Man Utd circus bottom of Premier League club ranking for manageability

Mauricio Pochettino stats graphic
Manchester United are the most unmanageable club in the Premier League

Being a Premier League manager at any club is obviously very, very hard but at some clubs, their circumstances make it very, very, very hard.

Sure, you get paid millions of pounds a year, but being a manager means having to deal with 25 inflated egos and being permanently at risk of being labelled a ‘fraud’ after any given weekend.

Make a bad choice and you will have an owner who thinks he knows more than you despite his background being in petrochemicals and a working environment that is not conducive to winning trophies.

Here then we present our ranking of the 20 Premier League clubs by how hard we reckon it would be to manage them…

 

20) Manchester United
Notice we said how good to manage and not how good to get sacked from.

The main positive for the last umpteen United managers is the big payday you get from your inevitable dismissal, but being the actual manager is an overall awful experience.

Let’s start with expectations versus reality. Expectation: win the league. Reality: you finished 15th 18 months ago.

Not since Ferguson was in charge have United been a serious title contender and yet that is the expectation from a large chunk of their billion+ fans because their brand demands it.

Now let’s get to the boardroom. It’s a mess, it’s full of yet-to-be-proven-competent men who know more about petrochemicals than penalties. Having an external businessman in charge is ultimately not a killer problem but when they insist on getting involved, it very much is.

Ratcliffe has appointed Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox to oversee the football operations. Berrada at least came from Manchester City but largely in an administrative role. Jason Wilcox was at Southampton.

You’ll get money to spend as the club goes deeper into debt but even that may dry up as funds for a new stadium are required.

And last but not least, the squad. There is some good in there but there also a lot of dross on very high wages. It’s hard to see any United player who would be signed by another Big Six club.

Premier League manager rankings: Will Pochettino, Frank or anyone else ever knock Carrick off his perch?

 

19) Nottingham Forest
Volatile owners are the opposite of what you want as a manager and every person that has stepped into the Nottingham Forest dugout in recent years has had to deal with the wants and whims of Evangelos Marinakis.

Ignoring his legal shenanigans (look them up for yourself), Marinakis has expectations far higher than the club should demand.

When Nuno Espirito Santo dared to qualify for the Europa League rather than the Champions League, Marinakis stormed the pitch to berate his manager.

No wonder then that their relationship fell apart. Successive managers came and went, resulting in Forest handing a king’s ransom to Oliver Glasner, who is also starting to bristle with the hierarchy.

It’s also worth bearing in mind that Marinakis is not even technically an owner – he put his shares in a blind trust after it looked like Forest could get Champions League football – but his influence is undeniable.

Forest should be happy simply establishing themselves as a Premier League club again but Marinakis wants results now.

 

18) Sunderland
Sunderland’s owners are very ambitious but do not always put their hands in their pockets to match that ambition.

To be fair to them, they spent big last summer but did not do spend again ahead of their difficult second season, so their current position in the table should not be too much of a surprise.

Rumours of a possible Regis Le Bris sacking have existed even before the end of last season with an unexpected European qualification keeping him in the job, but expectation versus reality seems a little off-kilter as it stands.

 

17) Chelsea
The Chelsea owners have simmered in more recent years but the temptation to run the club as a large-scale Moneyball project is still there.

Buy low, sell high is the natural philosophy of a private equity firm but that just doesn’t really work in football.

The Chelsea manager is trying to live up to the expectations set under the previous ownership without the capabilities of the previous regime. Roman Abramovich seemed to know when to get involved and when to leave it, even if he was criticised for rapid firing, but he gave every manager the tools to work with.

Chelsea managers get money to spend but rarely on the very best players and the focus is mostly on youth over experience. Chelsea have the youngest average squad in the Premier League and yet challenging for the title is expected.

 

16) Manchester City
Any other season and they would have been far higher but being Manchester City boss is so hard now because you are the public face of a guilty verdict of over 100 financial charges.

The Manchester City CEO and chairman have not appeared in front of the media to answer questions while the Manchester City manager has been wheeled out numerous times to find out how many different ways he can say no comment.

On the pitch, you are having to fill the shoes of Pep Guardiola but you are at least given money to spend with an already good squad.

Expectation is high but the manager is backed. Take away the charges and this would be a dream job.

 

15) Crystal Palace
As Oliver Glasner can attest, being Palace manager means having to lose your best players and not really spending the money to replace them.

In 2024 they lost Michael Olise and bought Ismaila Sarr for a third of the price. When they lost Eberechi Eze, they bought Yeremy Pino. They did not sign anyone when Marc Guehi left in January. This past summer, their most expensive purchase was Dwight McNeil.

Palace are not huge spenders and unless your scouting is very, very good, that means you will slide down the Premier League table pretty sharpish.

As for the expectations, Glasner’s trophies raised it to something more than just survival but they do not have a squad capable of anything other than that. Good luck, Thomas Frank.

 

14) Tottenham Hotspur
Managing Spurs comes with the added question of how you shake off an existential crisis that has been at the club for at least a decade, if not more.

Spurs have the shiny stadium of a Premier League champion but they have never been a Premier League champion. It’s been more than 60 years since they won the top flight, and yet that is the expectation, or at least the hope, of the club.

The Tottenham board are not exactly the finest minds in the game but they will at least spend money. In fact they often overspend; but it’s not your cash so what do you care?

The problem for Tottenham is that they are in the London ecosystem and so get compared to Arsenal and Chelsea, two clubs with far more recent success. A good season would be Europe of any kind, a great one would be Champions League, and yet we bet some in the boardroom would only be happy with a title win.

MORE ON SPURS ON F365
* Newcastle appoint Mourinho and Conte joins Man Utd in cost-cutting measure as ex-Spurs coaches reassigned
* Man Utd, Spurs, Newcastle need strikers; every Premier League club’s January priority
* Pedro Porro reaches decision on next club as staying at Tottenham is ‘out of the question’

 

13) Newcastle United
Newcastle are bumping into the glass ceiling of PSR (or SCR) while the owners’ ambitions are for something far higher.

The Saudi sports project has always been quite volatile. It was quick to try and take over the sporting world and the demise of LIV Golf shows just how quickly it can pull away too. That is because the PIF is used to getting instant results.

The Premier League have limited how instant those results can be and there are questions about whether PIF has the same interest.

Newcastle’s inability to move forward saw a number of their key stars leaving and the replacements were more for the future rather than plug-and-play ready-made Premier League players.

But expectation is that Newcastle will be challenging for at least a Champions League spot. Fans are a little more patient but they too are frustrated by the stunted progress of late.

 

12) Fulham
Being Fulham manager has always been quite a cushy gig.

You get to live in west London, you play in a nice stadium on the River Thames and the fans are – how we can say it? – more placid than the kind of passionate fans who light flares outside a training ground to protest a 1-0 defeat.

There’s also not a huge amount of expectation, surviving in the Premier League is good enough, but they never spend a huge amount of money.

Their net spend over the past five seasons is around -£200m, putting them 11th in the Premier League, and that is starting to show with a squad that looks very average.

 

11) Everton
The current uncertainty surrounding the ownership is why Everton are this low down.

There are a lot of perks to being Everton boss; they have a nice new stadium and are on about the third rung of the Premier League food chain.

But the Friedkin Group announced last month they were ready to sell the club having stabilised the Toffees’ finances. Perhaps that explains why Everton had a terrible transfer window and are one Thierno Barry injury away from disaster.

And what exactly is Everton’s expectation? It’s been a long, long time since they were league contenders and almost as long since they were even competing for one of the top spots.

As other clubs have improved, Everton have stood still to become a mid-table club at best or a relegation candidate at worst.

But fans obviously want more as their neighbours have had it far better for far too long.

 

10) Hull City
You will certainly be working for one of the more eccentric owners but while some seem like egomaniacs, Acun Ilicali appears to at least be coming from a place of passion.

He is clearly very fond of the club – who else would be live-tweeting transfer updates in the medium of flag emojis? – and is willing to put his hand in his pockets to help the team.

He is, though, a bit unpredictable. He only took over the club in 2022 and yet has gone through five managers. They have also had previous transfer embargoes for missing payments to other clubs.

Now in the Premier League, we will see a test of Ilicali’s patience. Sergej Jakirovic has earned the right to be relegated with the club given how he got them here.

 

9) Leeds United
When you’re comparing anyone to Massimo Cellino, it is going to feel like an upgrade, but 49ers Enterprises have done a lot of good work.

They are one of the more low-profile Premier League owners but have recruited well to give the Leeds manager a very good squad and now they are looking up the Premier League table rather than down it.

For a manager, expectations are always very high for this football-mad city, but in a reasonable way, and you have a passionate fan-base backing you.

 

8) Coventry City
If you were drawing up the characteristics of the perfect owner, you would get pretty close to Doug King.

Having suffered under SISU Capital, who had them playing at Northampton and Birmingham grounds at various junctures, Coventry fans looked like they were facing their choice of Mike Ashley or an American investment fund when King appeared out of seemingly nowhere to buy the club.

Since then, he has done things that benefited the club far more than they benefited him. He cleared £31m of debt when he took over and later purchased the CBS Arena, marking the first time the club and stadium was owned by the same person since 2005.

On the pitch, he has invested in the squad which resulted in getting the club back to the Premier League. And he’s done all of this in three years.

King clearly cares about the club and sees it as a project. Expectations are relegation, with anything else a bonus, but he has proven himself to be a smart operator when it comes to running a football club.

 

7) Ipswich Town
After local businessman Marcus Evans’ pockets failed to keep up with the increasing cost of football, Ipswich were taken over by an American investment fund who had desires to reach the Premier League.

Even those in Suffolk had doubts about such an ambitious plan for a club that was in League One at the time but it ultimately came true.

But more than just on the pitch, the work off it by the owners has been just as impactful. Ipswich have a shiny new training ground, making it one of the best in the country. The stadium has been revamped and the culture around the club has changed from ‘that’ll do’ to ‘we can do that’.

They are also not afraid to spend. Ipswich set a record for the amount of money they spent in the summer as they look to stay in the Premier League at the second time of asking. Expectations are high for the ambitious owners but the manager has an ideal environment to work in.

 

6) Brentford
Brentford are a club that is moving in the right direction and every decision is one that fits the overall club ethos.

How much you enjoy that depends on your style as a manager but if you are someone like Keith Andrews, it gives you the freedom to focus on the players.

Phil Giles is the sporting director and helps the club to move in a consistent direction and they are now a firmly established Premier League outfit.

 

5) Aston Villa
Nominally on the same level, Aston Villa is clearly a better club to manage than Newcastle United.

They too have hit the financial glass ceiling but have actually replaced their sold players with a mix of experience and youth talent.

The Villa squad is easily in the top half of the table, probably sitting around the sixth best, and the Villa board have shown a willingness to spend.

It also seems like a very well-run club with everyone moving in the same direction. How much of that is down to the genius of Unai Emery we will see once he eventually leaves…

Premier League manager rankings: Will Pochettino, Frank or anyone else ever knock Carrick off his perch?

 

4) Bournemouth
The so-called Bermuda Triangle, a nickname we hate but can’t think of anything better, exists because they are three very well-run clubs.

Bournemouth pip Brentford on the list because they seem more capable of challenging higher up the league.

Andoni Iraola and the club’s smart scouting pushed them into the top half and Marco Rose inherited a very strong squad.

They are amongst the most aggressive pressers in the league and have players with real quality. They also have what looks like a future superstar in the form of Eli Junior Kroupi.

Cherries managers are also typically given time. Iraola failed to win in his first nine games but there was never any real talk he was facing the sack.

 

3) Liverpool
FSG have been very good owners for Liverpool, turning them into a Premier League and Champions League-winning outfit.

As a manager, they give you pretty much everything you ask for. Liverpool have spent huge amounts in the past two seasons and even with the uncertainty of Jeff Bezos, comes the added investment.

The expectation is to win the league so the bar is high but for a Big Six club, it is a remarkably stable environment to work in.

 

2) Brighton
“Hi Brighton manager, it’s the board. Unfortunately we have sold our best players to Chelsea for £200m but don’t worry, we’ve signed two replacements who are actually better for 4p.”

If you’re the Brighton manager, you will feel like a cog in a machine but in a good way. Everyone who works at the seaside club seems to be competent, not something you can always say about a football club, and if they have picked you, chances are they believe you will fit the system perfectly too.

You do have to accept losing your best players but Brighton’s scouting is probably the best in the Premier League. It’s so good that they already know who will replace you.

 

1) Arsenal
It’s the perfect club to be the manager right now.

A lot of that transformation has come under Mikel Arteta and the Spaniard has helped build a club that has high-quality players, the right kind of attitude and the money and reputation to keep those players.

Expectations are very high with trophies now the accepted pass/fail rate but you have great players and a brilliant pulling power with owners that are willing to back you to achieve your goals. Their patience with Arteta also shows they are not going to give you the boot at the first sign of trouble.

READ NEXT: Alejandro Garnacho the new Harvey Elliott? Eight pointless loan moves