Poch supporters and defenders such as ourselves aren’t about to pretend he might be about to turn Diogo Dalot into peak Kyle Walker. But what if instead of a player who goes on to have their greatest success at Man City, you have a right-back who comes from Man City?

You have to remember that at some point in the next 18 months or so when we’d need this deal to go through that Man City may not be in a position of strength to prevent any of their players going anywhere else, no matter what kind of fat contracts they’ve got them on.

And Lewis strikes us as a very Poch full-back project indeed. A player whose potential has been clear for some time but hasn’t quite bloomed. He just needs unlocking, and Poch could be the man to do it.

It’s also possible we’re afflicted by extreme recency bias here after watching Lewis bag two assists in City’s 5-1 Champions League win over AEK Athens the other week, but for some reason we’re utterly convinced very deep in our bones that this would work splendidly well.

 

LB: Danny Rose – Harry Amass
Textbook bit of Pochettino-ing, this. A young player who’s already in situ, who’s had a brief taste of life in the first team (albeit during a time when first-team players were being rested during the moribund 24/25 run-in when all eyes were on the Europa League final) but has now been in the relative wilderness for 18 months.

None of United’s senior options at left-back are remotely convincing as Poch-style auxiliary attackers. We could still see United attempting a bit of short-term surgery at left-back in January via something like, say, a Tyrick Mitchell, who also feels quite Poch-coded. But if Poch retains any of his old magic then he’ll have Amass on the England radar by the time Euro 2028 comes around, and save United the embarrassment of being knocked back in pursuit of Lewis Hall who is, quite obviously, the absolutely ideal but very expensive and quite possibly entirely out of reach option.

READ: Man Utd target one player from every Premier League club in January

 

CB: Jan Vertonghen – Matthijs De Ligt
Sounds ludicrous, doesn’t it? But it’s spot on, when you think about it. Obviously talented centre-back from the central European lowlands who has nevertheless failed to win over a suspicious fanbase with his early efforts. What if he just needs a proper player-developer of a manager to come along with an arm around the shoulder and some chat about how lemons can stop bad energy or some such thing? And a further chat about the vital importance of enormous cojones? What if that really is all it takes to turn De Ligt into the centre-back who, in all fairness, we all thought he was going to be five or six years ago?

He’s already experienced inexplicable Poch magic from the other side, remember, in the 2018/19 Champions League, so he knows as well as anyone that it really can be potent if baffling stuff.

 

CB: Toby Alderweireld – Micky van de Ven
What do we know about how Pochettino creates a centre-back pairing that becomes the best in the entire league for a while there? That’s right, he gets two lads from the same country. Easy as that. Loads of other Dutch centre-backs around to put alongside De Ligt, but it’s not just the Spurs connection that makes Van de Ven and his fondness for extremely fast runs towards the opposition goal feel particularly Pochettino-coded.

 

CM: Victor Wanyama – Conor Gallagher
There has been the usual, predictable flurry of stories pretending Poch is about to go out and sign all his old players from all his old clubs. It happens every time a new manager turns up at a big club, as if every manager is Harry Redknapp and every former player is Niko Kranjcar. They aren’t. But it doesn’t mean the idea is entirely without merit.

A quick look at United’s current midfield options tells you one thing that will be urgently required and that’s runners. Perhaps the biggest puzzle of all for Poch to try and solve on the fly before he can make actual changes to the squad is where to get the runners in midfield and at full-back that have been so crucial to his best teams. United look woefully short of options within the current first-team squad. It seems certain that, despite all that focus on midfield United had in the summer, they will have to go again for an actual Pochettino sort in January.

Gallagher is a former Pochettino player now at another of Pochettino’s former clubs, who is potentially also available. So that’s perfect. We’d imagine it would be greeted by some grumbling from United fans and we understand it is not particularly exciting. But he is just one of a great many former Poch players whose best football came when they were working together and who fulfils an obvious need of Pochball and fills an obvious gap within United’s current offering.

 

CM: Mousa Dembele – Carlos Baleba
Look, a lot of this is going to end up being a reminder that it’s going to be very hard for Pochettino to do at United what he did at Spurs. These are two clubs who are famously impossible to solve. Carlos Baleba is not Mousa Dembele, the professional’s professional, and never will be. But he’s the most compelling of the current options and could yet fall under the category of ‘obviously talented player who was yet to fully convince after stepping up to a bigger club until Poch unleashed his full potential’ which was certainly true of Dembele.

 

AM: Christian Eriksen – Morgan Gibbs-White
The irony here, of course, is that for the last five years or so this has been the one position for a 16/17 Pochettino reenactment that United have had covered thanks to the magnificently moody and moodily magnificent Bruno Fernandes. He even fulfilled the Christian Eriksen role to perfection at a time when the Manchester United squad contained Actual Christian Eriksen.

But there’s a ships-in-the-night feel to Bruno and Pochettino’s story here. It does feel like Bruno might become more of an Adebayor than an Eriksen in Pochettino’s United mission. A personality that is large and dominant and not always necessarily helpful that might need to be excised for the greater good, especially with growing evidence that the player himself is on the wane.

So it’s not Bruno, who’s already 32 now even before Pochettino has embarked on what we’ve all agreed is at least a two-year journey to Make United Spurs Again. (But in a good way.)

There are no compelling options within the current squad even allowing for some Poch magic. Mason Mount was sold by Pochettino when he was at Chelsea, which doesn’t bode well. We can’t quite picture Kobbie Mainoo or Amad Diallo becoming the requisite creative force to match a peak Eriksen or Fernandes. So it’s outside the current squad we must once again go.

The name that is constantly being shouted here is Cole Palmer, and we can’t disagree with that as a concept. He has the star power and the talent and the Manchester connection to become the main creative spark for this team, and he’s another name on that long list of players whose best football of their career came under Mauricio Pochettino. But he’s also going to cost, conservatively, £150m. He may be the perfect player, but he simply could not be less INEOS-coded.

About half that price gets you a Morgan Gibbs-White, which is just as good, really.

 

RW: Dele Alli – Shea Lacey
Bit of licence required with the position. Dele didn’t really play on the right – he didn’t really play anywhere, specific, operating with fluid mischief from a permanent station in The Cheating Position. He and Eriksen and even the more obviously left-sided Son would flit about behind, alongside and in front of Kane in position-defying fashion throughout Spurs’ best work under Pochettino.

But we’ll call him right-wing here, because it’s the easiest direct comparison with a current United player given Shea Lacey has clearly been identified as the Great Young Hope currently making the step up to the first team.

Dele brought a youthful exuberance to that Spurs team and, while it’s asking a great deal for Lacey to be offering anything like the same level of tangible contribution as Dele – 22 goals and 13 assists in 50 games during that 2016/17 season – he could certainly have the same impish fan-favourite quality.

 

LW: Son Heung-min – Matheus Cunha
Cunha is already a couple of years older than 16/17 Son now, but there are some pretty clear similarities in profile. Generally operates from the left, but pretty handy as a second-striker or even filling in as a No. 9, and has both the requisite goal-scoring and goal-creating chops to offer a passable facsimile of Spurs’ Son, as well as the passion to drive the team on in difficult situations and a bit of a penchant for daft red cards despite being Not That Sort Of Player. Especially when you consider that Son is one of the very few Spurs players whose best years at the club actually came after the 16/17 highpoint for the overall collective.

Is Cunha as good as Son? No, he is not. But nobody said this was going to be easy or perfect.

 

ST: Harry Kane – Harry Kane
F*ck it. It really is the only way. There isn’t anybody else in the world who can do what he does now and was doing then. And that’s key, by the way; don’t let anybody tell you that Kane has suddenly developed all these extra all-round playmaker skills since going to Bayern Munich and getting Ballon d’Or attention. He’s always done all that other stuff as well as reliably scoring goals by the metric f*ckton. People just didn’t want to listen when it was Spurs fans telling them.

And you can ignore all concerns about the fact Kane will be 35 by the time we’re talking about this team coming fully to fruition, for the simple reason that he doesn’t actually age like regular humans or normal footballers. In fact, all the data we have suggests that if anything he’ll somehow be even better two years down the line than he is now.