Man Utd captain Fernandes joins Thiago and Lammens in out-of-form Premier League XI
Including Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes, these players have suffered a drop-off in form this season after stellar 2025/26 campaigns.
We have compiled an XI of Premier League stars suffering the same fate as Fernandes, who took home three major individual awards after guiding the Red Devils to third last season.
United ultimately came as close to Manchester City in second as their rivals did to champions Arsenal, but this season has been a completely different story for Michael Carrick, Fernandes and co.
Carrick has paid with his job and has been replaced by Mauricio Pochettino – probably five years too late – and Fernandes will hope to find a new lease of life under the former Tottenham Hotspur, Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea boss.
For now, he captains this XI of Premier League players who have suffered a drop-off in form in 2026/27.
GK: Senne Lammens (Manchester United)
It was between Lammens, Gianluigi Donnarumma and Robin Roefs for the goalkeeper spot, but the United No. 1 just edges out his competition.
Lammens has more errors leading to a goal (1) than clean sheets (0) in the 2026/27 Premier League and, after a year of looking safe and secure in the United goal, he suddenly looks shaky and unreliable when playing out.
He hasn’t been United’s worst performer by any stretch but, like most players here, the high standards he set last term are his downfall.
As for Roefs, he has kept three clean sheets this term and hasn’t been at fault for Sunderland’s rubbish form. Plus, he finished last season pretty poorly too.
Donnarumma has certainly dropped off, but a single moment in a game has ensured City victory on a couple of occasions, most notably his save against Manchester United in September.
CB: Malick Thiaw (Newcastle United)
Newcastle couldn’t get away with zero representation in this XI, but the problem we encountered is that they weren’t actually very good last season, so does anyone qualify? You could argue that nobody is safe except Lewis Hall, but you could also say that Hall was their only above-average performer in 2025/26.
Thiaw quickly adapted to life in England after joining the Magpies from AC Milan in the 2025 summer transfer window, but his early form has been nowhere to be seen for some time.
For all of Newcastle’s shortcomings this season, having a commanding, confident centre-back could solve a great deal; Thiaw has been far from that.
CB: Marc Guehi (Manchester City)
Perhaps a victim of timing, Guehi’s recent form for City has been miles off his usual high standards.
There were so many centre-backs under consideration – which makes Guehi’s inclusion feel even harsher – but he was bloody brilliant last season and his form under Enzo Maresca has been nowhere near good enough.
In the Premier League this season, Guehi has conceded one penalty and scored one own goal, while being hooked at half-time in the defeats to Aston Villa and Nottingham Forest.
CB: Omar Alderete (Sunderland)
It’s baffling what has happened to Alderete and several other Sunderland players this season. He was absolutely fantastic last term but has produced some truly astonishing lapses of concentration in 2026/27.
The Paraguayan defender was sent off in the defeat to Coventry, a fortnight after making an error leading to a goal against Bournemouth, and, without him, Sunderland went and beat Chelsea before the international break. He also made an error leading to a goal on matchday one at Ipswich. With only four league appearances this season, Alderete averages an error leading to a goal every 105 minutes.
RM: Harry Wilson (Leeds United)
Wilson is the only new signing in this XI, which probably makes his inclusion the harshest of all. That being said, Leeds fans might be concerned that they have fallen into the trap of signing a free agent after an incredible final year at a club. Willian to Arsenal comes to mind.
Wilson is yet to register a goal involvement in eight league appearances for Leeds and has only started three times, with his adaptation period not going smoothly.
CM: Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United)
Last season’s PFA Players’ Player of the Year, FWA Footballer of the Year, Premier League Player of the Season and Premier League Playmaker of the Season has been pants this season, with his six league goal contributions coming across two games. Give credit where it’s due: without his hat-trick and assist against Ipswich, United would have zero wins in 10 games, rather than one win in 10.
When things are going well for Fernandes, he is a joy to watch and United can even look like a competent football team. But when things aren’t going well, his sulkiness comes to the fore, and United suffer as a result.
As one win this season suggests, it’s not been sunshine and roses for United and their captain, who publicly criticised Carrick’s tactics following a humiliating 4-1 defeat to Como in the Champions League.
Pochettino brought the very best out of Cole Palmer in 2023/24, so we could see Fernandes return to his finest form under the Argentine, but he is a million miles off his 2025/26 form right now.
CM: Mikkel Damsgaard (Brentford)
Damsgaard was the flavour of the month for a period last season, but he is yet to register a goal or assist for Brentford in 2026/27.
The Bees are drawing too many games and we can’t help but feel an in-form Damsgaard would have turned a few of those draws into wins. Alas, he hasn’t been good enough.
CM: Morgan Gibbs-White (Nottingham Forest)
Forest might have turned a corner with their 3-1 thumping of Man City before the international break, but if they are to kick on, Gibbs-White needs to return to his 2025/26 self, or at least the player we saw in the second half of last season under Vitor Pereira.
We all know what Gibbs-White is capable of, but he has found it difficult to transition from life under Pereira to Oliver Glasner.
LM: Nico O’Reilly (Manchester City)
Another inclusion you could argue is harsh, O’Reilly’s minutes have been all over the shop since Maresca replaced Pep Guardiola, but there is no doubt that with those minutes, O’Reilly has not been great.
There is also the argument that O’Reilly isn’t fully fit after a gruesome 2025/26 that ended with a run to the World Cup semis with England.
Despite all of the reasons not to include him, here he is.
ST: Igor Thiago (Brentford)
Give him freedom, give him fire, give him an untelevised game at 3pm on a Saturday or he will retire.
With only two goals in 10 league games this term, Thiago is not on course to equal or better his 22-goal haul from last season. He has, at least, doubled his assist tally from one to two. Every cloud.
ST: Jean-Philippe Mateta (Crystal Palace)
There was also a reluctance to include Mateta due to his injury troubles, and the fact he is such a purple-patch player, but here he is, in all of his glory.
Mateta’s red card against Tottenham was the icing on a bitter cake but at least he has a new manager to work under and we’d be surprised if Thomas Frank doesn’t get a tune out of the big Frenchman.
READ NEXT: Alejandro Garnacho the new Harvey Elliott? Eight pointless loan moves