The famous England Ladder returns: Hall climbs again, White a huge re-entry, and four Bellinghams?
Thomas Tuchel, we don’t understand you. There, we’ve said it. And we’re not even talking about the Argentina game. Or at least, not entirely.
He’s been England manager for really quite a significant period of time now but we still find it hard to get a handle on him. The Ladder was much easier under Sir Gareth, is what we’re saying. You knew where you stood with Sir Gareth. Tuchel in his England reign thus far has managed to be both entirely clear and transparent about what he considers important and his commitment to backing the players he’s most recently picked while also retaining a devilish, mischievous quality for plucking a name out of thin air and just launching them into his latest squad.
We admire it hugely. But that, combined with another interlull awash with withdrawals and injuries both real and imagined, means it’s as hard as ever to truly pin down the England Ladder.
We’re sure by March there will be someone else who’s not on this one at all inside the top 15, and at least one player from the top 30 of this one who it seems absurd to even consider from a vantage point of four months from now, when England will, with a following wind, have just marched triumphantly into the last four of the Nations League and closer than ever to it acquiring real tournament status in the eyes of anyone other than Cristiano Ronaldo.
The last Ladder update from after the September/October megalull can be found here, with positions from that now defunct list in brackets below.
1) Harry Kane (1)
There are still a handful of easy ones up at the highest rungs (and, without wishing to spoil things for seasoned readers, the lowest rung) of the England Ladder, and frankly for that we are enormously grateful. Because below that it all gets very messy very quickly thanks to a ticklish combination of our own previous missteps, Thomas Tuchel’s hunches and changes of heart, assorted injury problems, and a deeply-held reluctance on our part to accept John Stones is no longer John Stones.
But do you know who is still Harry Kane? Harry F*cking Kane, that’s who. Two more caps to break jump-phobic goalkeeper Peter Shilton’s all-time record. Two more goals to extend his ridiculous goalscoring record. And they were both penalties just to tickle the fraud-sensors of those who still don’t quite trust the 93-goal striker with the Ballon d’Or on his mantelpiece.
Above all, the way he led the line against Spain was pure, uncut elite centre-forwarding. At some point somewhere along the line he is going to get too old for this sh*t and someone else will have to take over. But that time still just seems like a long way off. Incongruously, he still for now appears to be getting better at a time when minimising decline would seem the best that could be realistically hoped for. Ludicrous footballer.
2) Jude Bellingham (2)
And perhaps the most ludicrous thing about England right now is that they have a worthy Ballon d’Or winner in their ranks, a man who now has increasingly solid claims on being the best pure No. 9 of the age, and who is setting records that he could extend way beyond anyone’s future reach, but he is also not their best player. Jude Bellingham is their best player.
Lord knows we’ve been wrong about plenty of players before and will be again. The Ladder is a cruel business and offers no hiding place. But imagine if you were one of those journalists who genuinely thought England were better off going to the World Cup without Jude Bellingham because he doesn’t really play the UK press game and there’s no real prospect of getting a lucrative ghost-writing deal on his autobiography at the end of it.
Genuinely don’t know how those lads get through the day without remembering what they wrote about him and just cringing out a lung instead of trying to pretend they were probably what spurred him on.
Had, by his standards, a relatively quiet game against Croatia but he was simply magnificent against Spain.
3) Declan Rice (4)
Dropped out of the top three for the first time in what feels like it must be years and years after missing the September/October break through injury/utter exhaustion.
But he was back here and instantly reminding us all just how integral he is to this England side. Flawlessly controlled in the Croatia game, and we don’t think we’re speaking out of turn in suggesting England wouldn’t have emerged intact from that final half-hour against Spain without Rice’s nous and endeavour.
He’s up to 82 caps now, which also feels significant. England are an extraordinarily good side but they are in a state of flux in defence. We no longer know for certain that their first-choice keeper is the guy with over 90 caps, and we appear to already be in a brave post-Stones, post-Maguire defensive world. The experienced, battle-hardened spine of this team is now Rice-Bellingham-Kane. Who are also now their three best, most important and most experienced undisputed first-choice picks.
READ: How England pressed Spain into a tizzy for a golden hour of domination
4) Elliot Anderson (3)
Bit unlucky with the red card and wasn’t really the villain of the piece in any case. But what he has done now is offer someone a chance in the next international break and the all-important Nations League quarter-finals.
It’s a blow, because up to the red card he had spent this international break looking every inch the player we know him to be when required only to do the work of one high-quality midfielder rather than two, and appeared to be enjoying himself immensely.
5) Anthony Gordon (5)
Let’s not get too bogged down in the error for the second Spain goal, because happily for all involved everything turned out fine in the end there. So what turned out to be more important was everything Gordon had done up to that point, all of which was absolutely top drawer.
Three of the four starting spots in the ‘3-1’ at the top of England’s 4-2-3-1 are now absolutely locked down. It is to Gordon’s enormous credit that he has inked his name in alongside Harry Kane and Jude Bellingham. It really doesn’t seem that long ago that he was in a battle for a starting spot with Marcus Rashford that felt too close to call.
6) Ezri Konsa (9)
Returned to excellent effect against Spain after missing the Croatia game with a bit of knee-knack, and we remain comfortable with the idea that, all else being equal, Konsa and Guehi is Thomas Tuchel’s preferred combination these days. A combination of Guehi’s absence from these two games and both players’ club form in recent months does mean it seems only fair for a switch in their ladder order, though, even if it’s mostly for show.
7) Lewis Hall (10)
Seems an awful long time since he was overlooked for the World Cup. England kind of got away with it in that tournament, but there is so much to like about the Hall-Gordon left-hand side, where their time together in club football is of obvious benefit. They have a great understanding, but even without Gordon to really ram the point home, Hall would be making a truly compelling case right now to lock down a position that has been a bit of a problem for England over so many post-Ashley Cole years.
We make no apologies for being very happy at the idea of England’s left-back being a specialist left-back and not a converted midfielder or one of Gareth Southgate’s seven right-backs pressed into service on the opposite flank. We have a lot of time and respect for Kieran Trippier, but it was wearying.
8) Marc Guehi (6)
Missed this camp with a hip injury after coming off at half-time in Man City’s final game before the interlull. Hasn’t had the smoothest season at club level, but has been a near-certain starter for England for some time now, and nothing that’s happened in his absence over the last week suggests that has changed if he’s fit and available.
9) Jordan Pickford (7)
Used to be so easy, this. Pickford confirmed himself as England’s No. 1 at the 2018 World Cup as Sir Gareth Southgate’s quiet revolution took hold. And at no point since then has Pickford’s claim on the gloves come under any meaningful challenge. Until now.
Pickford and James Trafford have shared responsibilities across the six Nations League games, and both have done all that’s been asked of them. But while Tuchel’s public pronouncements have been cagey and couched, it’s hard not to read plenty into the fact it was Trafford entrusted with both games against Spain in a group where the quality was extremely front-loaded.
It didn’t, in all honesty, really matter who was in goal for the Croatia and Czech games. We still think it’s just about Pickford in front, but with ever falling confidence. At the very, very least these last two breaks have been about Tuchel laying the groundwork for a dignified and respectful changing of the guard with deference to all Pickford has done for the team over eight years of unprecedented major tournament sharp-end consistency for the Three Lions.
Pickford’s time as England’s starting keeper at major tournaments may well already be over. Still be nice to see him get to the 100-cap and 50 clean-sheet landmarks along the way, though. They’re both so close.
READ: James Trafford not yet England No.1 despite saving happy hour in Spain
10) Ben White (RE)
‘First-choice right-back’ might be the most astonishing twist yet in an unusual England career. We might be getting carried away, because it was only one game. But what a game. Surely nobody can have any problem with White on the back of that performance. Well, they will, loads of them, but never mind those people, they’re idiots who think he disrespected the Queen Mother or some such thing.
What a return it’s been for a man who slipped below Phil Neville in the last Ladder.
11) Bukayo Saka (8)
The evidence remains just about intact that when Saka is available, Tuchel will generally pick him to start on the right of England’s attacking quartet with what is now the fully established trio of Harry Kane, Jude Bellingham and Anthony Gordon.
Yet odd as it sounds to say about a man with five goals in his last four games for England, a nagging sense grows that he’s just not quite nailing it down in between injury absences.
He had a curious World Cup, never really catching the eye yet culminating in that hat-trick in the absurd 6-4 win over France in the pressure-free fun-factory of the third-place play-off. He scored twice in the 7-0 demolition of Croatia, but was the least compelling member of England’s attack that day for all that.
And now he’s injured again and giving other people chances to lay claim to a position on which he no longer appears to have such full control. It’s all a bit tricky to unpick, but for now you’d just about have him still inside the starting XI as we idly plot what suitable punishment Mikel Arteta might pay for breaking him so callously over the last couple of years.
12) James Trafford (13)
If not now, then soon. Soon he will be England’s new No. 1. England’s win in Spain wasn’t quite a game of two halves, but it was a game of two stages. Trafford’s contribution to the heroic second stage will not be swiftly forgotten. He is the first keeper to put Pickford under any pressure at all, and now appears certain to fully unseat him over the next 12 months or so.
We think Trafford will be England’s keeper at the Euros. We’re not quite so certain even now that this would be the case if the tournament was happening next month rather than in 18 months’ time. We expect this current job-share interregnum to continue for the next couple of international breaks at least. But change is coming, and it appears inevitable.
And we bloody love him for his normalness.
13) Morgan Rogers (12)
Has decisively lost the battle with Jude Bellingham for the No. 10 shirt, which is very much in ‘no shame’ territory. Isn’t as effective starting from the right, but is making a decent go of it nevertheless.
Has now at the very, very least established himself as first reserve in two of England’s key attacking slots which puts him on a pretty solid footing in terms of the wider squad.
14) Reece James (11)
We still think he’d be Thomas Tuchel’s preference at right-back, in an ideal world. But this is not an ideal world and James is the most infuriatingly cursed of men. Currently three weeks into a projected three-month lay-off after knee surgery, it is to be hoped for England and Chelsea and James himself that by the time the next England squad gather together in March he’s able to be a part of it.
Because we’re really not sure how much longer we can keep him up here, because we’re really not sure how much longer Tuchel will wait. He’s tough to read and his decisions on when to keep players, when to move on, when to promote them and so forth can be hard to fully work out; but what we do know for certain is how much emphasis he places on time and work done with the group in camp.
James isn’t the most high-profile Chelsea player to miss too many of those moments, but he might be the most important.
15) Jarell Quansah (24)
Keeps getting picked. Keeps playing quite well for large parts, right up to the moment where a massive f*cking ricket comes along and spoils it. But the ‘keeps getting picked’ feels the most instructive part for now, especially combined with England perhaps moving on from their old defensive guard quite decisively and the new guard being quite brittle.
The best ability is so often availability and Jarell Quansah is there. He always is. And now that appears to have made him England’s third-choice centre-back. Which is a vexing situation, really, and especially when he’s paired with Ezri Konsa. It’s just too confusing.
16) Dominic Calvert-Lewin (23)
Played in half England’s Nations League games, which is good. Those three appearances totalled 22 minutes, which is less good. But while it might not be great for the rest of us to see that the amount of pressure anyone is currently applying to Calvert-Lewin’s status as Kane’s back-up become roughly equivalent to the pressure DCL is currently applying to Kane’s starting spot, that is the situation and it is what it is. What do you want instead? Liam Delap? Will Lankshear? Semi-retirement’s Ollie Watkins?
Calvert-Lewin now occupies a curious space, neither challenging the starter in front of him nor being challenged from those stragglers behind him. Feels like that’s quite a rare status for a non-goalkeeper to acquire.
17) Myles Lewis-Skelly (19)
Replacing Harry Kane for the final 12 minutes of a meaningful rearguard job is, if nothing else, a show of considerable faith from the manager. He is inside the circle of trust.
18) Trent Alexander-Arnold (25)
He’s not quite completed the journey from indispensable right-back for club who couldn’t quite make it work at international level to indispensable right-back at international level who couldn’t quite mark it work at club level, but he’s getting there. He was England’s right-back for three of these six Nations League games, which is more than anyone else can say.
19) Nico O’Reilly (14)
Has been playing through pain at club level and the plan to take some rest and recuperation during the international break was almost certainly a sound one for the long term. But since he missed the last two games of the previous superlull, it’s fair to say the left-back picture has changed, and not in a good way for O’Reilly.
Any time you miss England games, you are not only denying yourself opportunity but handing that chance to others. Lewis Hall has taken his, and quite possibly with it the starting left-back spot for a good while to come.
The only consolation here for O’Reilly is that Hall is about the fourth or fifth player to have seemingly tied down the left-back spot. It is the one England position that has a long and proud history of coming untied.
20) Alex Scott (15)
Has been out of action since the last international break with a hamstring injury, a time mostly spent watching Bournemouth discover that maybe they should sell him for eleventy million quid because they seem to be coping pretty well without him.
Did look like he was about to truly set himself up as the next-cab-off-the-rank contender for any time either Rice or Anderson is unavailable. The latter’s red card against Spain means every chance that opportunity presents itself again in March.
21) Dean Henderson (16)
Has returned to the Crystal Palace goal but not yet to the England squad. He’s conceded 13 goals in five Premier League games this season – letting in at least two each time – and that is clearly sub-optimal. But also, we can surely all agree, not really his fault.
There have certainly been plenty of games where he’s kept it down to two or three goals conceded. But still. We genuinely might be approaching the point where sitting on the Brighton bench watching all the pretty football they play might be a better choice in every way up to and including international call-ups than standing in the Palace goal and watching abject f*cking nonsense unfold in front of you every week.
22) John Stones (17)
Injured on his first start for Inter in September and hasn’t made it back on the field since. Did get as far as the bench for the 2-0 win over Como just before the international break, so maybe there’s a chance he isn’t entirely in the past tense. We don’t want to give up on him. But, like Pickford now and Kyle Walker before, there exists the very real prospect of his England career coming up just short of the three-figure mark.
We think everyone is by this point relatively comfortable with Guehi-Konsa as the first-choice pairing. But we’d still rather see even a fading Stones on the pitch than just about anyone else England have tried in their absences over the last couple of months.
23) Marcus Rashford (18)
The season wasn’t exactly going to plan even before an extended lay-off with a hip injury. But he could be back in action for Man United very soon – perhaps even at Anfield at the weekend – and it would be no surprise to see him swiftly emerge as one of the big winners from Mauricio Pochettino’s arrival at Old Trafford.
There’s a long run now until the next break, and things could look very different then. In a good way. We think.
24) Djed Spence (20)
Back in the squad this time after injury and got himself involved for the final stages of the rearguard against Spain. Does all just feel in every way like the World Cup might have been just one perfect moment in time, though.
Where does he realistically rank among England’s defensive options on the flanks? It’s not in the top two on either one, we fear.
25) Kobbie Mainoo (21)
Had missed some football during the depths of Man United’s despair, but it does feel like that provided cover rather than a reason for his absence from this latest England squad. He played 30 minutes of the Chelsea game and the full 90 of whatever that nonsense against Villa was, so it does feel like had Tuchel wanted to pick him he could and would have done.
Tuchel did mention the football Mainoo has missed when asked for his reasoning, but also seemed comfortable enough saying Jobe Bellingham had outperformed Mainoo between the interlulls anyway.
It did feel more like a dropping than an enforced leaving out.
26) Eberechi Eze (22)
Sat on the bench throughout both games this week. Everybody loves Eze, and that clearly extends to Tuchel as well. But surely at some point he actually needs to be good again? Doesn’t he? Doesn’t he actually need to play some good football again somewhere at some point? England do have loads of other players for these roles.
27) Dan Burn (41)
Dan Burn’s England career cannot be killed by conventional methods. We’ll be honest, we thought it was in the past tense, but Marc Guehi’s injury opened a door and it was no surprise really to see Thomas Tuchel opt for Burn’s experience and enormity against the physical threat of Croatia on Thursday, and then deploy him to do Dan Burn things in the closing moments of the Spain game in a miniature yet stirring re-enactment of his unforgettable Azteca performance.
28) James Garner (28)
A reliable and dependable sort who has quite obviously secured Thomas Tuchel’s trust. But it does all feel like it’s going to be in a kind of ‘named in every squad between tournaments, but not for the tournaments themselves’ way. He’s a very capable footballer and clearly a reliable chap to have around the place, but it all just screams ‘standby list’.
29) Rio Ngumoha (31)
Thomas Tuchel is clearly a huge fan and listen, fair play.
30) Trevoh Chalobah (26)
What’s with this current trend for Tuchel’s defensive favourites to saunter off to Italy and immediately pick up injuries? We deserve answers.
31) Morgan Gibbs-White (30)
Bit-part roles in the first four Nations League games. Watching brief for these two. He’s brilliant, but he’s not Jude Bellingham. That’s a tricky puzzle to solve. Just incredibly hard to see how Gibbs-White can become more than an afterthought for England at this point, harsh as that may be.
32) Tino Livramento (27)
How many richly talented but permacrocked right-backs can one England Ladder contain before losing structural integrity? It’s at least two.
33) Liam Delap (44)
Who knows what might have happened if he’d scored two goals against Man City a week earlier. Might even have been in the actual squad. It doesn’t bear thinking about, and we just have to hope that his two goals against Man City were a flash in the pan so we can all get back to not thinking about it. We’ve said it before and we’ll say it again: if the answer is Liam Delap, then we don’t want to know the question.
34) Noni Madueke (34)
Tuchel described it as a ‘difficult decision’ to leave out a man who has been among the England manager’s most trusted players and whose greater opportunity on the right in recent weeks for Arsenal in the absence of Bukayo Saka seemed like it could straightforwardly translate to England too.
No such luck, though, and we now find ourselves wondering if Madueke might become that player who sort of drifts out of contention and thoughts between tournaments but once it becomes time to really commit and name a tournament squad again BAM there he is.
35) Jason Steele (35)
Might be closing in on the dream gig. Spending most of his life watching a really good club side play lovely football from the bench, and the rest of his time watching a really good international side play lovely football from the bench. Nicely done, sir.
36) Jobe Bellingham (NE)
I’m seeing double here. Four Bellinghams.
37) Jarrad Branthwaite (29)
Not getting a single minute of action when Marc Guehi missed the whole international break and Ezri Konsa the first game is a pretty clear indication of where he sits in Tuchel’s thinking at this time. And it’s not necessarily where we’d like him to sit, if we’re honest. Tuchel has spoken carefully but pretty candidly about how England’s style differs from that Branthwaite is used to playing with Everton. We’re taking a small liberty keeping him above James Hill, to be honest, given Hill was named in the matchday squad against Spain and Branthwaite was not.
38) Cole Palmer (32)
It’s starting to look like a marked card now. Would Palmer be in a full-strength squad picked entirely on footballing ability? Yes. Is that enough on its own given the quality and depth of alternatives England possess? Nope.
England just have too many good players in the attacking positions for room to be found for one who, for whatever reason, doesn’t seem to vibe with this manager. Really not sure what could happen now to change that dynamic.
39) Adam Wharton (36)
We have to be at least slightly real and simply accept the fact that it’s now an awful lot of midfielders who’ve been called up by Tuchel since he last handed Wharton a go. He was already behind the obvious starting pair, and Kobbie Mainoo, and Alex Scott, and Myles Lewis-Skelly. Now we must consider James Garner and Jobe Bellingham to be ahead of him too. It’s a lot.
40) James Hill (NE)
We’d have liked to see him get a run out, because England are starting to look light at centre-back. Dan Burn is Dan Burn and can only legally be deployed under certain strictly-regulated conditions and Jarell Quansah gives us The Fear.
It would be lovely to think there might be another one of those players out there who just comes along quietly and looks like international football is the place he was always meant to be, like Elliot Anderson did in midfield a couple of years ago. We’ll have to wait, now, and who knows what the picture will look like by March. Not us, that’s for sure. We can’t get our head round what it looks like now.
41. Josh King (42)
42. Rico Lewis (33)
43. Dominic Solanke (39)
44. Harvey Barnes (40)
45. Will Lankshear (46)
46. Phil Foden (37)
47. Jarrod Bowen (38)
48. Ethan Nwaneri (43)
49. Ollie Watkins (45)
50. Phil Neville (50)